It’s 2026! It’s almost 2027!
What the heck is wrong with a group of people that all love and support each other? It sounds great!
If people didn’t judge it so badly I would have realised that it’s what I want a lot sooner.
EDIT: I haven’t read the comments yet why are there so many… oh… oh no
Should I have prefaced this by saying I mean healthy, non-patriarchal polycules? I thought that would have been obvious. The fact that people defaulted to thinking I meant Mormon style with one dude and a bunch of waifus is kind of what I meant when I said people get the wrong idea about it.
I mean, don’t get me wrong. I’m not mad because struggle sessions over unexpected things are pretty funny. But it’s a little disappointing too, I guess.
I suspect some of them are confusing polyamory with mormon polygamy, which is actually very weird and bad
And then there’s polyarmoury, which is a different third thing
That’s where you have multiple collections of weaponry
Such as fear, surprise, and an almost fanatical devotion to the pope
my polycule & i share a love for the second ammendment
Polycule with nukes hell yeah
juche-cule
When your rimworld colony gets raided while everyone is working outside you’ll be thankful for the polyarmoury
Or polyarmery which is like Dr. Octopus or General Grievous or Goro from Mortal Kombat.
I gots two hands, I can holds two guns. Why limit myself to just one?
Like any relationship, it’s bad if it’s one sided and patriarchal.
Also doesn’t help when a famous weirdo claims he’s polyamorous as well. Sam Bankman and friends didn’t do you guys any favors.
The anglo-capitalist culture has been heavily discouraging any kind of mutual support since birth. Even shit like “sharing” and “helping” are predicated on the charity of the individual owner or the helper. The only acceptable mutual relationship is the most atomized possible version of the family.
Also they are jealous cuz we fuck
Actually they are jealous of how much they THINK we fuck because they are also encouraged to think of any other form of relationship, even friendship and family relationships, as inherently sexual
yeah, it’s a lot of monogamous people assuming i am constantly fucking. tbf i do have group sex pretty often, but that’s not because i’m polyamorous that’s because i like group sex.
Well, duh. Oh course it’s weird, any form of amory is weird. This is a volcel website, we have to be voluntarily celibate to post here. It’s in the rules

Shit it was a trap! We’re all about to be taken to VolCel Jail by the

I don’t know what exact comments you’ve been reading and I’m sure there are some people just being bigots, but there are people I know who have these opinions because of a misunderstanding of what healthy polyamorous relationships actually look like.
Several times I have seen a situation play out with friends who have a habitual problem of partnering with shitty people. They have married or are living with emotionally abusive men who want to sleep with multiple women and still benefit from having someone to clean their house and raise their children. Several women I know have been locked into these circumstances where they are financially dependent on a man who then manipulates them into an ‘open relationship’ when it is not something they are actually comfortable with.
I know this isn’t what polyamory is, but a lot of straight monogamous friends and family members have a perception of polyamory as just being an open relationship that someone has been coerced into. Which I think is a relatively easy thing to talk them out of, because it’s not from a place of hate for the concept, but a reaction to a harmful thing they have witnessed.
Yes, that’s what I thought it was too so I never considered it. Only after seeing examples of healthy poly relationships did I start thinking “Oh, I think I get this now…”
I think you just hear less about the healthy ones, since the one sided “open relationship” dynamic is so common.
I’m fine with it but I have been annoyed by really sanctimonious poly people who seem to believe they’re enlightened and free of emotional burdens imposed by society etc and anyone not doing it is an emotionally immature possessive dorks. I’m sure this is just a few among many, I would have to imagine most poly people wouldnt even bring it up unless it was relevant. But I have known people who made it their personality and clearly believed themselves to be superior. I’m just like, not here to judge anyone’s relationship that is age appropriate and generally happy, but this sample bias is admittedly amongst people I know who can be super insufferable in general.
