• EmmaGoldman [she/her, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    35
    ·
    2 days ago

    Ridiculous, non-falsifiable belief.

    This is equally as well founded a philosophical argument as “I think it’s likely that there is a magic sky daddy who created a world and us to rule it in exactly 6 days, exactly 6000 years ago” or “I think it’s likely that a teapot has always existed in an elliptical orbit between Earth and Mars”

    This is religious delusion, not scientific understanding.

    • purpleworm [none/use name]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      24
      ·
      2 days ago

      But have you considered that we could just use an academic/philosophical-sounding phrase to refer to our whimsical belief, thereby making it sound like it has substance or is maybe even a real field of study? We don’t need to know anything about the “field of study,” or whatever real field of study we might be misappropriating, just name drop it like we do with “Liberation Theology,” despite not ascribing to that religious movement ourselves, or knowing about its history, or anything like that; it’s just a magic word to socially normalize whatever silly thing we feel like.

      It’s the inevitable outcome of cultural osmosis via memes and quips replacing any kind of study or education, that people are just left with vibes and meaningless labels.

      • EmmaGoldman [she/her, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        11
        ·
        2 days ago

        I think it’s really interesting that people wanted to essentially invert the outcome of results from studies on plant intelligence and what that tells us about some animal intelligence.

        If a study determines that a plant and a fruit fly have the same level of intelligence and sentience, your takeaway should be that fruit flies are not sentient and not that plants are. For some reason, many of our comrades took the incorrect outcome that was pushed by clickbait articles instead of spending a really long time reading all the research firsthand.

        I think people don’t want to admit that there is actually a line you can draw somewhere in the animal kingdom, because if you admit that there are animals that can’t think and feel, it feels like you’re conceding a philosophical argument to carnists. The very act of drawing that line feels so bad that people would rather think plants are sentient than admit that maybe a large chunk of invertebrates aren’t. I personally think this is incorrect because sentience shouldn’t determine whether a living being deserves our respect, but I understand why people have a strong reaction to these things.

        • Le_Wokisme [they/them, undecided]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          10
          ·
          2 days ago

          i hear there’s debates about whatever barnacles or bivalves or something that have no nervous system and are incapable of feeling pain

          even if everybody thought it was cool to eat some of the bugs, capitalist mass farming of them would find some way to make it not ok by the strictest standard

          • EmmaGoldman [she/her, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            8
            ·
            2 days ago

            Yes, that’s right. Bivalves don’t have a central nervous system at all. They entirely lack the capability to receive, interpret, perceive, or react to pain, it literally does not exist to them. Scallops are the only member of the family for which there’s any serious debate among professionals as to whether they can sense or experience anything at all.

            Scallops alone have a visual aspect to their reflexive nerves. It works similarly to the way a Venus fly trap uses sensory trichomes to detect contact. Their 200 eyes are basically just on/off light detectors that individually can detect the near field in front of them or the peripheral field further away. They’re unbelievably complex eyes each with this array of square guanine crystals that project a field onto two separate retinas, and yet all the animal gets from it is basically just the ability to flinch based on light and dark. They have a grand total of three ganglia and they’re remarkably electrically quiet compared to the nervous ganglia in a vertebrate animal.

            There’s not a whole lot going on there, but the other bivalves have drastically less.

      • Zorro [he/him]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        2 days ago

        What is the motivation for plant intelligence being a CIA psyop? I missed those struggle sessions but I did read the popscience articles about plants experiencing stress and being able to communicate with other plants in a way that I forgot

        • HamManBad [he/him]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          22 hours ago

          The study was done by someone who was previously a CIA interrogator, the only connection seems to be that the dude really liked polygraphs

          • Zorro [he/him]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            21 hours ago

            What motivation could the CIA have to spread the idea that plants have intelligence? I’m genuinely trying to understand this. It seems weird to me that they would go through this elaborate route to promote carnism and confuse animal rights activists but I also am not an expert on CIA psyops.

            I’m not validating the plant intelligence narrative btw, I just thought it was a weird side effect of idealism dominating in science.

        • Yeah it isn’t literally a CIA psyop, and misuse of that word does irk me.

