Thinking about the discourse around CURRENT GAME 6 and how these franchises change over time. Similarly, God of War went through a maturation while still trying to retain its identity.
I think part of the problem is that these are franchises that would have ended if not for the current mode of production. These things can’t be allowed to die because they’re products. Instead the product itself is forced to change, often in jarring ways. One minute you’re a power fantasy for a 13 year old boy and the next there are diaper-buying mini-games and reflections on the role of post-colonialism as told through a token character.
I think if games weren’t products then we wouldn’t even run into this problem. We would have way more games that take on these themes in their own way and it would make more sense as a body of work like film or music. Instead there’s like 5 franchises that must encompass the entirety of human experience over the span of 30 years. Devs change, consumers change, new consumers are now met with the current product and may be unfamiliar with it in the context of the previous entries.
Even without the capitalist mode, would devs revisit their old works and remake them using their gained life experience? Would they just make something new? What do you think? Some of you are amateur or indie devs. What do you envision for your games?
I’m anti-franchise, anti-canon, and anti-remake in general. I think every work of art is stamped with the context of its times and franchises and cinematic universesTM are just ways to groom consoomers into buying useless merch that will go to the dumpster even as the actual work has long since become outdated. GTA should have ended with San Andreas exactly like you said. Its tone and style of humor is so early 90s-mid 00s. You could just imagine the song “Asshole,” itself also a product of the early 90s, playing in the background as you go around running people over with golf carts. That’s why GTA IV fell flat because the devs realized they can’t keep pretending its the mid 00s, GTA V tried to have it both ways with Travis, and GTA VI now has you doing generic household chores to signal how it has “grown up.”
I don’t really see fanfic, mythology, and stuff like Arthurian cycles as the same thing because there isn’t a real canon and what’s broadly agreed upon is so vague relative to what people consider canon. The Sherlock Holmes “universe” is that Sherlock Holmes is some smart detective with a less smart detective named Watson. That’s literally it. There’s the OG books by Doyle, but I remember some cartoon about a futuristic cyborg Holmes, Disney has a cartoon movie where Holmes is a mouse, you have stuff like House where some people swear it’s just a Sherlock Holmes adaptation, and so on. The Sherlock Holmes fandom is the first fandom in the world, and the Sherlock Holmes fanfic has so eclipsed Sherlock Holmes “canon,” basically the works by Doyle, that the canon-fanfic divide isn’t even useful to describe the cultural phenomenon of Sherlock Holmes. You could write a short story of Sherlock Holmes beating up James Bond and King Arthur and it probably doesn’t even hit the top 30% of weird shit.
But the thing is Doyle couldn’t get away with writing a story of Sherlock Holmes beating up King Arthur or “wot if Sherlock Holmes was a mouse” because audiences have build up an expectation of what a Doyle-penned Sherlock Holmes story should be. Audience expectation is a restraint and capitalism demands that you continue to produce feed for consoomers to consoom, but artists mature and the time changes. All franchises have this contradiction. Just look at The Simpsons. The Simpsons has a floating timeline, so Homer is supposed to be a millennial, but does he even look like a millennial? How many fat bald white dudes do you know who also don’t have glasses, facial hair, or tats? I would say that Homer looks like some kind of cop, but even younger cops have tats these days. Homer’s very character design points to him being a boomer especially the baldness-lack of facial hair combo. At best, he’s like a xennial cop. They obviously can’t update Homer’s character design to look like an actual middle-aged millennial because they have cheap plastic toys to sell. And this isn’t even getting to Marge’s hair which was supposed to be satirizing a boomer fad.
At the end of the day, franchises and canons are simultaneously too restrictive to really get creative but also don’t respect the source material enough due to having to keep up with the times. Fandoms are far more creative and just letting your work stand on its own as you move on means the work can be understood and enjoyed as a product of its time.
I read an interesting thought on Twitter the other day between all the cursed as hell “takes” that I thought was pretty good. GTA as a franchise is really based on a late 90s view of American cities, when the crime rates of the 80s and early 90s were at the forefront of people’s minds. Even with crime rates dropping this city still existed in the late 90s and through the 2000s but it is increasingly disappearing, especially through the 2010s. In the year 2026 this type of city doesn’t really exist in the cities GTA is parodying and commenting on, except in out of the way pockets. In some flyover cities this type of city still exists to some degree but essentially this person’s point was GTA, a franchise ostensibly based in the present, is increasingly a late 90s period piece. The cities GTA is based on have just become too safe to be the basis for another GTA game. Hell I go into NYC these days and I feel like I’m in Disneyland compared to when I’d go down and hang around there back in the early 2010s and even that period was far removed from type of city in the early 90s GTA was based on.