Personally it just ain’t my thing cause i’m not very social. I’m open to it, but even with friends there’s like one that I hang out with and do stuff, anyone else are just people im on friendly terms with and see when I see and catch up. And then theres scheduling…
You have a majority group that often marginalizes the minority group. Are you really surprised the minority group slings it back?
We have to listen to people like you call us super insufferable and say some make polymamory their entire personality as if there aren’t large swathes of the population who have made monogamy their entire identity. Are you really surprised that a group of people you describe as super insufferable would characterize the group you belong to negatively?
Didn’t say a whole swath. I specifically said people who i’ve had personal experience with and even pointed out that I may have a bad sample group of people who are sanctimonious about just about every part of their lives. I don’t really see how poly people are marginalized either, if you could give examples with material consequences i’m happy to hear them out, it is very possible I have a blind spot. But being poly as far as I can tell isnt really an oppressed minority group in and of itself. A lot of poly people are queer and or trans and those are oppressed groups so the overlap can make it seem that way. But aside from from my observations fairly mild social stigma, I don’t really see much marginalization going on.
Would you argue that gay marriage being illegal counts as a real form of opression with material consequences? If so, have you noticed that it’s outright impossible for poly people of any gender to marry more than one of their partners? Honestly, if you’re missing things that are this obvious, i’m not surprised you find discussions with polyam people difficult, but maybe you should not blame it on them.
It is like veganism. It is ethically a better option. No one has figured out how to say it well yet though.
This is exactly the kind of posts they’re talking about.
Not eating corpses is totally the same as being in a relationship with multiple people.
Actually you are closer to it than I am. Veganism is about finding a better way to live and avoid unnecessary harm? Is this not so? Similar, poly is about finding a better way to live and avoiding unnecessary harm.
As monogamy and carnism are part of white supremacy culture this analogy is way better than I have any right to claim
How is being poly reducing unecessary harm? Is it immune to creating new types of harm? If so how and why? How is it at all equivalent to millions of animals dying every day strictly for carnal pleasure?
Monogamy and carnism are part of none white cultures. They arent exclusive to white supremacy.
It’s not a better way to live. It’s just a different way to live. You are allowed to do things that are outside of societal norms without pretending it makes you better than everyone else.
Calling monogamy white supremacy is wild. TIL I’m not brown but a white supremacist for being married to one person.
I feel like feeling a sense of superiority over a neutral distinction is closer to white supremacist mentality than only having one romantic partner but I’m a simple monogo
It’s cultural enforcement in our society is such. I feel that is well supported.
He’s full of shit anyway because the most patriarchal societies were polygamous. Are we seriously entertaining the idea that a society where women could be concubines are somehow freer than what we have now? I guess some random Tang emperor with thousands of concubines is the model of what all polyamorous relationships aspire towards.
That’s getting into territory i think is bad faith. Your historical arguments are sound but I dont sit well with the conclusion
Pretty sure OP’s talking about polyamory not polygamy. Also pretty confident that polyamory and polygamy aren’t synonyms.
Are you seriously equating polyam people with “some random Tang emperor”? What kind of bad faith bullshit is that? And then you make up scenarios in another thread about how this could lead to the CIA doing polywashing to justify imperialism and how that’s a totally real concern we should take seriously. Please go and touch grass, this is disgraceful.
deleted by creator
If people were good at monagmy this wouldn’t be an issue. Most people have trouble with it most of the time. Look at the divorce rates, spousal abuse rates, rates of cheating. If it was socially possible to chose another way many people would do better with this seccond option.
Address the thing I was replying to plz. You are changing your argument.
Removed by mod
I even said in the post that we have not crafted the science of not sounding like assholes when we say it.
As a vegan, I disagree and this is precisely what I was talking about.
And yet just as a carnist disagrees that does not invalidate the math.
Fuck off, dude.
Reasonable. And yet, I am unfortunately making valid points
No you didn’t
Look at what marrage culture did to our parents ans grandparents and tell me the system is good and it works.
What math?
That enforced cultural monogamy needs alienation, causes significant social harm, and is something most peope have to stress over maintaining. It is a system that is not working.