          It was total clickbait bullshit though, and those pop science articles were intentionally deceptive. Neither plant intercommunication via micorrhizal networks nor the ability for organisms to respond to cell damage actually connote intelligence.

          Some fungi, on the other hand, do appear to demonstrate the capability of discrete point to point communication which could indicate that they’re doing something we don’t yet understand.

  • jack [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    41
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    2 days ago

    Not to take this too seriously, but…

    This is an extremely idealistic view of consciousness as some innate, essentially supernatural quality of living things. Consciousness, like everything else, needs to have a material basis. It’s obviously a very complicated process that demands a great deal of biological ‘computation’ power, and so I’d oppose ascribing it to anything that doesn’t have a large, complex nervous system or something computationally equivalent. I would entertain a spectrum of consciousness that includes all kinds of non-human animals, because I think very little about human consciousness is fundamentally unique and many non-human animals are much closer to us cognitively than we like to recognize. But I don’t think that expands all the way down to bacteria - why not to viruses? Why not to fire, or to wind?

    • EmmaGoldman [she/her, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      20
      ·
      2 days ago

      On an even lower level, we can assume that consciousness requires a net of interconnections and some quantity of communication between those points of connection. That consciousness is a product of communication is typically the most basic assumption that everyone is willing to agree on in phenomenology.

      Single celled organisms are not communicating with each other. There’s no quantum entanglement going on that lets all the E. coli bacteria exist collectively as a gestalt. That sort of non-falsifiable belief is almost never worth discussing because it’s not based in materialist reality.

      • distal@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        7
        ·
        edit-2
        2 days ago

        Single celled organisms are not communicating with each other

        This is incorrect.

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quorum_sensing

        Edit:

        I want to add this in response to your mentioning of quantum entanglement, since you wrote that “There’s no quantum entanglement going on that lets all the E. coli bacteria exist collectively as a gestalt”

        As per Wikipedia on the quantum mind: »These hypotheses posit instead that quantum-mechanical phenomena, such as entanglement and superposition that cause nonlocalized quantum effects, interacting in smaller features of the brain than cells, may play an important part in the brain’s function and could explain critical aspects of consciousness. These scientific hypotheses are as yet unvalidated, and they can overlap with quantum mysticism.«

        Not saying that bacteria are strictly conscious in the way a human or bee is conscious of course.

        • EmmaGoldman [she/her, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          7
          ·
          2 days ago

          Quorum sensing autoinducers don’t work the same way as neurotransmitters, so it’s not really comparable. They have a very limited impact on nearby organisms and have an effect on their local environment rather than a direct form of point to point communication between specifically identified individuals. This is one of those times where trying to explain a concept in plain, colloquial English leads to ambiguity. The sort of communication of which single celled organisms are capable cannot ever result in a broad, networked process of any sort.

          Wikipedia puts it far too politely, the idea that entanglement or superposition could impact any aspect of consciousness is pure woowoo. The kid glove treatment of complete delusion is one of the major problems I have with Wikipedia’s style guide.

          • distal@lemmy.ml
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            5
            ·
            1 day ago

            I mean sure, it’s not comparable. I think at the end of day even bacteria run away from unpleasant stimuli and move in the direction of food. Plants and fungi react to changes in the environment and seem to have coordinated reactions. “Consciousness” has to have emerged somewhere. Within evolution we can observe the emergence of infrastructure for coordination, signalling and so on. Somewhere along the line action potentials become a thing – I don’t have to tell you much about it.

            The human brain can recurse, it engages in grammar and so forth. We have amygdalae, there is some sort of emotive system. Where in evolution can point and say: »there is consciousness!«? Especially when there are interactions with non-neuronal cells like glia that don’t really mesh with the traditional synaptic view, as well as inter-organic interactions related to the immune system and gut. Personally, I don’t think it’s terribly wrong to say that bacteria have some sort of very basal experience. A stupid calculator is a CPU too. Subjectivity or subjective experience is of course out of the picture here and I think that the consciousness debate is, bluntly put, DOA owing to the fact that there are seemingly as many conceptions of consciousness as there are people working on the “issue”, for some it’s closely related to subjectivity for others it’s bioelectrical patterns, others, who really don’t know shit from shinola, like our friend in the screenshot project their idealism. They think bacteria could ride bicycles.

