Some awards show controversy had House House disclose possibly the lightest possible LLM usage you can imagine. Anyway it’s a Bad Game now.
Amongst all the glut of genuinely vibe coded slop, inventive AI reverse engineering and the plain ol’ realities of LLM living in modern software development, I get a bit frustrated seeing it all grouped into one essentialized category.
The common understanding of what AI even is, is at an all-time low, imo. People see ‘AI code’ next to a game title and imagine someone prompting claude for 20 minutes, and these sorts of stories and over-the-top reactions don’t help.
The basics of what happened with this story, is that a particularly bad Unity bug plagued the team and the unity support wasn’t being a help. LLM fixed the bug. I’m shocked to see that even this usage is considered unacceptable to some people.
They hid their usage of AI until they had to disclose it for some awards, and they still aren’t disclosing it on Steam. And they did more than just fix a single Unity shadow bug like people keep on saying (see their new disclosure page which still isn’t disclosed on Steam).
But considering the artsy and human vibe they were portraying in their marketing, even the smallest use of the plagiarism machine would still reasonable make people feel lied to and betrayed. I keep seeing people saying on other sites that it’s fine they hid it since otherwise people might not have bought it in the first place, which really frustrates me since they were still deceptive and I don’t really empathize with companies that lie to consumers to get their money.
I keep seeing people saying on other sites that it’s fine they hid it since otherwise people might not have bought it in the first place,
Pretty bleak that they’ve given up even the sophist arguments and now hope to ram LLM into everything hope people don’t notice.
Seeing this in game fan translations where the slippery slope argument of why they should be allowed to post stuff on romhacking and translation sites was “don’t worry, it’ll all be tagged; we’re just offering an option for people” for that to immediately turn out to be a lie. They’re not tagging it, they’re hostile to being honest about it and think they shouldn’t have to.
So now the question shifts from them having to prove its merits (which they broadly won’t or can’t do) to us having to basically deb00nk every single usage of it.
This uses datacentres that are burning the planet operating LLMs trained on the theft of other people’s works to ultimately carry out an action that removes work that would’ve been someone’s paid job.
I think I’m in the pool of people that thinks even this is not really ok. I know it’s very very small. I still think that when you put it in these plain terms about what this action actually does it still clearly isn’t ok.
I still like House House. I think the awards jurors made the right decision though.
I’m shocked to see that even this usage is considered unacceptable to some people.
i think people are getting way too upset about ai and we are losing our ability to make material analysis of its harms because we are being drowned in dogmatism
taking a stance of “so much as even touching it makes someone fundamentally and ontologically evil” is not going to make ai go away, and if i was some big billionaire ai guy i would much rather people be harassing some random developer (that cut out a significant portion of their profits by not publishing on XBOX because of the bds boycott) than me
its also just an extremely anti-marxist position to take. material harms need to be weighed, you cant just drown in dogmatism under some fear of corruption
obviously ai is shit, but the underlying problem is that ai has caused a severe degradation in documentation which is why house house had to use it in the first place. they went directly to unity and were told “there is no solution to this problem”. the fault lies with unity not the developers
if we turn every minor edge-case use like this into an end-all moral hazard, all we accomplish is losing our minds with scrupulosity and crashing out while the ai companies, who are the actual enemy, laugh to themselves and thank us for getting out of their way
ai is uniquely evil, unlike coffee companies which enslave people. its different because ai is Here and Here is where white people live, but slavery is Over There full of people i dont care about
and i think that really is why its so Universally Hated unlike other things. the people its affecting are generally white petit bourgeoisie artists who live in the imperial core, which makes it Evil and if anybody ever even thinks about it they are Tainted
and really the problem here isnt that they used ai. its that something they liked used ai, so its corrupted now. and they are a worse person for liking it because materialism isnt real and everything is based on morality, and if you have ever seen the claude logo you are ruined forever and we have to kill you.
people saw warhammer 40k having chaos and the inquisition and were like “what if we treated real life like that” and now some random guy on nexusmods who wanted to change the colour of his sword is getting put on doxbin for having tzeentch write 15 lines of code
and really the problem here isnt that they used ai. its that something they liked used ai, so its corrupted now. and they are a worse person for liking it because materialism isnt real and everything is based on morality, and if you have ever seen the claude logo you are ruined forever and we have to kill you.