And so in its attempt to stay based in the present GTA takes aim at the current political and social situation in the country. And I think this is jarring to a lot of people since GTA to most people is about a certain urban decay which is increasingly based in the past (there is an urban decay video game to be made in the present I think but it’s different from the urban decay GTA originally commented on). And then by commenting on social issues GTA inevitably gets caught up in culture war issues. I think also GTA is associated with that 90s era and especially Bush era edgy shock humor and crassness for the sake of being crass. Offending for the sake of offending really aimed at pissing off a certain type of religious conservative from that period. But at this point the critique of this behavior which always existed as socially ignorant mostly holds sway and so they’re not gonna play into this humor in 2026. Those expecting the same humor as the 2000s and even early 2010s will be disappointed.
So idk if it’s really growing up as much as it is changing with the times. I think it could’ve been done differently, hell maybe better. Or they could’ve accepted the change into “late 90s period piece” and just removed the overt offensiveness. But they needed to change and update some aspect of the GTA formula and this is how they did it
I think if games weren’t products then we wouldn’t even run into this problem. We would have way more games that take on these themes in their own way and it would make more sense as a body of work like film or music. Instead there’s like 5 franchises that must encompass the entirety of human experience over the span of 30 years. Devs change, consumers change, new consumers are now met with the current product and may be unfamiliar with it in the context of the previous entries.
I think this view is ahistorical. When you look back to the human past, having “universes” of characters and stories with a variety of tones and themes told by a large number of different storytellers with varying takes on the stories. As far as historical and ethnographical evidence shows, this seems to be how stories have been experienced by the vast majority of peoples for the vast majority of human history. Stories would arise piecemeal over generations and be shaped by hundreds of storytellers.
The idea that stories should be self-contained, on topic, one theme/tone, the product of one author or set of creators, etc actually arises in the bourgeois era of media production with copyrights and the emergence of a market for medias produced by competing petty bourgeois or bourgeois media producers guarding their intellectual property.
Without intellectual property law standing in the way, either as we see atm with increased monopolisation or as we will see under socialism with the abolition of IP, it seems people return to combining stories together into universes or mythological cycles
Fan fiction is weirdly a example of this in a capitalist society.
Another very good point in this thread. I myself am a product of this system so it’s difficult to think outside of it even when attempting to criticize it. Stores have, traditionally, been social experiences. They’re not a singular product of one genius creator with one vision.
Imagine if they did a mature version of disco Elysium

Finally, a version where Kim makes me his boyfriend
Disco Elysium but all of the dialogue choices are the Boring Cop dialogue choices and the only political quest is the world’s most laughable centrist one.
I think developers would absolutely revisit their old works and grow them up even without capitalist pressure. It would definitely be a lot less frequent than it is now, but especially if you have one thing that’s more popular than the rest of your output I can see why there would be an extremely strong pull towards making a sequel that comments on the original in some way. Even without that, any developer who’s feeling nostalgic themselves would reach for an old success, as would any developer who is going through the process of looking back on their career and putting it all into perspective.
God of War 3 to 4 was a pretty huge jump, a much bigger jump than from GTA 5 to 6 frankly, and the kind of jump that I would expect from a creator that feels like they’ve done as much as they can with their original idea, and through the process of doing that thing they have come up with a new idea which requires the context of the old idea to work. Sure, they can make a hypothetical new character with a ton of baggage that plays the same role as Kratos’s baggage plays in God of War 4, but in this case the late sequel helps the new game because it spares the new game from needing to spend tons of time explaining what the baggage is and how it got there.
I haven’t released any full sized games yet but I definitely envision mine as one and done and never returned to again lmao. Maybe I’ll feel different ten years from now.
A similar example from an indy dev: I have a friend who has developed a series of games using stolen assets from existing corporate games, and he’s currently working on the 4th one (Distorted Travesty series). He obviously can’t profit on a game like this; he just does it for fun.
In the case of games, sometimes the story is really just there to hold together a bunch of otherwise loosely associated levels and gameplay elements. A person might make a game, reflect on it, and realize therebare still fun things they can do with a core concept. Easiest to just make a sequel and get into the nitty gritty of gameplay then.