            What all of this should maybe tell us that consciousness itself is hard to grasp from a typical Popperian viewpoint, even when it involves human subjects who are able to report experiences. I myself am much more a fan of the Buddhist perspective (of all things), that there is probably not much to it, but that is a stylistic preference to be honest. I could not come up with many good reasons to weigh in on this debate in a way that conclusively links consciousness to any one mechanism. I hope any of this made sense. You’re welcome to correct me.

            • I have no corrections for you, you have a very good understanding of the general playing field of phenomenology!

              Consciousness is a really confusing thing to wrap one’s head around, especially when talking about non-human consciousness. It’s often easier to sort of just study a critter for a while and “know it when you see it.” Like, you can pretty easily tell that a cat or a dog or a honey bee is conscious, but it isn’t easily identifiable in something even as complex as a fruit fly, a starfish, mining bees, or some ant species.

              We can see goal oriented behaviors in creatures as simple as a tardigrade, but there seems to be a general fuzzy region maybe around 250,000-750,000 neurons where creatures go from like a meat robot to being a conscious individual. I personally subscribe to the belief that consciousness is some sort of emergent phenomenon which becomes apparent somewhere around there.

              What sort of qualia would a single celled organism even be able to sense, I wonder?

      • jack [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        8
        ·
        2 days ago

        I only make a single assumption: consciousness requires substantial processing power. And that’s not just an assumption pulled out my butt. We have no direct evidence of consciousness outside of the human experience, and the shared feature there is big brains with lots of processing power. What assumptions do you think I’m making?

        • CeffTheCeph@kbin.earth
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          11
          ·
          2 days ago

          You’re assuming consciousness is an algorithmic, input/output process. Others may assume consciousness is non-algorithmic, two very different philosophical approaches.

            • jack [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              8
              ·
              2 days ago

              I’d also appreciate an elaboration on this idea. I’m pretty anti-‘individual organisms are a thing’ because I find it undialectical and metaphysical, so I’d be curious to hear more about this.

            • CeffTheCeph@kbin.earth
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              3
              ·
              23 hours ago

              Algorithmic processes produce an output based on the input. Something gets input into the machine, like visual stimulation for example, the machine takes that input and performs a series of logical operations (the algorithm) on the data and produces a specific output. In this example when we see the colour blue (the outcome), our eyes take in as input the wavelength, frequency, intensity, etc. of the light we are seeing and our brains take that data, run it through logical steps like comparing it to past light frequency data we have in memory, or sorting it along a spectrum of different light frequencies that we are also seeing at the same time or whatever. These type of algorithmic processes are completely deterministic, as in the output can be determined based on the features of the input data and how that data gets manipulated through the algorithm’s logical steps.

              Non-algorithmic processes occur when there is no set of logical steps that will determine the outcome based on the input data. Quantum mechanics, for example, is a stochastic process where the outcome of a measurement cannot be determined by the input parameters, but rather the outcome is determined by a set of statistical probabilities of possible outcomes. Of course the Schrodinger equation is deterministic and algorithmic, however when an outcome is measured that determinism collapses along with the wave function and the measurement becomes stochastic in nature. The collapsing of the wave function is a non-algorithmic process and there is no consensus among physicists on how that ‘collapse’ process actually works in nature, hence the plethora of different interpretations of quantum mechanics out there today.

              • jack [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                4
                ·
                22 hours ago

                Interesting, but I don’t think this makes any difference to my point. I don’t care if it’s stochastic or algorithmic, it’s still material and still requires some sort of processing basis.

                • CeffTheCeph@kbin.earth
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  17 hours ago

                  From the context of your argument I am interpreting the ‘processing power’ you are talking about as the physical power or energy needed to perform physical work as input data is being physically manipulated by a series of logic gates per the algorithm.