What math?
it is wild seeing people going full reactionary over polyamory in this thread. what the hell.
I mean, we all have a liberal inside us so it isn’t suprising especially if we are as a group reddit proximal so that complicated relationship stuff hits a nerve here often.
good bait comrade

Are we for real doing bait posting on hexbear? And that’s fine with you as a mod? The fuck?
Vietnam flashbacks to the israel flag struggle sesh
whatever this is it’s nothing compared to the zionism exposed during that
never forget
was called a “holocaust emoji”In before someone equates monogamy and Zionism
My partner was promised to me 3000 years ago
Mormons pushing a ballot initiative to legally define marriage as “one manifest destiny, one womanifest destiny”
monogamy in the imperial core does stem from settler-colonialism so it’s unfortunately not all that far of a stretch.
Lol, no. There were native American tribes that practiced monogamy as well as polygamy and polyamory.
I don’t think it is as serious as you are making it out to be. And I don’t think the actual OP (DirtOwl) made the post as bait. You chose to get into a 10 comment chain argument with them (CrawlMarks) prior to me even looking at this thread.
I’m not gonna just wholesale nuke comments & ban people from chat because they managed to get someone to reply to their ridiculous comment(s) on a thread like “Not eating corpses is totally the same as being in a relationship with multiple people.” thinking they were being 110% serious. You can disengage with them at any time, you didn’t even have to reply to them in the first place!!!
Dirt owl is fine, it was a sincere topic and @CrawlMarks@hexbear.net is supposedly sincere. Saying ‘nice bait’ and a rat salute after implies that it’s bait. Therefore I should treat it as such. It is perfectly reasonable to think someone would have this point of view and based on the rest of the conversation they do hold these views. So why muddy the waters?
Sorry if you thought I was muddying the waters.
I don’t think you should be reading any “nice bait” comments as a definitive statement on whether or not someone is being sincere. I, and a non-zero number of users on this site, have definitely said ‘nice bait’ or “:bait
” as a reply to something that was said/posted seriously in the past because we took it as bait.My original comment you are so mad about is no different. I took CrawlMarks’ original comment as bait given the fact that it caused you both to immediately start arguing about whether monogamy is more or less inherently harmful than polyamory in literally less than 2 comments.
“If people were good at monagmy this wouldn’t be an issue. Most people have trouble with it most of the time.” you can’t convince me that when CrawlMarks typed this he didn’t have a smirk on his face because I have a smirk on my face reading it. Maybe he is being sincere, I dunno, but either way it is bait for someone in some way (maybe bait for me to wind up being forced to post a “We’re getting rid of the bait emoji, and here’s why” thread in SelfCrit I guess)
He could also just be a crank. I dont know this person and have seen super wack takes here. Posting bait in someone’s sincere thread isnt appropriate either way and as we have just concluded it seems to be a matter of interpretation whether it is or not. Either way, i tend towards trusting people here. If I wanted to second guess every post I read I would go anywhere else online. I shouldnt be treated like the asshole for taking it as sincere. Are you gonna post a ‘U mad bro?’ next? This is juvenile bullshit that I come here to avoid.
I do belive it but I was also being glib. More freedom vs less freedom, falgsc, etc. etc.

Removed by mod

If this is ragebait, you are a bad person and shouldnt be posting here.
This is not ragebait. Jury is out about my quality as a person. I mean, here are some of the few people I respect enough to try to have a debate nerd session with.
Ive made my personal conclusion
About weather or not people should have the freedom to explore non-patriarchy based lifestyles?
I’m sure lack of exposure is a huge factor in my opinion here, but I always imagine the friction points of a relationship would become much more difficult with more people involved. There really aren’t relationships where no mistakes are made. If I’m in a monogamous relationship sometimes one of us is overly emotional or a jerk in some way, talking it through and calming down is a necessary process but it’s very difficult. There will be times when it’s just one person at fault, but the distribution there isn’t an even back-and-forth, often one person is having a hard time and making a few consecutive mistakes. The other person’s turn for that might be later. One person has to be understanding and forgiving, and the other person has to have faith in that forgiveness.