I think this is poignant because Big Walk isn’t just some run-of-the-mill popular indie game. It resonated heavily with a lot of people and built a very unique experience all around human connection. It’s as ‘art’ as ‘artsy games’ can get and I think people feel the need to overcorrect when exceptions to the “AI is antithetical to art” appear.
Although that is being very charitable to the controversy, because of/c AI didn’t have a hand in the formation of that experience, just the debugging process of development. Still as you say this is enough to taint the project and you can see it reflected in some of the commentary, ie, ‘how can we trust that they didn’t use AI in other parts of development?’ As if they are somehow fundamentally worse now than they were before, even though you still don’t really know anything about them on a personal level.
I think this is poignant because Big Walk isn’t just some run-of-the-mill popular indie game. It resonated heavily with a lot of people and built a very unique experience all around human connection. It’s as ‘art’ as ‘artsy games’ can get and I think people feel the need to overcorrect when exceptions to the “AI is antithetical to art” appear.
To be honest, this is entirely my real issue. “Oh its artsy so a bit of AI is fine” is the absolute opposite-to-correct take. A game that emphasises human connections and artistic experience and relation is expected to be, from bottom-to-top, a human-made experience. Otherwise it, in an effectively completely unknown capacity, is not about the singular thing it sells itself on - human connection.
I’m not sure why it’s hard to understand that people are reacting negatively to that. Once it’s clear that some amount of the game ISN’T built on human experience, how are we supposed to know where human connection ends and the slop machine begins?
It’s like excusing a really good scientific paper because the authors have only been caught lying a few times. Like yeah, that undermines the whole fuckin’ thing.
This is a Quality Marxist Comment
I’m shocked to see that even this usage is considered unacceptable to some people.
I’m shocked to see that this usage is considered acceptable to some people.
What have they really done wrong here? The solution could have been delivered by Unity support eventually and it would likely be the same fix. They could have accidentally been presented snippets of code simply googling aspects of the bug, because google search automatically runs your search through their AI. They also could have not engaged with the LLM and shipped the game with the bug intact, or made other concessions, and the end result would have been lesser.
I am asking this in good faith despite how opinionated I already seem about it. I just don’t ‘get’ the thought process and why we would expect a rational human being to behave differently in this situation. Solidarity and all that, yeah - but it’s not like they’re enthusiastic AI developers. They claim AI was used in no other part of development and what they produced was one of the most human and expressive video games out there.
So from where I’m standing, such resolute opposition just feels dogmatic, without really considering the current realities of software development. I’m half-way between ‘this is an appropriate use of the technology, and surrounding market dynamics are the problem’ and ‘good boy developers get a little LLM as a treat’
I basically agree with you, but
the current realities of software development.
is such a weird and needlessly weasely way to talk (and you do this in the OP too). You aren’t giving any useful new information, just saying “that’s just how things are now” in a more pretentious and knowing tone. If you are trying to say anything rather than just engage in sophistry with this phrase, you are failing.
the current realities of software development.
The current reality of software development for me is that I had to fully and forcefully rip out all AI generated code in anything that I actually use last year and rebuild it from scratch.
I get the allure of “have the stochastic parrot fix it for me”, but you can just add easily spend some time fixing it yourself. It you’re able to prompt one of these things in a way that actually solves the problem, you’ve already solved the problem.
Since you know about this and I do not, could you explain how something could happen like the OOP? It seems like a few coders tried to fix it, both the devs and whatever poor intern was doing Unity support or however that works.
I should be clear, I don’t mean the particulars of this case, but some people apparently not being able to figure it out and an LLM doing it. Would you call this exclusively explicable as laziness or time-saving or something of the sort on the part of those people?
I’m not completely sure. There was probably a pressure to fix it, they probably tried and fell back on the LLM because they didn’t have the time or couldn’t be bothered.
They didn’t give much info on exactly what the code was. Either way, you can almost always solve these issues with dev time unless they’re actually unsolvable (which this one isn’t, since we know they found a patch).
I just know that in the past, whenever I did that a monkeys paw curled. The accumulation of tech debt becomes exponential and you lose your ability to navigate and understand the codebase.
