Children are something like a quasi-class. Not a full class because aging is not historically specific. A dictatorship of the “class” of children would be nonsensical as there cannot be any continuity of leadership or identity.
But the historically determined ways in which age groups are socially separated is something that can be revolutionized. It is not biologically given that children are treated as property, are made to labor and fight wars, are forced to train up as future wage slaves. These political-economic conditions are peculiar to children, and on that basis it is valid to speak of children’s liberation. Children’s liberation would be part of the broader proletarian class movement, because what we have to solve is specifically the bourgeois family and bourgeois category of children, not children in the abstract.
Yes, clearly.
The amount of direct control they are subject to, and how little recourse they have for the abuse the majority sees no issue inflicting on them (and even in extreme cases of abuse, does nothing to protect) is disgusting.
edit
I see all the arguing back and forth about what a class is, I had just substituted it for group. I don’t really want to debate what a class is just saying they are massively oppressed as a group, uhhh probably globally.yes children are an oppressed social class, i think it’s obvious. to claim otherwise is to engage in vulgar class reductionism. i have come to think that youth liberation is crucial to real revolutionary politics. it is tied up so tightly with queer liberation especially. being a child sucks, it’s preposterous how little agency you have. kids should be able to basically divorce their shitty parents (utopian vision). like, aren’t we all on the same page about this? haven’t we all read engels at least? the family is one of the most harmful institutions on earth and enables the worst parents to unleash unthinkable violence daily on helpless kids. it all needs to be destroyed
Okay. I want to be onboard with this.
I am a parent. What do I need to do to start getting at least my six year old to understand her class interests?
My son is intellectually disabled. His class interests will be difficult to communicate to him, so let’s start with my daughter.
Is this at all possible to do at an atomic family level? Or does it require cultural sea change?
it will require cultural revolution essentially i think, as i stated it is something of a utopian vision. i don’t feel qualified to give advice on parenting i’m afraid!
In my experience, no class or group of people is easier to radicalize in the imperial core than children. And it’s not because they’re ignorant, at least in the sense you might be thinking of. It’s because the bourgeoisie and their running dogs haven’t had time to convince them that bad is good and good is bad—yet. If kids have incorrect political views, these are also much easier to change than in the case of basically anyone older. The younger a person is in the USA, the likelier they are to have leftwing political views, because they are oppressed and / or exploited.
I hate when people use the word “childish” as an insult. Kids might not be a class, but they are definitely not the enemy, except in the very rare cases of the American Volkssturm we saw in 2020. As a teenager and when I was even younger, I was often frustrated that I had virtually no control over my life, especially in high school when I found myself frequently performing arduous yet pointless tasks for legions of unpleasant and unaccountable adults. I still have virtually no control over my life as an adult, but I certainly have a greater illusion of control.
“Age isn’t an indicator of class.” Actually, I would argue that age is an indicator of class. There are many exceptions, but the overwhelming majority of boomers in the USA are bourgeois, and almost every member of the bourgeoisie is a boomer—except for, like, Mark Zuckerberg. Among the petite bourgeoisie, very few are younger than 45 years old (I know that this makes some of them Gen Xers but fuck you). Even if many boomers are currently becoming homeless, I’ve seen stories about homeless boomers still being libs. Ultimately however, whether or not you own capital, whether or not you are white male cis (and benefiting economically from white supremacy and patriarchy), these are more reliable indicators of your politics than age in the imperial core. But there’s always a subjective factor. We all have stories about meeting the most oppressed / exploited type of person you could imagine, only for that person to have reactionary politics. Lenin, Mao, Castro, Che, and many other famous communists came from relatively wealthy families. Marx could have been a comfortable boring professor or lawyer if he had wanted.
Kids, especially kids in shitty / petite bourgeois households, often do unpaid labor, and will suffer abuse or worse if they refuse (and will also just be abused on the regular even if they comply). I once saw a white girl—who was barely up to my waist—working at a local restaurant. Kids have very few options if they’re being abused, aside from becoming homeless, at which point they become the prey of Epsteinists. Epstein and similar monsters frequently preyed upon homeless teenage girls because they had no one to help them and were desperate, perfect targets. We have also seen in places like Gaza and Iran (as well as ICE deportations) that Epsteinists specifically and repeatedly target children. The IDF’s primary purpose is the elimination of Palestinian women and children. Adoption and foster care is also often indistinguishable from slavery and human trafficking. There are numerous instances of adults fostering shitloads of kids and leaving them in terrible living conditions in order to make easy money; children are also increasingly the targets of family destruction and are likewise daily victims of school shootings and other forms of stochastic violence promoted by the US ruling class. Want to get super depressed? Search youtube for the Brothers Home in South Korea.
