Hasan used to be against screeching “tankie” at people like the liberals. This shit is the exact same thing but the word has been swapped to ultra.
He’s using it the exact same way, it’s a barrier, it exists to tell people “do not move any further left than me otherwise you’re an ultra”. He’s not useful to the left anymore if he’s doing this shit, it’s identical to Vaush even if he is less grotesque in behaviour.
How dare you correctly criticize MY socdem parasocial relationship.
My comfort politician is feeling vulnerable right now 😔
I believe he also said anyone who refused to endorse Graham Platner was an ultra
He pulled out LWC to justify voting for Platner too! 🙏😭
I can’t confirm but he always seemed to be skeptical of plattner and left it up to others. He mentioned his nazi tattoo and sus background a lot. My take was that he never endorsed or directly promoted but also never totally denounced either. I think the majority report and Ryan grim were way worse with denying how terrible plattner was
He never endorsed Platner in a formal sense and he is always very quick to remind people of that, but I’ve personally watched streams where he was calling detractors “troop exploders” (derogatory) who had no belief in the ability of people to change and reform, despite Platner very clearly not reforming with respect to the military. He was unambiguously out there defending Platner in some respects that were obviously misrepresentations of the issue, so him acting like his hands are clean and he wasn’t trying to launder the reputation of that proudly murderous freak who turned out to still be violent to helpless people when he got home is disgusting.
I don’t know about all of the claims people make about this, but he was harmfully wrong about Platner from early on, however much worse those others were on the issue.
I’ve personally watched streams where he was calling detractors “troop exploders” (derogatory)
Okay you’ve convinced me, this guy sucks. Who the hell thinks exploding troops would be bad?
I think it would be a correct criticism of a real but tiny minority of leftists who think that being a veteran, no matter what you do after or how you try to help move humanity forward despite the damage you did in your past, should be discarded from consideration for any type of leadership position. Those people have a harmful moralism that damages progressivism for no benefit, but again are a vanishingly small minority and rarely who Hasan is actually talking to.
The problem is that he conflated that group with people who think proud veterans who are pro-US military should be discarded from consideration for any type of leadership position, because those people are correct.
Basically, it’s a trick to turn a very obvious leftist stance into an absurdity, refute the absurdity, and then declare victory over “ultras” in the name of common sense and pragmatism. It was really disgusting to see him try to gaslight people into believing in the rehabilitation of a braggadocious serial killer when no such rehabilitation took place.
Plattner never struck me as the kind of guy whose judgement any leftist should leave up to others. I do believe in reformist justice, i think even a murderer can be successfully rehabilitated, and that does include former troops, but that does not just happen, that takes work on part of the murderer that i have never seen any signs of from Plattner. When you’re an ex mercenary with a Totenkopf tattoo, you seriously gotta deliver and prove you have set out on your redemption arc. And i would argue that even then, the correct treatment of the person undergoing rehabilitation is not to run them for a political office that sets them with a cushy job and financial security for life and the power to make political decisions that directly relate to the crimes they did in the past.
And what did we see from Plattner? What were his positions on the military and foreign policy? Opposing military aid to Israel is obviously a correct and in fact mandatory position, but it appears as a pandering smokescreen when the rest of his takes are stuff like “we need better recruitment and be more picky about which imperialist wars we get involved in”, that is too obviously damning in light of his own biography. I was not surprised when the reddit posts surfaced, i was not surprised when the SA allegations came out, something like that was obviously going to happen with a person like that, and i am not saying that as claiming i am some kind of human can opener who was supernaturally knowledgeable about the guy, for example it still shocked me to hear he was stationed at Abu Ghraib, that is some supervillain shit i do not take for granted even with ex Blackwater. But i’m saying that calling him out and not buying any of his lies was the consensus on this site and that it would be the obvious conclusion for anybody who understands how imperialists run and justify their wars nowadays. When you have a Graham Plattner biography, you need to come clean about so many things. You have to be in full confession mode when you’re a public facing person with that history, you have to demonstrate real will to change, real insight into how you failed personally and politically, and that could do some good in US society, it would obviously not be as good as giving a voice to his victims, but it would be a start. And he exhibited none of that ever. None.