                  Perhaps I am misinterpreting what you are getting at when you mean ‘processing power’. The distinction I am trying to point out is that there is no way for any algorithm to be able to generate a true random number. All of the energy in the universe converted into processing power will still never be able to produce a true random number as an output through an algorithm.

                  I am also likely misinterpreting what you mean by ‘material’. Is the number 3 a material thing? We can use materials to interpret, or represent the number 3 in the physical world, but the number 3 itself does not have any material basis in our physical world, it is just an abstraction created in our brains. If our physical brains do not exist to be able to create that physical abstraction, does the number 3 even exist at all, does it have a material basis?

                  I do not mean to argue about this at all, there is no right or wrong here. I’m trying to point out that some people assume consciousness is algorithmic, some people assume it isn’t. People who assume consciousness is algorithmic are the same people who believe that the genAI that we have today will eventually become conscious, or sentient, once there are enough data centers to be able to provide enough processing power to eventually reach the level of consciousness we are talking about.

                  People who assume consciousness is non-algorithmic genuinely believe that the genAI we have today will never actually be conscious, because all our AI is today is a bottom-up algorithm iterated billions and billions of times using all of the data that exists in our world. However, if consciousness really is non-algorithmic, just like the case of more processing power never being able to produce a random output, more data centers will never able to produce consciousness, or AGI.

                  Roger Penrose’s 1993 book ‘Shadows of the Mind’ is a great resource to see the distinction. There Penrose very thoroughly distinguishes between top-down and bottom-up algorithms, and the difference between algorithmic and non-algorithmic processes. His description from 1993 of what today we call ‘deepfakes’, for example, is incredibly interesting.

                  Again from the algorithmic standpoint, I think my favourite description of how our genAI works today comes from Jonathan Swift’s ‘Gulliver’s Travels’ from 1726. In part 3 of the tale we are introduced to a technocracy and a description of a device called the ‘Engine’ in the Academy of Lagado. This machine is made up of all of the words in their language written out on a giant grid. There are a series of rotating levers that changes the order of all of the words on the grid. The argument is that if you rotate the levers enough times the words will eventually arrange themselves into logical sentences that say real things. If you write down all of the logical sentences that the machine creates, and if you keep rotating the levers billions and billions of times across thousands of different Engines writing down every logical sentence that comes up, eventually you will have written down everything that is knowable in their universe.

              • pcalau12i@lemmygrad.ml
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                3
                ·
                edit-2
                20 hours ago

                Every statistical process is deterministic over an ensemble. If I flip a perfectly fair coin an infinite number of times, the distribution of 50%/50% ceases to be random probabilities for a given flip, but becomes the precise physical proportions over that ensemble which the system will converge to. Ensemble descriptions are always deterministic, so of course the equations on their own evolve deterministically, because, as Blokhintsev discusses in his book The Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics, the theory is a statistical theory, and as such, it should be understood as one that describes the deterministic evolution of ensembles.

                The so-called “collapse” is mathematically just a Bayesian knowledge update. An ensemble description only tells you the proportions of the system, again, over an ensemble, not in an individual case. You can use your knowledge as to how it behaves over ensembles to serve as a “best guess” as to what its outcome may be in an individual case, but in an individual case, there is only one outcome. If you know what the outcome is, you can then apply Bayes’ theorem to update that guess.

                There isn’t anything physically “collapsing” as if the ensemble description described the physical system in the individual case but then physically “collapsed” to the individual description when you looked at it. Mathematically, that cannot even be made consistent with quantum mechanics if it were true. The ensemble description never physically existed in an individual run of an experiment; it only describes its behavior over an ensemble. The “collapse” is, again, just a Bayesian knowledge update after you gain new information about how the system actually behaved in that individual case.

                I don’t see what you mean to say it is “non-algorithmic” as Bayes’ theorem can be expressed as an algorithm: just reduce the probabilities for every event incompatible with the new evidence you gathered to 0% since you know they cannot occur, which will make the probability distribution no longer sum to 100%, and so then you normalize the probability distribution so it sums to 100% again. That’s an algorithm.