The bourgeois family should be abolished. People of all kinds should have necessities guaranteed, regardless of whom they live with.
I think you haven’t considered that children don’t have assets, and thus no vested interests in supporting imperialism to help their own material interests in the parasite states that we call the first world.
Assets are a legal distinction. A kid who has free access to their guardians’ money to buy the latest tech, designer clothes, generally live a bourgeois lifestyle are perfectly interested in the maintenance of the income stream which sustains that. Kids (especially teenagers) can be very bourgeois and classist and not only because of indoctrination.
As an economic class? No
As a marginalised identity group? Yes
If a parent beats a child, why can’t they just run away? What is the basis of their near property-like existence if not economic?
What is the basis of their near property-like existence
The basis is the mother carried them for 9 months then breast fed them for 2-3 years which is a fundamentally different bond to any other. That and someone has to take responsibility for raising them throughout the many years that they are not going to make informed or responsible decisions.
The same reasons we don’t arrest or sentence children under the age of 12 to crime, and have reduced sentences for those who are older but still minors.
Like, obviously the situation is not ideal and could be more communal or something else. But the basis of this is more complex than saying it’s economic. The situation of the woman in the partnership is more obviously economic and the children’s situation is a side-effect of that.
It would require far more spoons than I currently have to write out everything I think about this particular issue, but this is one of the things that has radicalized me as a parent, a neurodivergent woman who was bullied as a kid and just while witnessing the treatment of children in the society I live in, how hostile it is to the very existance of children.
Many of my views come from thinkers like Kollontai and Engless (The Origin of Family, private property and the state). Also Friere and The Pedagogy of The Oppressed and others.
While I agree that children, like women, are not a class as such, they sure are the proletariat within a proletariat in a way. In capitalism or anywhere where property is tied to inheritance children themselves are property.
In the so called modern West kids are insurance projects to do instead of full human beings. They have very little say in their own life even though not long ago these same humans were somehow completely cabable of hard labor and in many places still are. The double standards are everywhere when “protection” typically means removing agency and freedom from children.
The conditions for kids in daycares and schools are horrible. They are like worker factories for capitalism where you get a hearing issue and ptsd by age 3. Kids go kind of feral, because nobody has time to actually raise them or show them how all of this works. In large schools with low resources the vibe to me resembles a prison. Kids don’t get to choose if they participate, they are forced to.
I personally think that communism is the only way for a better life during childhood as it would reframe things like education towards growing into full humans instead of little obedient wage slaves.
Childhood as a concept is only about 200 years old. While a lot of good has come from it, it has also created a very steep hierarchy and dismissal of childrens capabilities and agency that kids in my opinion very well could have. That does not take away from them needing space and time to learn and grow and be protected. I’d argue that they mostly aren’t getting much of that right now anyway, apart from in lofty declarations. Society is still mostly hostile to them, just look at the sour faces when a child makes noise in public. It is not a friendly environment they are growing in.
Family abolition doesn’t just mean tearing families apart. It means expanding systems of care so that the family isn’t the only place that people can receive it. In their original writing, Hegel, Marx, and Engels all used the word aufhebung to refer to abolition, which is really better translated as “positive supercession.”
family abolition is much more than taking power away from parents and giving it to the state. In fact, that would run counter to the goals of family abolition and youth liberation, but it happens regularly under capitalism through the family policing system.
I fucking hate the vocabulary they make up for Marxist texts when translating. Correct me if I’m wring, but “uplifting” is a closer and more comprehensible description of aufhebung from German to English than fucking “PoSiTiVe SuPeRcEsSiOn”
You aren’t wring, but “aufhebung” has a contradictory (or rather dialectical) double meaning of “abolishing/destroying” and “lifting up” (to the next level). That double meaning is lost if you just choose one of them. What Hegel called “aufhebung”, Engels called “negation of the negation” in his three laws of dialectics. Doesn’t really make it easier either, does it?
Sure. But it’s still orders of magnitude better than “super pregecesesioning” or whatever the fuck they smoked, which gets BOTH meanings lost to 90% of readers instead of just one.
A word that conveys both abolishing and lifting up could be “reconstruct”, for example, idk I’m not English native or German, but using such language is just intellectual elite masturbation
cancel the family
I’m sceptical about this framing, but the treatment of children is pretty shitty on the societal level.