And i can’t say if Hasan was as reluctant to endorse Plattner as you claim, others disagree vehemently with that, but even if you’re correct, not immediately denouncing the oyster farming old money Blackwater nazi tattoo guy is at best incredibly poor judgement of a guy who is the most obvious red flag collection. And it’s a case of poor judgement that was very widespread among media and political counseling and organizing folks in the US, and afterwards everybody wrote it off as “we made mistakes in vetting him”, and if Americans want to show the tiniest shred of accountability for what their empire does to the world every single day, they should not let that fly.
He did the the same with Fetterman in 2022. Didn’t learn shit in 4 years.
That’s fair. It was obvious to me that a totenkopf tattoo would be disqualifying from any position of power or (moral) authority. The left media in the US is so focused on elections that any candidate that says the magic words gets immediate buy-in especially with the GOP steering the ship into an iceberg. At least with Hasan his equivocation was unprincipled and problematically I don’t think any “leftist” creators suffered any reputational damage for it.
Kavernacle knew there will be people like you in the future. That’s why he made this video. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=v8BfC26dffo&t=0s&pp=ygUMUGxhdG5lciBsZWZ0
really good video that shows the centrality of anti-imperialism as the primary contradiction
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
Wouldn’t it be easier for the cognitive dissonance part of your brain to just give in to correct critiques and stop parasocially defending Hasan and instead just detatch your ego from his and look at this objectively?
no no no it’s out of context! You have to listen to 800 hours of his streams before you understand, it’s actually good to be a succ dem left-puncher. If you attack him you’re just like Destiny!
You have to listen to 800 hours of his streams before you understand
It was already a chore sitting through half an hour of him bumbling through Disco Elysium, i genuinely can’t understand what hexbear sees in this guy.
like half of this website isn’t marxist or communist, they’re bernie succs who pretend they aren’t. A majority of this website was all in on Bernie 2020 and AOC. A large plurality also vocally supported Mamdani. Some were even dying on a hill for Platner lmao.
These people are fundamentally supporters of Democratic Party entryism and social chauvinism. One gets 1 freebie as a newb to the left, but if one is still repeatedly defending this faction after multiple cycles of these betrayals there’s no excuse. Lesser evilism is a disease.
That’s possible. Even if they aren’t, i know that clinging to media personalities who serve politics as entertainment can be hard to get rid off, but i seriously recommend spending less time with streamers and video essayists and podcasters and journalists who all have systemic reasons to suck. It’s a bad habit to overconsume their slop. People talk about pipelines and yeah, whatever, but anybody who is here should be out of that pipeline by now.
Agreed. There comes a time in every socialists political journey where they will have to pick up some books, read some geopolitical analysis and maybe even join a party. Entertainment gets some people to the left in the pipeline? Ok I guess, but if they just stay there clogged in the pipe never developing past watching streams, cheering for elections and donating money then they are still liberals in effect and the pipeline hasn’t gained us much.
Mamdani
he was my last compromise, i was skeptical that he’d get anywhere but in the sense of assassination in place of betraying his “socialism”. no election cycles for me from now on. in my defense it was before i got here
Electoralism has its place as a means to demonstrate its own failures. It can be a useful tool in that sense, but holding office within bourgeois institutions is a dead end. Chokwe Lumbumba was an actual radical mayor in Jackson Mississippi and he mysteriously died 8 months into office.
Electoralism as socialists in a socialist party has its place. Not electoralism and entryism into the democrat bourgeois imperialist party, which does not have its place
i mean you might as well hang a D next to your name if you’re running for county comptroller or whatever. getting ballot access is hard and you can skip some steps by affiliating with an existing party in all those places where somebody is otherwise running unopposed.
trying to reform the party or thinking you can make it socialist is delusional and a waste of effort.
Wrong
And the other half is utterly blackpilled.
Another terrible take from a bad poster. You are just repeating Hasan’s critique of everyone to his left being an ultra doomer etc because we don’t see value in your electoralism mini-game
Am I a Bernie succ for understanding that social democrats are not going to fundamentally change the system, while still being somewhat excited that there is a growing movement of people who want and advocate for socialist policies?
