Explanation

  • something that is fucked to me, and off center to the point of the tweet, is how monetary policy in US political economy is basically in thrall to this “money supply” mindset, especially in the neoliberal dominant era. government spending used to mean something else in the New Deal era. but all that stopped, and the only game in town is a single lever that adjusts the pain of borrowing.

    the logic goes: higher interest rates means businesses contract, owners lay off workers, and demand goes down. thus reducing the price of things because people are broke. also, nobody wants to buy a big ticket item like a car or a house or take out a HELOC to fix a roof when interest rates are high, because the loan takes a bigger chunk of your ass.

    and maybe there was some logic to that when 25% of the population wasn’t functionally unemployed and that inflation was not being driven by the production and transport capacity of liquid fuel being shithammered for 8 months with an increasingly bleak future.

    but i do not see how raising interest rates is going to do anything but bring more pain. the housing market is already batshit from speculators and short term rentals eating the excess inventory. no chance it slows down housing prices. tariffs have fucked construction, which was already pretty fucked anyway. people need places to live and everybody already moved back in with their parents 10 years ago. cars are a shit deal and lot inventory is high, used cars are astronomical. everybody with the option is already heavily disincentivized from doing anything except surviving, so making borrowing hurt more is just making everything worse but i don’t see it actually slowing down consumption much more than it already is and was going to be with all the cuts to federal programs.

    trump is obviously pissed, because low interest rates are when rich people can run wild with borrowing and VCs can do their scams and ponzi bubbles with all the easy credit. but the fed doesn’t want to play along because the dogma is to raise rates when inflation goes up. i kinda assumed his attempts to pressure the fed for lower or at least stable interest rates would be kind of successful, but i guess that ship has sailed.

    anyway all signs point towards a hard winter and policymakers at every institution doing what they can to make it worse than it had to be.

    • Soot [any]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      19
      ·
      edit-2
      12 hours ago

      I like citing the Bank of England on interest rates v inflation

      Higher interest rates mean higher payments on many mortgages and loans, meaning people must spend more on them and less on other things. Saving becomes more attractive because the returns are higher and it becomes more expensive to take out a loan. These things all discourage consumers and businesses from spending.

      The explicit reason to raise interest rates is so that poor people in debt have less money and can’t buy stuff they likely need, and we give that money to rich people as a payment for not spending it.

      Oh you’re drowning in debt and can’t buy food? Sorry pal but that’s literally the explicit, intended effect. Now pay Mr Moneybags another hundred so he doesn’t increase the demand on golden yachts.


      For comparison, China far more heavily relies on other mechanisms to control money/goods supply. Their interest rate is significantly more stable, and their inflation rates continue to be low despite massive growth. Which has resulted in people earning more money while food, necessities, and houses are not becoming equally more expensive. Which is an alien concept to my western brain.

    • queermunist she/her@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      17
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      19 hours ago

      Historically, the market becomes more volatile and trades lower in October. Maybe this is The Money deciding to put their thumbs on the scale of the Midterms to neuter Trump’s agenda so he can’t fuck anything else up. Or it’s an inside job (despite Trump’s bluster) and Trump plans to somehow use a market crash before the Midterms as an excuse to do… something?

      The whole thing is weird.

      • dead [he/him]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        5 hours ago

        I would like to point out that /c/slop is the second most active comm as of this past week and purely because people just post everything in here. The only similarity between posts in this comm are that they are all written with a tone of condescension.

        I am told that this comm is to protect hexbears by being a space for quarantine of offensive content. This is a lie. If this statement were true, then it wouldn’t be the second largest comm and growing. It might become the largest comm before the end of the year.

        The comm exists purely as a space for hexbear posters to be smug. The comm is treated as a space for bullying.

        And it makes me wonder? Who am I to feel condescension towards the main negotiator for the latest victim of US imperialism?

        Ghalibaf has shown himself to be a great threat to US global hegemony. Ghalibaf is the representative for ~90 million people, standing in the face of the Greater Satan.

        If Ghalibaf posts math memes, then I fucking love math memes. He sets the standard for what is cool, based on his achievements. When Neil deGrasse Tyson posts math memes, it is cringe because he only prides himself on being an enlightened atheist. It is the people who mock Ghalibaf who are slop.

        • buckykat [none/use name]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          4
          ·
          5 hours ago

          This post isn’t mocking Ghalibaf, though. The title is playing on the joke of Amerikkkans being so uneducated and racist that they are scared of things like algebra and Arabic numerals.

          This comm exists because a subset of the mods really hate Twitter screenshots, started a fight with the users about it, then lost.

    • micnd90 [he/him,any]@hexbear.netOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      18
      ·
      20 hours ago

      Its a slop because behind the equation this tweet is just an Iranian uncle shitposting on twitter. Uncle’s basically saying Fed increasing interest rate would not really cut inflation because there’s still no supply, because they (Iran) control the supply of oil.

      • dead [he/him]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        45
        ·
        20 hours ago

        Just an Iranian uncle? MB Ghalibaf was the lead negotiator in the Memorandum of Understanding ceasefire agreement at the Islamabad talks. The agreement promised that the US would give Iran $300 billion dollars and Trump signed the agreement in France.

        As long as Iran is successfully resisting US Imperialism, I would say the lead negotiator of their country is actually pretty smart and probably deserves some respect.