“Liberation” for kids always gives me Walden Two vibes, and it creeps me out. So personally I’ll give that a hard pass.I would argue too that they’re not a class, there’s nothing artificial to their undeveloped state and it’s time limited.
But I will say this, our society is ageist as hell. Kids are cool, they’re smart in ways that adults often don’t see. And I would argue that children have a wisdom that adults and the world seem to try and beat out of them. Example being, how accepting and unbigoted they are of others, how they instinctively share. There’s something in the heart of children I think we should all strive to get back to.
“Liberation” for kids always gives me Walden Two vibes, and it creeps me out.
If your opinion on a subject is largely rooted in fictional media, vibes and gut feeling, you should probably re-examine it. I seriously recommend giving this thread a read, there have already been a lot of good points brought up and a lot of problems that have historically shown up in this context have been at least partially adressed.
Yeah, that’s fair. I’ll work on it at some point, but right now it’s pretty low on my to do list. especially because I’m not in a position to affect change in that realm. For now I’ll leave this discourse to my betters. Just being honest.
The idea that children are a oppressed class is complicated depending on framing.
However you slice it however children in the west and capitalist society are often viewed as property. They are investments for adults to be taken care off outside the state. Children are supposed to feel obligation to fulfill this roll no matter how they are treated. Should be noticed rich children while often abused do not suffer this frame work often. Which kind of shows its a intersection issue more then anything.
Children are not seen as young humans who we have the privileged to guide and raise so they have a better life. They are tools to be used, mold, and made into the next consumer or overlord.
Meanwhile children when given the chance are very inquisitive by nature.
made into the next consumer or overlord.
And worker, too. A lot of discipline and “education” is really just training children to replicate the patterns of an adult proletarian’s workday and environment

Oh yes, sorry still early for me, consumer was meant for that too but obviously that doesn’t make complete sense.
No problem, I didn’t mean to imply your comment was incomplete. The consumer and worker bit kinda go hand in hand yeah
Althusser enters the chat
I don’t know much, but I’m very open to learn about it.
Classes are defined by how they relate to production. Children relate to it in a unique way. Reproductive labor is central to capitalism to reproduce an indoctrinated, split labor force with predictable skills. Children are not just subject to unpaid reproductive labor, but also forced to shoulder a big part of it. They work on themselves within oppressive institutions like the patriarchal family and bourgeois schools. Within the labor force, they are often it’s weakest part with the lowest amount of organizing and the fewest rights.
If children are a class, are they a revolutionary class? Covid has shown, that the most immediate purpose of the schooling system is not even indoctrination, but detention of children and denial of their natural needs, so their parents can continue wage labor. School strikes therefore can multiply their impact across the economy. In practically every revolutionary political movement, youth are overrepresented and organize not just around their specific issues but also have a strong tendency for solidarity and to consider issues in broader society as they will impact their future.
It takes a village to raise a child. Minimising their childhood trauma and maximising their access to opportunities is how you keep them from rebelling in antisocial ways. I think children deserve a more holistic version of public schools that immerse them in the wider community and grow their talents, showing them that there is a world beyond their parents’ influence while removing some of the burden of that domestic labour from them. I think something akin to Waldorf or Montessori schools with free summer camps, robust community centres, and youth unions representing their interests would achieve that.
children are bourgeois

I don’t think this has an easy answer. It’s sort of a category error IMO to think of children as an “oppressed class”, but certainly they are an extremely vulnerable group.
I do generally think that children and teenagers deserve and benefit from a lot more liberation and autonomy than is traditionally given to them. Younger teenagers are basically at adult-level intelligence, and can in fact navigate almost all situations in life with a bit of guidance and practice… and so we should basically just let them, IMO. With the strong proviso that we also need parenting and support from their community to guide them away from doing all the classic young person dumb shit. One of the major societal problems caused by atomization is the breakdown in social support that children and teenagers used to have more access to, and I think it’s a major reason why sometimes helicopter parenting can be a rational response.
There is also the major and common issue that lots of children and teenagers are trapped in bad situations. Children are not empowered to escape these, but also there may not be any reasonable safe living situation that they could escape to.
There is also the major and common issue that lots of children and teenagers are trapped in bad situations. Children are not empowered to escape these, but also there may not be any reasonable safe living situation that they could escape to.
and any apparatus you might want to build to handle that is at risk of being racist and whatnot. there are times western CPS gets it right but there are a lot of times it doesn’t or where the real solution would be giving the family a few bucks and killing a landlord.
