When you write everything, or write on a team, you start understanding the ways that people solve things. You can navigate the code just by remembering landmarks. LLMs take that away, and you quickly enter a situation where you get instantly lost and unable to fix things yourself.
It really does feel like “AI realism” similar to “Capitalist Realism” I hear this argument in pretty much every article on AI, “Yeah, it’s actively worsening society and harming people and killing the planet, but that’s just how things are now so there’s nothing we can do to change it.”
This probably sounds and probably is irrational, but I find some optimism in knowing that the pushback against AI is no longer willing to entertain nuance.
I find a lack of nuance is almost never actually good. We shouldn’t feel proud for being dogmatic about anything
Material analysis ✋🙂↔️
Vibes 👈😌
Any material analysis that does not take into account the concentration of power, pollution of communication and trust, deskilling, and economic disruption that genAI entails is incomplete and dishonest.
It’s like saying “Wow, look at all the good we’ve done in developing our agricultural productive forces with the leftover chemical weapons from the war”.
In a best case scenario you’ll have a neutral (or mixed benefit/harm) effect with something that was designed purely around harm.
That sounds like some nuance is being entertained and I will not stand for it.
I liken the harms and social ills to factory farming, which is the single largest cause of pure suffering inflicted on any living being on the planet.
Factory farming is also killing the planet and its opposition (or at least advocation for severe moral regulations) is an ethical imperative.
Still, we cannot destroy it with a boycott, we cannot minimize its suffering through shame, and no amount of solidarity will remove its market presence.
It must be wretched from capital and seized for the people, and minimized or destroyed however that manifests.
I see a lot of this echoed in AI, in that anti AI advocacy that is dogmatic cannot work. It like many other industries must be put in the hands of the people before we can figure out what reeling it back looks like.
That’s all in the future, and if we can agree that’s what needs to happen, then we can hopefully engage in the discourse and material analysis dispassionately and with nuance, while also being kind to our fellow workers operating through the same unprecedented technology as the rest of us.
Oh no don’t hate me, I only secretly did A BIT of replacing human creative input with the kill-human-thoughts machine that’s leading the world into yet more disaster

I say this as someone who does a lot of programming for work - Nah fuck off with that. People are fully in their rights to hate LLM use in any capacity. Yes, AI can help you do some stuff, but I’ve never met a regular user who didn’t underestimate how much it screwed their own work over. The way a good portion of leftists, even here, accept the slop machine into their lives like this is fine is deeply upsetting to me.
Agree 100%, so many people are sounding like an OpenAI PR rep on left Lemmy these days and it’s incredibly disappointing. The flaws and concerns around these things that existed 2 years ago are exactly the same today
It is interesting to me how today western leftist spaces completely lose the plot when it comes to AI. In my opinion it just shows how low revolutionary consciousness is in general. When the discourse gets better it will be a good sign. I agree that we need to push back against AI but we need better arguments, and to find them we need better (marxist) analysis.
All “theft” arguments ultimately rely on the existence and enforcement of intellectual property, which we want to abolish. We should stop making these arguments period.
All “labour” arguments describe the consequences of any productivity-increasing technological development under capitalism. We know Marx already covered all of this: companies lower costs by firing workers, the rate of profit falls, we all get closer to another economic crisis (the AI bubble), and the workers suffer. And yes, LLMs can in fact increase productivity in software development. I’m not talking about vibe coding or anything like that, that is just a technical debt trap the big corporations are all falling right into so they can fire workers because code quality does not matter to them. I’m talking about describing a problem (even in abstract) to an LLM which suggests a solution and then you write your own code based on that, without ever copy-pasting anything. If you have ever written code you might have tried using LLMs this way because it they can be legitimately useful if you are stuck, and from what I understand this is more similar to how House House used LLMs if we are to believe them, and I have no reason to doubt them because the scenario they described is very realistic.
All other externalities are not a problem exclusive to LLMs. In a capitalist state the capitalists decide what infrastructure to build, and at the expense of whom.