Depends. When these social democrats are correctly skewered for their cowardly and Zionist actions and statements do you defend them? Turns out, many users here did!
He’s aggressive, confident, hot, and has some genuinely unfathomably despicable enemies, and a lot of his streaming is oriented around spoonfeeding the viewer in a way that takes almost no mental effort.
That and demsocism in general has appeal to some people on the basis of them being able to celebrate electoral victories, so it seems like it has a lot of appeal to say “this, this thing that on a micro level can often be pretty doable and you get to feel rewarded and validated if you buy in, this is the way to really change things”. Communist organizing can also feel rewarding, but it’s not nearly as ready-made and it’s sometimes much more hazardous.
Have you considered he is hot though :^)
Yeah that’s another part i do not get about this, i genuinely can’t comprehend seeing men that way. I hear it about him all the time and it just doesn’t register.
A significant portion of humanity is attracted to men, across the entire gender spectrum. I think it’s a bit like not understanding why some people enjoy baked potatoes. Different tastes, I suppose.
Yes, i am aware of a significant portion of humanity finding men attractive, it is kind of inescapable in our culture to be confronted with it and that is in fact at best puzzling and in some cases even lowkey disturbing to me. In extreme cases, it can get downright threatening.
A matter of different taste is which women i find more attractive than others or which ships i prefer. This isn’t about whether i like baked potatos or prefer hash browns or yams or rice as a side, it’s more like being served a chunk of clay, looking down on the inedible lump of earth that has been plated and served to me for reasons i find indecipherable and wondering why everybody else at the table is tucking in. And when i leave that restaurant, i step out on the street and see billboards advertising granite pizza and gypsum casserole and feldspat roast and when i go to a restaurant that actually specializes in serving plants, there still is stone on the menu. Now don’t get me wrong, there are many animal species that eat clay, i have heard of pregnant women developing a sudden fondness of geophagy, so on an abstract level i get why there are beings that do want to eat mineral matter i find wholly inedible, and i am not judging anybody for that, but it still clearly does not ever register as food to me.
Look, I was mostly talking in jest. That said, I look at this through the lens of a pansexual person and I genuinely have a pretty varied and wide-ranging taste. I just happen to love and adore people regardless of their gender. Their gender is a factor I consider and I certainly have preferences, but in the end, to stick with the food analogy, it’s all food to me.
I mean, I can be horny for Megan Thee Stallion and Willem Dafoe despite them being completely different kinds of beings. And I mostly consider that an advantage. No disrespect to people with a more limited palate, of course.
If you were to attack Hasan for being too far left, then you would be just like Destiny.

26 now damn.
It all started with that smile, that damn smile…
Zorhan Mamdani as the Teletubbies sun
who keeps sheepherding people into the the
do nothing
corporation. You’re damned right we want the pendulum to swing ULTRA instead of window dressing and civility wing of genocidal Empire of Epstein

Oh boy time for another Hasan struggle sesh
When will he reach horse guy status? I no longer wish to remember he exists.
Horse guy?
And my roommate plays him as background noise so forgetting him isn’t an option for me lol but it could be worse so I won’t complain
Edit: oh shit did you mean Mr Hands?
V*ush
Lmfao yea I forgot all about that horse guy, good riddance
but they told me that guy was the tankiest antisemite :(

Got me some chocolate, put on the E gel and came to Hexbear to see “86 new comments”.
I’m ready for the

Hasan Piker is a dumbass twitch streamer who makes money streaming, stop minding him
As much as I would like this, we have a bunch of people here who parrot him, so I think it’s justified to give especially this specific criticism.
They shouldnt do that and also stop giving your money to a twitch streamer jfc
People who glaze him should stop calling themselves Marxists.
