Playing videogames is completely non productive and like all hobbies that’s what makes it based. “Wasting” your time and potential from a capitalist lens is good and should be encouraged. Life should be enjoyed to the extent we are ethically able. Production should not be the goal
i believe you will come to find that the purpose of all life is oboemaxxing.
The oboe is as productive as videogames, broadly, but I’d argue anything thats broadly fighting entropy is productive even as a hobby. I think the understanding here, that productivity is just what you do in the context of wage labour or similar isn’t that great. Cooking, fixing shit, bugfixing open source projects, anything like that. I’d go further, it’s probably good for one of your hobbys to be something like that.
Wasting time like life isn’t a gift to be enjoyed. What? Is your life some kind of obligation? Some kind of resource to squander? God’s going to want some kind of P&L report at the pearly gates? If God’s an author then they’ll be there excited to see you again, “So, what did you think of the sunset? Pretty cool, right?! I was experimenting with purpose, love, connection, and joy. What did you think?”
Most of the time you can sit in a park at sunset even if you’ve gotten a pretty raw deal or you’ve fucked up pretty bad.
If we’re attributing value, I like to think that, within capitalism, a good hobby is one that fosters connections and cooperation between groups of people.
Games that develop cooperation and combat social alienation and anti-social behaviour? Based.
Any other type? Life-waster at best.
I disagree solely because some of us need quiet by ourselves hobby times so that we have the energy and capacity to be intentionally present socially. Not every hobby can or should be social. As someone who loves social activities I absolutely need my own quiet time or I can’t be who I want to be with others
I agree with the sentiment, and I feel the same way most of the time (work has been intense and I have social anxiety).
I don’t know enough games to give good examples and make my point, but I guess a “good game” category wouldn’t necessarily be built on multiplayer strategizing or whatever, but would also include stuff like Stardew Valley and Don’t Starve.
I’m thinking of a specific feeling, the one I used to get when I was in a Tolstoy’s short stories binge. There’s this warmness that I rarely get from any other literature, and I think it mostly came from the connections between the characters, or between me and the characters. I felt warm, included, even hugged sometimes. Then, back in real life, connecting to other people was infused with this magic that I can’t explain.
The reading itself wasn’t (immediately) a collective effort, but it was instrumental in pruning anti-social behaviour in teenage me.
Trying to describe how gaming was different than playing music made me realize how similar they could be, I agree it has a huge dependence on the game itself. Playing music generally fosters cooperation and teamwork and the use of intellect/mental energy that is superior to what the average western capitalist-derived games evoke. Good music can soothe emotional distress and enhance class consciousness. Good games can do this too, and bad music can have socially negative effects.
As a hobby, either is fine. As a skill for personal and social development, I would debate that music is superior, but that particular games could probably be just as adequate. In my own experience, even the best games do not ease my mind or enhance focus like playing music does.
Art in general has a possibility for both of these (social and skill development) that is way more intense than with video-games IMO, and I think this is the threshold that the latter still didn’t cross towards an art form.
Of course, there’s different types of art just as there are different types of games. Making art can also be alienating and toxic, but there is still nothing quite like playing music in a gathering of friends, or getting together to make paintings, a silly short film or even a sand castle at the beach.
By the way, some of my fondest memories are of a bunch of friends going to someone’s house to play GTA San Andreas, FIFA or Need for Speed for the whole day
so reading books is wasting your life too i suppose. i think you’re painting vast amount of art with a broad brush.
so reading books is wasting your life too i suppose
Some books can be, or even outright toxic (and this is also for games, music etc). Reinforcing or propagating social alienation is the criteria I’m using here. I think I made myself clearer on this in another comment.
Man who has 1600 posts with no likes on Bluesky angrily tries to explain why other people are wasting their time by having fun
Haha imagine making 1600 posts on some random irrelevant social media
it’s relevant to me, dammit [cries]
I’ll have you know I’ve accrued dozens of upbears over the years!
I don’t post here on my “free” time, I post here when Im “outside”.
I have never fully understood [why my children prefer to stay with their mother and play video games over the weekend instead of coming over to my apartment and watch me play the oboe]
Time enjoyed is never wasted

spoiler
Just make sure you’re actually enjoying yourself
-someone with 2k+ hours in Destiny 2
That’s true, but there are enjoyable things that improve you and enjoyable things that don’t. I usually feel better about the time I spend on the first type of things.
That’s cool! Just remember that feeling joy and forming happy memories is justification enough!
What a hot take, just like any hobby the reward is the enjoyment lol
Actually the reward is that political power grows out of being the very best at pokemon battles.
Hexbear and Bluesky are indistinguishable in the way most users are liberals and also extremely susceptible to baitSo take the phrase ‘video games’ and swap it with the word ‘work’ or ‘job’ or ‘career’ and see if it still applies.
I get better at existentialism.
They targeted musicians.
Musicians.
Mournful melody on the oboe plays
I am saddened
Both are hobbies, what’s the difference. I hate gamers btw.
I thought we were friends! Nah, I’m kidding, I generally hate gamers even though I myself am one…