I agree with the other comments that say that the negative reviews for Big Walk are mostly because players feel betrayed by a game they considered progressive. It does not matter that House House boycotted Microsoft consoles, a decision with material consequences against a BDS-listed corporation. AI was used in any amount during development so the game is now evil, corrupted and ruined, and it actually was all along. That is idealist nonsense. I understand being disappointed and upset (no one has to feel bad about having emotions), but let’s not allow that to cloud our judgment and analysis.
For the record, I am against AI but I don’t think House House deserve this kind of reaction based on their history and the information currently available.
My main arguments against are AI are how it insidiously makes you stupider, and that the removal of humans from the creative process is pure poison, but still I disagree with your issues with the other arguments.
Yes, we want a society that doesn’t have IP or an need to make artificial demands of labour, but we do RIGHT NOW work within a system that has those things. This is just “oh you typed this on an iphone” excuses with more steps. Yeah we don’t want the iphone either but we are limited by the material conditions that exist right now and any non-accelerationist leftist SHOULD oppose those conditions getting EVEN WORSE.

I hope, if you met an indie artist who had their work 100% stolen by a big corpo, you wouldn’t say “oh you shouldn’t argue about that because IP is ultimately an undesirable concept”.
My main arguments against are AI are how it insidiously makes you stupider, and that the removal of humans from the creative process is pure poison
I agree with both arguments, in fact both are not even a matter of opinion, they are objectively true statements.
I hope, if you met an indie artist who had their work 100% stolen by a big corpo, you wouldn’t say “oh you shouldn’t argue about that because IP is ultimately an undesirable concept”.
Obviously I wouldn’t say that. I would probably say something like “that sucks, I’m sorry that happened. Of course the big corpo would do that, IP laws only actually apply to anyone beneath them and that’s why they are not worth defending. And the burgeois state that allows that to happen is also not worth defending, so become a communist and push for revolution”
I do not mean to imply that any artist victim of theft from AI is an hypocrite. But they should not be running towards burgeois law for protection, that does not work! They should be moving (and we must help them) towards radicalization against the entire burgeois state, and towards marxist theory so they can understand what’s happening and not be powerless anymore.
People are calling it theft both because they’re subconsciously recognizing it as hypocritical to live in a propertied world, but some property is getting valued more than others by the state that pretends to be impartial.
But also because they recognize on some level this is primitive accumulation happening again.
They’re calling theft in a pragmatic, moral sense. Not in the property-obsessed liberal sense. The “well if you trained it on your own art AI would be fine” arguments are a minority opinion at best by liberal-centrist discourse perverts.
Westerners are more mad at them for LLM usage than they care about BDS-ing Microsoft/Israel because they see that LLMs are an imminent threat to themselves whereas they still don’t see Palestine as them in the future. This isn’t an issue of idealism because it’s an issue of chauvinism and small-mindedness. Might also be easier to boycott LLM-slop and criticize AI than it is to criticize and boycott Israel too. As of yet, they haven’t got an IdPol argument pro-LLM as strong as calling people antisemitic for criticizing Israel.
I’ve only ever seen AI be used as a shortcut, a way to cut human labour out of the process and devaluing that labour in turn. Hyperbole, but it doesn’t become ok to stab someone “a little bit” it’s still the same thing even if it isn’t as bad as it could’ve been.
The real crime here though is the dev team still using Unity. That is unforgivable.
If you don’t have solidarity then you’re a scab. I don’t care why you need to use the environment wrecker labour smasher 7000. I don’t care if it’s one picture in your portfolio or a single line of code. Code is not less precious than music or paintings.
Fuck sloppers
Is debugging really an artistic endeavor?
“Art” is not what makes something valuable.
The machines are built via a massive act of exploitation and ruin, they exist to empower the worst people in the world. If they work it’s horrifying and if they don’t it’s horrifying.
Using them is fruit of the poisoned tree, it is used by the people who make them to justify the wanton exploitation and enormous waste involved in creation. It is the thin edge of the wedge, and a place that proponents can use to divide and conquer.
Solidarity is important because we all have different concerns and we must be united if we are to stop the future being wrested from our hands.
I don’t disagree with the critique of the technology, though I think the realities of it are a lot less poetic. Under current property dynamics it’s almost purely an extractive technology that has more or less stolen collective productivity and turned it into a slop machine, but the thing still exists and is capable of production. This is less of a ‘cats out of the bag’ appeal and more ‘we’re going to have to seize control of this technology just like everything else’ line.