Agreed, the only issue is that the supposed “communists” keep bringing him up and defending his endorsements of Democrats and repeating his arguments regarding entryism and collaborationism. They vulgarize socialism and drag themselves right and they don’t even realize they’re doing it
I dont really care about that actually, i just think hes a twitch streamer, twitch streaming is gross and your opinions shouldnt come from a guy like that
i actually do care about supposed socialists who put marx in their name going around vulgarizing and distorting things in leftist spaces with democratic party nonsense. Hasan isn’t the cause of that type of behavior, it long predates him, but he’s certainly an integral part of that ecosystem right now and a central rallying point for these types.
this is the correct take, who gives a shit about this bozo
He genuinely believes every critic of his liberal zionist darling Brad Lander and Jeffries-supporting socdems like AOC and Mamdani has been sent by BadEmpanada. See how he immediately switched the argument into ‘trying to create bigger Market share for other content creators’ instead of addressing the actual issue that is his liberal zionist apologia and dem party entryism?
He wants all of his audience members to think his left-wing critics are anti-electoralism, when in reality they are not. Like Marxist theory suggests, they advocate for running independent, socialist candidates under a working class party instead of liberal democrats.
Piker might be under the impression that the DSA constitutes a working class party or at least is a predecessor to one. Which seems a little misguided at best and deliberate sheepdogging at worst
This is the primary issue. Does the DSA constitute a ‘working class party’ or the predecessor to one? For now, the DSA is folded neatly into the body politic of the Democratic Party, which is not a working class party, and from what I have seen, the Democratic Party has been much more successful in pulling the DSA right than the DSA has been successful pulling the Democrats left, as police reform is completely off the table now.
Does the DSA constitute a ‘working class party’ or the predecessor to one
Neither. It represents a labor aristocrat social chauvinist organization, and will always do so as it is a private organization not a party that can be seized
I am in no position to disagree with that statement.
The issue is, is it possible for us to communicate that position effectively to your average DSA person or even someone not steeped in leftist politics? Can we pipeline effectively to a working class party from the DSA, or is the DSA a complete dead-end?
DSA is not a dead end though. It leads directly to the Democratic Party.
Is it a dead end for socialist involvement though? To which the answer is, kinda? But it takes disillusionment with the DSA apparatus, which can take years, and if they keep winning elections, it could take even longer.
Yes.
Best case scenario it becomes so contradiction riddled that it implodes on itself during a moment of acute crisis. I don’t see it having any particular utility and those who endorse the “dirty break” entryism cope are better off instead just organizing labor, forming/joining an actual socialist/communist political party or doing weatherman type behavior in smaller cells (disavow). Even if it’s just electoralism via a socialist party, that’s better than whatever the hell these people think they’re doing in DSA
implodes on itself during a moment of acute crisis
PSL beat them to it
Hence why I put “form” as an option for a socialist party in the US. Would be great to have one without the baggage of trotskyism, zionism, marcyism, nepotistic family own structures like PSL that ossify from the top and fail to meet the moment
or doing weatherman type behavior in smaller cells (disavow).
Don’t do adventurism
The weathermen did more then 100% of people on this website.
I’m not saying to do adventurism. I’m saying that it’s still more useful than wasting your time in the DSA endorsing democrats, that’s how low the bar is, it’s negative and harmful. Do you think half the western left publicly dying on a hill for Platner was harmful or helpful? Wouldn’t it be better if they just shut the fuck up and definitely didn’t do any crimes?
DSA was started as an anticommunist, liberal zionist org to serve as an alternative to socialist parties that were pro-USSR.
Oh I am well aware. I have been following this stuff for over 12 years now, and was personally involved in the org back in the day, and I had some friends in high places, though most of them are no longer there.
I don’t think the DSA has ever advocated for a non-Democratic candidate outside of Sanders. It’s awfully suspicious that there has never been a candidate fielded by the Green Party, CPUSA, PSL, and so on that the DSA would endorse. In a race with a Republican who’s 100% going to win, the DSA would rather sit this one out than nominally support the Green Party candidate.
Until DSA starts endorsing independents or candidates from other parties, calling them sheepdogs for the Democratic Party is completely justified even from a socdem perspective.
I’m under the impression that the election systems Lenin was talking about were different from the US and didn’t have as many rules effectively soft-banning 3rd parties from existing. So I don’t know if Lenin would even advocate for what the DSA is doing. He might advocate for something more widespread like tenants unions being the basis for organizing.
He was still just crassly quote-mining Lenin without engaging with any of this. Even if we imagine Lenin actually would agree with Hasan’s stance (I strongly doubt this), Hasan did nothing to establish that.