Trying to imagine myself in polyamory, if this week I’m taking my turn to be difficult and in an emotional place, but with (example) two partners instead needing to point out my mistakes several times in a row, I think I’d be extremely prone to feeling ganged up on. I’d wonder what’s being said when I’m not in the room. Anytime I question, rationally or not, am I less loved then they are, that would hit my insecurity. Surviving would take more security in myself than I’ve probably ever felt at any point in my life.
The opposite direction would feel like garbage too - I feel agitated with someone, another partner feels the same emotion, we need to restrain and temper our displeasure so they don’t feel isolated and ganged up on. Then there will always be the question “how much are they tempering their true feelings in this conversation?”, another roadblock to building trust.
The key difference is that in monogamy, there’s an understanding that both partners share the isolation of any disagreement. The ten-year relationship I was in gave me a lot of experience with what provides emotional security for me and helps me build trust, and when I try to contemplate polyamory I see so many potential pressure points to impede that feeling of an inseparable bond, that feeling that we really are in this together, from ever fully taking root. For me personally, I don’t think my emotional health could ever be strong enough for me to thrive in that situation.
So yes, it does seem weird from the standpoint that it would require everyone involved to have much stronger mental health than I ever have. I’m sure there’s a really big number of people out there who fit that description, but that doesn’t make it easier for me to understand.
With all of that said, something that’s crossed my mind when thinking about this is that being alone with one partner and strengthening your bond because you’re both absolutely fawning over the person not in the room is a really heartwarming fantasy that I’ll never get to live out.
You formulated my thoughts in a way I couldn’t. I barely know myself. Trying to understand an entirely different world in the form of a person you’re intimate with requires so much work, at least for me. Multiple people at the same time? I feel like that’s beyond my emotional capabilities. I guess everyone has their own understanding of love and intimacy. I’m always thinking of that person I’m intimate with, their presence is always in my mental background. Like, I love my parents, but I don’t think about them 24/7 the way I would a lover. Not sure if this is what other people are like in relationships. Maybe it’s problematic and unhealthy behavior. Maybe I’ve been programmed to think in this manner and it shouldn’t be like this
I guess everyone has their own understanding of love and intimacy.
I think this is probably the difference. What I was writing was hard to articulate, but it was hard because to me it feels almost self-evident. Being honest, I don’t believe the reason that polyamory works for some people is that they and their partners have an emotional strength that I don’t. Those traits that make me too fragile to thrive in polyamory are same ones that have given transparent evidence to partners that the relationship means everything to me, that I am putting a lot of emotional effort into resolving disagreements. That’s how bonds have been formed and strengthened in my experience.
I think it’s more likely that my idea of love is how I dream for it to be for me and their idea of love is how they dream for it be for them. We all just tend to assume that when we’re speaking the same words with someone then those words must have the same semantic meaning, but subtle semantic differences could be the difference between what feels self-evident to me and what feels closed-minded to someone else without either one of us being wrong.
This significantly describes my position also. Relationships are hard, and while I can see some positive draws to polyamory, the lack-of-trust fears would be amplified in me tenfold.
Monogamy comes with a huge behavioural practicality - voluntary exclusivity is a constant demonstration that your partner is dedicated to making a life with you included, in some form or another. That gives you more reason to invest time and effort into reciprocating. It is an endless show of trust.
More power to anyone who can get by without that huge-ass boon, polyamorous comrades rule, but I couldnae do it.
You’re raised to basically have strong feelings of possession, jealousy, etc. towards your monogomous partner in our culture. These reactions aren’t like, instinctive the way we think, it doesn’t need to be like that, but when every role model you know has a set of highly negative reactions to non-monogamy, it’s going to feel weird to see people who aren’t so invested in “possessing” a person, divesting intimate relationships from any sense of ownership or exclusivity is scary because of it.