To that end, when I imagine an ideal possible scenario where this technology now has to exist alongside fundamentally different market dynamics, I have to imagine the application of local models in specialized fields would be one of the ways it sticks around.
And, I think, it will stick around - we have to meet people where they are at a certain point, and software devs range from vibe code addicts to professionals indulging in a powerful new tool. None of them want to give it up, I don’t think.
Some technologies are stupid and bad actually. The stuff people often say they’re useful for that are on the scale of tasks that reasonable models could be built for are tasks that more efficient software already exists to solve. Like you don’t need some nuts gpu full of conflict minerals and 500 joules of electricity to rename some variables or adjust the tone of an email. You should go and read the papers that describe how to build these things, make a small language model, see how stupid of an approach it is. They’re dead simple just really big and inefficient.
Many software devs hate this shit. I am a dev and I hate this shit. It has absolutely destroyed the pipeline for training people in good ethics and practice and is actively destroying what little good practice we have managed to cultivate in software design. This is decent reading: https://tante.cc/2026/04/21/ai-as-a-fascist-artifact/ and so is this: https://deadsimpletech.com/blog/no-such-thing-as-just-a-tool
also go and read the transcripts of microsoft standing in front of the EU parliament talking about how we need to blow past climate goals for AI. This isn’t some stupid bougie concern, millions of people are going to die.
I’m in the “professional with a powerful new tool” category, using copilot in an IDE on a work project for the first time.
Been messing with code for over 10 years but never in a professional capacity and it’s been helpful for quickly getting me up to speed with unfamiliar libraries or languages, or HW interfaces. I’d be fine giving it up tho.
It’s an undeniably powerful tool with genuinely impressive capabilities. Because of this I’m convinced that a zero tolerance policy is a losing proposition long term in terms of popular support.
But it’s also an open question what the real cost of operating these things is in the long term is. We’re still in the bubble with huge amounts of capital going around to make these available for use below their actual cost. It’s likely many would not fine it worth using if presented with its unsubsidized cost.
Because of this I’m convinced that a zero tolerance policy is a losing proposition long term in terms of popular support.
i think this is also a big one. any reasonably informed historical perspective has to contend with the 50 movements against automation over the past 2 centuries and how they have all near universally failed. theres plenty of blame not due to those within these movements, but at some point you have to contend that “harassing those who use a technology to force it to recede” is not a viable strategy given the conditions at hand. and given the average argument actively reifies intellectual property or goes on about True Art and The Human Soul, i dont think this will amount to much either.
If AI was sentient do you think that would make it OK to steal collective productivity (i.e. humans learning from textbooks) to become a slop machine (i.e. humans making video games)
Yes. Just like applying gesso to a canvas is an artistic endeavor. Some of the greatest bits of artistry in this industry came from debugging.
Can you imagine making a game without debugging?
No art is a straight impression from brain to presentation medium. There is always a technique to it. A dialectic between creator and created, one might say.
In this case it would be more honest if House House had made a “degree of AI usage” declaration where people could know that it was used in the process but not in the design of anything visible to the end user.
I don’t disagree with this approach and especially the last bit, but I’m still not sure on the idea of using AI as a debugger having meaningfully infringed on the art.
There was once a time - think PS1, N64 - where you could not imagine making a game without accounting for extremely low framerates. Sub 20 FPS, what we might consider unplayable today. It was a technical limitation that bred creativity, as they all do, but it’s also a limitation we’ve moved past and very very few developers would champion the artistic merit of making your audience motion sick. Had they the option, many of them would have pressed the magic ‘higher framerate’ button at the time.
Taking this into more of a hypothetical, if a specialized debugging LLM was developed that worked extremely efficiently at eliminating unintended game functions based on a developers prompt, I don’t believe many developers would champion the artistic merit of manual debugging, either. And if we are to say that something in the artistic process was still lost at that stage, then I can’t see that as anything but having arbitrary reverence for limits in software development.
As someone who does a lot of programming, I truly believe it is. And I would balk at length to anyone who says it isn’t.