The opposite of this would be a guy like Hironobu Sakaguchi, director/producer of Final Fantasy 1-10, who hated sequels and felt like they were the death of creativity(Seems ironic considering he made 10 games in the same series, but that’s why every Final Fantasy is so different).
Some people just like making sequels. Some don’t
I really love the fact that every final fantasy is so different from every other one. Maybe that’s because I was such a huge fan of the series when I was younger that it affected how I view sequels as a whole, and I wish more series operated that way. Like it doesn’t have to be a jrpg thing, arguably the Super Mario series also operates the exact same way, with the only continuity in those games being the gameplay ideas.
It’s always weird seeing people try to force a continuity on to Mario when Mario goes out of its way to shatter that illusion.
Similar with Zelda, except Aonuma evenutually broke down and tried to shoehorn a timeline into the series, which never worked and still doesn’t work
Even without the capitalist mode, would devs revisit their old works and remake them using their gained life experience?
Whose old work is it anyways? I mean even if it wasn’t a capitalist enterprise but an NGO or just a hobby some people had organized through a club or an association at this point it’s been 29 years since the first GTA. How many are straight up dead or disabled or simply had their life priorities shift in 30 years? Mindseye got some hype because Leslie Benzies, former president of Rockstar and “main producer” of GTA was spearheading it and that’s a fucking mess. I think games, especially of this caliber, are such a huge, cooperative project they’re better understood in a sense of folklore. Some themes stay, some themes evolve with the times to fit the current zeitgeist, some get added, some get dropped. People make SP mods that tell different stories than a game originally did, even if it’s not “their” work and I’d assume a lot more would do it if it wasn’t such an insane amount of work because “tell the story you want to in the medium and setting you are a fan of” seems pretty appealing, I mean look at AO3.
Also every time a studio manages to not become a hollowed out corpse acting as a namebadge they also constantly revisit their old works in their new works. All of Kojimas MGS4 is basically him just reckoning with what he used to think, what he thinks now and his role as per MGS. You can trace such a clear path from Max Payne 1 to Control: Resonant, hell GSC: Gameworld from STALKER: Shadow of Chernobyl to STALKER 2 is all Sergiy Grygorovych and while he’s apparently a shitass boss and the games have terribly confusing politics and messages if you think about it anymore than not at all you can still see the throughline.
That’s a good point about thinking of these as large teams with multiple inputs rather than the singular vision of one individual.
As far as someone like Kojima goes, how much of that was Kojima wanting to revisit MGS and how much of it was him playing the business game and knowing that’s what the executives wanted? I mean some writers do 8 seasons of a TV show. Not so much because they love revisiting the same characters over and over, but because they recognize that’s their role and their job as a TV writer. I imagine Kojima knew his role at Konami. Since he left he does seem more interested in new projects, despite doing MGSV.
I honestly feel like the whole concept of fictional “universes” is anti-art and is purely a result of capitalist pressures. There is simply no reason why disparate stories gain anything from being set in the same “universe” instead of being told in a bespoke context for each one. So franchises that span multiple decades that are essentially just double dipping the setting to recycle their audience only exist because it’s more profitable to do that instead of taking the risk of starting something new when it’s time to tell a new story.
I disagree with this to the point of calling it objectively incorrect. People spend hundreds to thousands of hours dreaming up their fictional settings and then write down the stories that take place in the worlds they’ve created.
There is simply no reason why disparate stories gain anything from being set in the same “universe” instead of being told in a bespoke context for each one.
Of course there is? The same events in the same setting can have drastically different consequences for different characters in different places or even at different times. This is absolutely worth exploring.
Disagree. The universe important to the narrative. If I say my story is set on coruscant right before Star Wars ep 1, you now know a ton about the world that I no longer have to explain in my story, letting me take more time to tell the story itself in a satisfying manner. If I say that it’s about male Twi’lek servant to a rich human, if you’re familiar with the world you can fill in all sorts of dynamics without me having actually written them. Again giving more time to the characters and maintaining the narrative’s structure.
I think that’s a capitalist reflection of something that people do anyway. People write fanfictions for free, and a lot of religious text is just in-universe headcanons for shit people wrote before, where they powerscale and ship these gods with those gods or whatever.
Worldbuilding has just always been a thing. Capitalists haven’t done anything but fence it off and monetize it
idk DS9 gains a lot from being in the same setting as TNG, and to the extent that there used to be some ideological throughline from the original series and later trek it was good that it kept going until enterprise killed it.
i think making a coherent fictional world is much harder than a bunch of individual stories, but that just makes it more impressive and carry more weight if someone does a good job of it.
what’s the limit? should every issue or episode of batman retell his origin?