Them Christians done fucked with us all for too long
Personally, I would love to live in a big house with a bunch of cool folks like y’all
I have been turning this over in my head a bunch and I’m convinced it’s something that will need to be rooted out before we can become the best organizers we can be. Maybe I’ll make an effortpost soon
Tankie in the streets and anarchist between the sheets
it me
exactly. it’s not that fucking difficult of a concept
Hold the fucking phone

Looks like you’ve got some explaining to do “owl.”
@Dort_Owl@hexbear.net I waited until the thread was buried to confess my dark shameful secret. Every result said that burrowing owls were highly ployamorous and I ignored your pfp and posted it anyway for the gram. The hexagram. May God have mercy on my soul.
tagline worthyWe are the posters on the wall
I’m more concerned about the “claim territory” part.


They play Risk.
Many such cases
deleted by creator
Bizarre that this seems to be controversial topic in leftist spaces, including this one. Cuba’s Family Law would like to have a word with some people.

Some of this might be my fault
it’s not your fault, you just didn’t cater to mononormative fragility lol
some people really want to own others & take a very reactive view to anyone who personally chooses to opt out of that dynamic.
I am actually pretty mad at this thread, enough that I opened up a whole text file and have been writing and deleting the first paragraph. One opened with ‘the fuck is wrong with you people?’ but that might be too belligerent. What compels people to go into a thread about how bad it is that people still find polyamory weird just to agree with the people being complained about? It’s the same thing this website will happily dogpile on a liberal for doing in a vegan thread.
I’m technically poly but I’m also some variety of aro ace or something so it hasn’t come up often but I do keep it to myself because you can see it in people’s eyes when you say it.
I just don’t understand monogamy personally. If I love someone and they love me, what’s the issue as long as they’re safe? I want the people I love to enjoy themselves and I don’t see why that needs to be exclusive.
hey, fellow poly aroace! i was positively miserable until i figured out i was poly. now i get the parts of the relationship im cool with (not the sex or romance stuff) and my partner gets to still get that from their other partners, and i get to be happy for them about it, all while not contorting myself into something im not.
<3 <3 <3
aroace polyamory gang rise up
deleted by creator
Have you never felt jealousy before? I’m envious lol.
What do you mean by jealousy? That can mean all kinds of things from possessiveness to fears of not being enough to worry about your partner’s safety to disgust to FOMO to envy to seperation anxiety to not getting enough attention to a bunch of other things. And whether you’re poly or mono, it makes sense to not subsume all of that under one vague label like “jealousy”, but to understand what you feel that makes you jealous and what you would need to make that better so you can talk about and resolve it.
Which i recommend doing regardless of whether your partner is actually seeing the person that is causing you these feelings or not. The feelings are still there, and they are a sign of emotional needs you have and it just makes sense to adress that. The trick to being poly isn’t never being jealous, the trick is to understand yourself and your needs and to communicate them openly, and that is something that also helps in monogamous relationships. That mono people have an easier time ignoring it doesn’t mean they should.
I’m jealous of people who have stuff that I want and don’t have, not really for anything else
that’s envy not jealousy.Then no, I guess not. My friends have other friends, which is great, and I love my friends. I don’t get why it would be any different for a partner. But apparently I’m pretending to be an enlightened being or something.
This is one of those things that’s going to come up in a much worse way in 3-6 months isn’t it
In theory, I am, but in practice, I am not. Me and my wife always had a pretty strong relationship but it’s actually gotten stronger since becoming poly. The shit people say when we talk about it is…fucking something. And like I get it to some point, I had to work through some abandonment issues and the knowledge that some fucking wedding promise wasn’t going to mean she wasn’t going to cheat on me and abandon me. But…I worked through it. I have absolute trust in her.