Creative moments are built into every last thing we do. Debugging things gives you ideas. And it gives you understanding. And it gives opportunities for you to do something a different way. Art and all of human creation is built around the limitations we come across.
Half of Cubism is effectively derived from the technical limitations of 2D painting. Picasso could’ve just said “AI make a holograph that shows other perspectives than this painting”. But in wanting to show more perspectives, we learned to show metaphorical, wilder, and even fictional ones too, which all relate to human experience in deeply striking ways.
So yeah, overcoming technical limitations is an artistic endeavour.
Just as much as fixing the mistakes in a drawing or on a painting.
They can have a little slop for boycotting Xbox but I’m watching them
Like with Clair Obscur I wish awards would take the independent label more seriously.
Big Walk was developed and promoted with publisher funding.
It’s not really doing service to indie game development to always just highlight the games that got developed with the most resources.
“indie” doesnt really have a concrete definition. i agree clair obscur isnt indie, but what about something like silksong? its made by the hollow knight developers and has no publisher, but hundreds of contractors worked on the game. what about ultrakill? its a small team passion project but its published by new blood interactive. removing games with publishers removes like 95% of games in existence lol.
its just vibes based, and award shows are all owned by and paid for by massive corpos anyway so
True. I feel like what’s called indie is a new generation of game devs in the lead of game development, and the label sticks around as those people get more entrenched in the industry.
Most people dont want any AI usage whatsoever. Shit is radioactive. Sometimes that bites like in this situation, where had LLMs been kept.local and didnt have the stain of Big Tech it would be seen as cool. But because they are stolen labor spy machines nobody wants them and I agree. Local are cool though, and House House doesnt deserve this hate for this, but the lines in the sand are fully drawn and quartered by now.
the lines in the sand are fully drawn and quartered
wut
What you’re not familiar with the common expression “drawing and quartering a line in the sand”?
sounds like you want to start a game of four square but you can’t play that in sand. The ball won’t bounce. IT WONT BOUNCE!
I may be almost out of my mind. Expressions never save right.
No worries, I wouldn’t call it a flub, just an honest mistake.
I thought it was intentional and funny
You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make them chase two birds in the bush.
Yes I do agree that an ideal scenario is local models tailored only for software development and used only by software developers, and I think that’d be the future of the technology in any just society. I don’t know if the lines are fully drawn in the sand under our current market dynamics, though. From what I’ve seen the application of the LLM in the above story is almost standardized now, as in you could accidentally generate the solution to your problem by just Googling. I haven’t spoken with someone in programming that hasn’t remarked that it’s everywhere in the workplace and I haven’t seen a git project without a claude contribution in ages.
Lots of people are vocal about their stance on AI in development, but we’re not seeing those principles in practice.
My problem is more that they waited until now to disclose this. If they had announced this at launch there inevitably would’ve been some drama but ultimately most people would just move on. Waiting until after it had gotten so much popular coverage to only now disclose it feels gross to me.
Hi. I downvoted Big Slop on Steam. I can only taste shit after finding out the delicious soup I ate had fecal matter in it after the fact.
I’m not advocating that a programmer who used Claude be subject to violence or harassment. I’m not advocating that studio leadership that chose to use Unity for their game engine after 2024 (lmao) and bungled this messaging be fired or replaced. I’m not advocating that a studio that understood Steam didn’t require them to disclose use of AI for code, and then disclosed it to win an award, be shut down. I’m leaving a negative review to effect the least consequential of things somebody under capitalism can do, which is to spend money elsewhere.
I don’t think anyone should give House House the benefit of doubt going forward. I don’t have to tolerate any use of AI for any reason, and I don’t have to justify my intolerance for use of a tool to anyone. Big Slop doesn’t deserve to win an IGF award IMO, and I’m thankful to the judges and jurors who are taking that stance.
I hope House House learns from this mistake and does better. If not, there are plenty of other indie devs and studios I can support.
and I don’t have to justify my intolerance for use of a tool to anyone.
This is a counterproductive mindset. No one is denying you your precious right to do consumer activism, they are questioning if people in this instance should be doing so. Not if you can, which no one contests and which is the only framing that your statement applies to, but should.
good for them