                Nothing about these two aspects of the theory (a deterministic evolution which you can “collapse” at measurement) even differ from a classical statistical theory, and so they don’t even capture anything about what fundamentally distinguishes quantum and classical mechanics. Classical statistical theories are also formulated in terms of a deterministically-evolving ensemble description, which serves as your “best guess” for any given individual case, and after observing the outcome in that individual case, you can “collapse” the probability distribution down by applying Bayes’ theorem to the actually-observed outcome.

                There are fundamental differences between quantum mechanics and classical mechanics, but the majority of times when people list fundamental differences, they are basically just talking about statistics, and don’t understand statistics, so they end up mystifying statistics.

                • CeffTheCeph@kbin.earth
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  14 hours ago

                  Thanks for this!

                  I very much agree that I have over-simplified here, and likely mystified things a lot. I was only trying to point out that assuming our brains work like computers with lots of neurons and processing power implies an assumption that consciousness is algorithmic in it’s process. An assumption that consciousness is non-algorithmic, in that there is no way to demonstrate that outcomes are a direct result of a set of specific logical steps, is equally as valid an assumption to make about consciousness, I think.

        • RedMari@reddthat.com
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          1 day ago

          What Trashcan said. Also assuming that consciousness needs a material basis. That’s the hard problem of science, we don’t know how nonmaterial conscious connects with the material. Also assuming that consciousness requires immense processing power. There is so much unknown about the nature of consciousness. I appreciate that your comment responses show a willingness to discuss civilly and engage with other perspectives.

          • jack [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            4
            ·
            1 day ago

            Also assuming that consciousness needs a material basis.

            Nah, this one I’ll stand by pretty firmly. The world is material and all phenomena within it have material bases. Literally every single thing in existence definitionally has a material basis.

            • RedMari@reddthat.com
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              16 hours ago

              Sir our senses can’t even perceive objective reality. Hard to state much with objective certainty when considering that.

              • jack [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                3
                ·
                16 hours ago

                Ok well our non-senses can’t even perceive subjective reality so let me know if you have a better option. If you’re just gonna do some Cartesian idealism you were definitely disproven about 300 years ago so I’m not really concerned. The world is material. I’ll believe you when you can demonstrate otherwise.

  • Zoift [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    40
    ·
    2 days ago

    I’ve been tuning in to the noosphere of the microbiome, and im sad to report its just mostly a tidal wave of qualia about being hungry and being eaten, and being exploded. Theyre not depressed per-se, but they are all screaming.

    Also there are the lithotrophs way down in the leylines who are just vibin, literally the only lifeforms that are having a good time.

  • AssortedBiscuits [they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    1 day ago

    This is just panpsychism. Panpsychists say that physical matter itself has a corresponding mindstate in which consciousness arises. This is one way of resolving the hard problem of consciousness. Since physical matter has a corresponding mindstate, panpsychists can speak of the subjectivity of bacteria or rocks or rain. To panpsychists, whether these aggregates of matter have neurons or silicon wafers isn’t relevant to whether they can experience subjectivity.

  • EatMoreMacroplastics [she/her]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    19
    ·
    2 days ago

    If this is true, i’m fairly certain that some of my friends’ gut microbiome is not an orgy but a 5000 posts 12 upbears 40 bans struggle session about which dog breed is the most reactionary pet you can keep.

  • queermunist she/her@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    2 days ago

    I don’t know what the point of believing this is.

    Okay, whatever, let’s say they’re conscious. Who cares? Now what?

    • WhatDoYouMeanPodcast [comrade/them]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      2 days ago

      If I could hazard a guess, panpsychism would be a framework through which one would come to decipher consciousness. Experiments therein might lead to advancements in neuroscience. That would allow us to use neuralink more effectively so you can vibecode your entire existence and then be like Avatar where you grow a ponytail that allows you to connect with the world tree and see your ancestors.

    • CrawlMarks [he/him]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      2 days ago

      That is a valid critique. Given how we treat other humans whe know are conscious. Animals are conscious and they fare little better

  • whiterose19 [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    2 days ago

    why stop at organisms. Everyday rocks make decisions like am i gonna vibrate this way? am I gonna vibrate that way? The ions travel around in ways that cannot currently be comprehended by science.