I would disagree, I don’t think the idea of “universes” is necessarily purely a product of capitalist pressures. There are folk tales/myths that have existed for thousands of years that kind of take place in a shared “universe” where the same characters are used to tell different stories. It’s not to the same extent of modern examples like marvel or Star wars but you’d still have the concept of pre-established characters in a familiar setting.
star wars isn’t even like star wars anymore. there’s maybe three eras of it: early stuff like the novelizations and first run of comics, and splinter of the mind’s eye; middle era stuff where they had a guy who was in charge of coordinating continuity, and post-disney garbge
the best quality stuff is almost all from that continuity manager era
marvel isn’t as reset-happy as DC but the way mainstream comics do shared universes is really haphazard and they try to cash in with those big crossover events that are impossible to follow casually instead of it just being cool that batman beyond is the future of btas and there’s a little bit of connection but it’s not filled with knockoff future versions of everybody.
I miss the old pre-disney EU, I’m not surprised my interest in new Star wars stuff (I was the biggest Star wars nerd) evaporated when they declared the EU non-canon (until they started picking bits out for new Disney stuff)
I think this is only applicable to if your universe is just the actual world because then it doesn’t really add anything interesting. Sticking to videogames: KOTOR I and II are pretty good and if you wanted to do them without Star Wars you’d have to reinvent the force and at that point what is won
That is a factor for sure. However did you know about the helenistic story universe? Where’re every local god was somehow related to one of the big gods in the mainline franchise. All the heros were somehow related to someone or other. The reason your town has a cool rock is some interconnected story about a man and a wooden horse.
That strikes me as the natural way people make stories. Just like with AO3 people take the stories they were told and fit new narratives in them
Oh I can go off for hours about shoving shit in the same universe. I hate it so fucking much. And people will get mad at me for pointing out the issues.
Edit: looking at the replies I thought we were talking about shit like Marvel and trying to make every super hero exist in the same universe.
I agree. I enjoy Batman. But Gotham stories just dont make sense to me in a universe with the likes of Mr. Myxyzptlk and Plastic Man. Complete tonal dissonance.
It’s not like good writers haven’t made this work despite that, but the canon eventually gets bloated and the stakes get lowered when you know the Flash can’t suffer permanent consequences because the writing team needs him as a swappable asset.
It’s one of the things I like about the cartoons. They aren’t concerned with decades-old canon, nor are they hoping to build 40 year legacies because businesses consider them temporary “throwaways” for kids that will grow out of them
It’s one of the things I like about the cartoons. They aren’t concerned with decades-old canon, nor are they hoping to build 40 year legacies because businesses consider them temporary “throwaways” for kids that will grow out of them
they didn’t go into btas thinking they were inventing the dcau but once something like that exists at all i think it elevates the component parts as long as there’s good stewardship of it
Shame that the DCAU peaked with BTAS then.
Anyway, Caped Crusader is where it’s at now.
there’s shoving shit together just because, and there’s having a bigger thing going on

Indeed
I like the idea of creating a setting that is bigger than the story you’re currently telling. Something that holds multiple stories or time periods. In that way the setting becomes a character. Three crime stories that take place in LA in the 40s and then in the 90s and then in 2010s can work if the intention to say something about LA. To your point, simply recycling LA because your audience liked the first one would be a problem.
Counterpoint: GTA has always been a social commentary. Likewise, GoW was always about family and the necrotic effect of hate and vengeance. They aren’t growing up, people are just now actually picking up on themes.
As for new games and franchises, just this year we had Cairn, Don’t Stop, girlypop!, Replaced, Mouse: P.I. for Hire, Pragmata, Stray, and many more that have some amount of social commentary.
Yeah but you have to admit that early GoW was more “vengeance is toxic but it’s also badass” and current GoW is more of a literary take on vengeance. They might have the same theme but the sensibility and level of maturity are different. Like there’s a difference between John Wick and a tragic stage play about revenge. GoW did definitely grow up, it’s not as exploitative as it used to be.
I’ll give you less exploitative, given the one quick time event, but I don’t think it’s fair to discount a game just because the player doesn’t realize they’re playing as the bad guy. You can certainly criticize the narrative as less developed or not executing on its themes as well, but I don’t feel like that’s what you’re getting at.