And besides the fact that Lenin would clearly call Hasan a phrase-monger, I also think that we should probably be more concerned with what is true than what Lenin would think if we gave him a time machine. My complaint is Lenin as a historical figure being misrepresented to make an unjustified political point rather than Lenin’s authority with respect to how we should form our conclusions.
deleted by creator
“you are against progress”
yesBecause we’re trying to build a pipeline, so this means we need more surface level people to hide their power levels, right?
RIGHT?!
EDIT: Just to clarify, this is a joke. While I do unironically think there needs to be some outreach to libs…I’m just coping here tbh.
I swear it will work this time just one more time we’ll be able to trust suckdems to not be Rosa-killing libs trust me I swear this time it’s real!!! Please ignore all the anti-communism and liberalism and that other thing he totally owned that other streamer and donated money once!!
I don’t really want to get into how we can’t actually copy fascist pipelines 1:1, where they simultaneously say that the Holocaust didn’t happen and it was a good thing that it did, but genuinely the idea that Hasan is doing that and when he quote-mines Lenin to try to conflate entryism with any electoral participation that it’s all a guileful ploy that his recruits are meant to eventually disbelieve is cope.
You can make an argument if you want that in this respect he functions as part of pipeline even without meaning to, but he doesn’t seem like a very efficient one since he goes on and on and on attacking his left critics as “ultras” who were probably sent by Bad Empanada and so on.
You can also make the argument – and he himself does – that he is operating as a pipeline on the basis of the fact that he has beliefs that he generally does not publicly acknowledge and he is trying to get a pipeline to those beliefs, but for the same reasons as mentioned before it is clear that many things which we would call pretty basic positions are things he genuinely opposes and are not part of what he is trying to encourage even indirectly.
who were probably sent by Bad Empanada and so on.
Well that one is sort of on Bad Empanada for being so fucking terrible a person and thus tainting what few correct positions he held. I hate all these people, but that one the most.
I think you’re removing Hasan’s agency in this by blaming it on BE, however much of a shitbag BE is. It’s Hasan’s responsibility if his political project has a fraction of the seriousness that he alleges it has to be able to separate his beef with BE (and BE being a shitbag) from the truth of falsity of those mostly pretty obvious claims.
No I mean it is cowardly of Hasan, but also BE and fans have actually been going after him over other more silly shit so they created that defense for him.
These people are all deeply unserious and I do believe BE is more harmful for being the more reactionary of the two. Sure BE supports some good things but he also is a weirdo little gremlin freak nobody likes he’s anti-china he’s transphobic, he’s ableist, and he is genuinely a terrible person.
Bad Empanada supports the axis of resistance and Palestine. Should we throw that under the bus because he’s unsavory? Allowing the position of streamers to “taint” correct positions is a terminally online you problem, not a real one. You are letting inconsequential streamers determine your political stance, even if it’s in a negative and reverse-psychology way. There is no reason at all to give this power to them. Critique them when they are mentioned, ignore them otherwise is the universally correct policy.
Bad Empanada is a contrarian reactionary and nothing more.
I don’t hate him because he is “unsavory” and that is a fucking insulting way to frame our distaste for his transphobia, ableism, racism, and chauvinism.
He’s a piece of shit Strasserite-esque asshole.
“Unsavory”… Go fuck yourself frankly. Trying to do some fucking freshman level psych 101 psychoanalysis on why I hate this piece of shit is also real classy.
Threaten to beat him with a hammer already so we know who this is
Edit: oh sorry, your favored weapon was a tire iron
I’m saying he’s a loathsome transphobe reactionary and not to take him seriously. I also said I despise Hasan. They’re all just streamers and yalls obsession with these people is unhealthy.You are the one with the unhealthy obsession here, letting your political positions be distorted and determined by these inconsequential and meaningless figures that you give outsized importance to
Pipeline to the democratic party hell yeah
We’re building a pipeline!
The pipeline:

Yeah, just like SPD circa 1919
Yes, I am an ultra
in the US overton window? yeah pretty much





