Uhm I actually get better AT videogames, which brings me one step closer to being a professional e-sports player
You’ve obviously never attended an oboe battle.

your gif is broken

it’s sublime how perfect the looping is
I mean, you could make the same argument about books? “I can learn things from a book”- yeah, and you can learn things from video games. You can also learn nothing from a book.
I think people go “video games” and think it’s nothing but Call of Duty, meanwhile you have Expedition 33 out there making people argue about unreliable narratives, abuse of authority, grief, so much fucking grief. etc
Art and experiencing art is like one of the main if not the main, points of existence? Telling our little stories and experiencing other people’s little stories in return to grow and further understand other people and our surroundings.
Not even getting into puzzle video games. Like, the amount of research that has been done on Tetris is mind-boggling.
Actually, I do feel better when I’m having fun, believe it or not. A good whack to the face with my poleaxe, and their horrified screams immediately fill me with joy

You have no poleaxe available. What is your next polearm of choice and why?
That depends: Against armoured opponents I’d choose a Luzerne hammer or an Ahlspieß, but against peasants nothing beats a good halberd, although those 16th century fauchards look really adorable too
Bec de corbin, of course.
The world saddest song on the world’s smallest oboe (piccolo?)
Don’t know what it would be, but not a piccolo. Oboe uses a reed but a piccolo is like a tiny flute, no reed.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piccolo_oboe
Thesis, antithesis, synthesis
I was very pleased seeing that to have it immediately confirmed that they are also called piccoloboes

Is this a DBZ gestalt character?
piccoloboe
Reading these in my head in Squidward’s and Patrick’s voices
idk there is 100% a difference between spending your time playing video games and engaging in something like playing the oboe… it is okay to play video games, of course, but it is much more comparable to watching TV than playing an instrument. You aren’t really doing anything.
I’m playing Rimworld and it’s hardly a passive experience, even if it is a story unfolding before you.
Games aren’t all just murder simulators. Some are crimes against humanity simulators.
“I’ll just play phoebe chillax on adventure story, I’m not trying to micro that hard. Let’s even pick temperate forest”
-timber wolf is hunting biscuit
-disease: plague
-blight
timber wolf is hunting biscuit
F
True but it’s also one of those games that you can just actually let run on their own and see what happens.
There’s definitely a range to how closely people want to engage with it, but for me personally the goal is always to turn it into the astra militarum. I get super into production, logistics trains and airdrops, specializing vehicles, standardized equipments and loadouts, ranks… This is not to go against what you said, but to illustrate the other end of the spectrum.
Funny, my colonies also tend to drift towards a form of siege socialism - lots of bunkers, fortifications, weapon emplacements, with main exports being painkillers, medicine, cybernetics, and kalashnikovs
No joke my first thought was Rimworld
The virgin oboemaxxer versus the Chad Wii Bowling enjoyer
I think if somebody was like hilariously good at wii bowling I’d actually find that more impressive because I have a frame of reference there. What do I know how hard it is to play the oboe or how to tell whether somebody is any better at it than obviously hitting the wrong notes.
What’s the difference?
In the basic sense they can be very similar, you might play games as a performance like streamers, but I’d say the difference is typically people game for their own entertainment but they play music for artistic expression and entertaining others as well as themselves. Games can be intellectually/emotionally stimulating as well but rehearsing and performing music has a different impact on the psyche and development on average. I think both are fine hobbies but people don’t as often go to concerts to watch gamers for example, music has a special role in the emotional worlds of people that gaming doesn’t fill.
Artistic games could potentially fill this role, but as a gamer and a musician there is a distinct and obvious difference between the engagement with the two for me, it’s hard to describe it exactly because of the ways in which the two can be similar. Sometimes racing games in particular do remind me of the feeling of playing in a concert when I was in orchestra.
Not really, both require effort and you do improve with practice. If I put in 100 hours playing super smash bros I’m going to be better at playing it just like if I put in 100 hours to playing oboe. Only difference is our society values oboe skills more then smash skills for arbitrary cultural reasons.
You don’t improve on watching tv, if you watch 100 hours of TV you don’t get better at watching tv, it’s completely passive.
