People will say things to me like, “Oh, I need to know that I’m the most important person to my partner,” and shit like that, and…it honestly gives me the creeps. Then there is the paranoia “Oh they just want to do poly so they can find their next partner.” Hell, my wife’s shitty ex literally tried to do this and said this when it was over. It was fucking wild but that’s a whole other story. There is just a lot of people out there that desperatly need to work through their shit, and we live in a society that is actively pushing for people to not fix their shit cause it makes them better consumers.
I do understand people, though who say “oh I just don’t have time for that” cause honestly, same, I have a QPP but they live in the same house as us. I honestly would love to date and stuff but I just do not have the energy or time right now. Let alone the funds. Almost all my money goes to garden shit or takeout because I don’t have the energy cause the docs can’t figure out what the fuck my autoimmune disorder is. But that is also a whole other story.
There is just a lot of people out there that desperatly need to work through their shit, and we live in a society that is actively pushing for people to not fix their shit cause it makes them better consumers.
100% this. monogamy makes alienation easier to take hold.
we are in a bubble.
personally i’ve never met a polycule i wanted in on
Personally I’ve never met a monogamous couple I wanted in on
same
polycules are only one type of polyamory though. you can have multiple partners who aren’t necessarily each others’ partners
polymer chains are still molecules

that is the statement of someone who has never experienced the joy of solo polyamory & i weep for that because my life is awesome
I know exactly one polycule (if three people can be considered a polycule) I’d like to be on, but they are not taking new members. And also my wife wouldn’t approve.
>I know exactly one polycule (if three people can be considered a polycule) I’d like to be on, but they are not taking new members.
Oh you also know my personal friends Nick, Stav and Adam?
Three people could be considered a polycule
To be poly is to reject society. Happy well adjusted people tend not do to that. So the self selecting group in question are marginalized persons at best. This is also true of us as comunists.
I find it weird because I am an emotionally and physically possessiveremovedthat absolutely could not share a person under any circumstances. I struggle to handle my own emotions in a monogamous relationship, there is absolutely no fucking way I could handle it without turning into a wreck and tearing apart every social connection at the seams.
Same for me. I think people are either wired like that or wired to be poly, with most people being the former. Like some people have a compulsion to have multiple partners, and others are sickened by even just the idea of being with someone other than their partner or their partner cheating on them, and neither of these groups can comprehend the other. And the distrust cuts both ways, obviously, with poly advocates often belligerently acting like they’ve uncovered some pure, natural state of being that’s superior, and that any unwillingness to take part in it must come from indoctrination and oppression.
And I mean I can give the people saying poly relationships can even work the benefit of the doubt, and accept that they are wired in a way that they can be happy like that and only like that, but after more than a decade of exclusively socializing in queer spaces and seeing a lot of poly arrangements, not one of which worked out and which were almost always just one shitty person churning through, preying on, and ultimately throwing away less experienced people who naively think they’d be fine with the arrangement, it’s really hard to accept even the hypothetical idea that maybe it does work sometimes for some people.
There’s definitely no indoctrination or oppression here. If i fall for someone and any amount of insecurity is allowed to creep in I become a really fucking awful person, I do not like myself as that person. I become unable to prevent myself from certain manipulative behaviours. I become clingy. I become a mess. I have to work very very hard to avoid allowing anything that would promote that insecurity because it is absolutely lovely as long as that does not creep in.
I categorically would not be able to do that in a poly thing. Not possible. I have nothing against the people doing it, I find it weird and don’t understand HOW they do it, but I absolutely can not do that. It would be incredibly unhealthy for me and for everyone else involved.
Same for me. I think people are either wired like that or wired to be poly, with most people being the former.
And there are the aces who are wired like neither. People just need to accept that everyone’s wired differently and move on.
But like, you see how mathematically that breaks down yeah?
I love threads like this after things fizzled a bit and people trickle in with non-specific meta-commentary and get upvotes from every involved party(including me)
It’s like when the sun comes out but it’s still raining a bit
































