Pictured: deep-nesting in mailing list form.

Not pictured: This thread actually goes all the way back to mid-october.

In particular, quotes from this email have been making the rounds recently

as a hypothetical example: if i live in a territory that permits slavery, and by law i am granted sole ownership of the products of that forced labor, and then i use that to create contributions to gnu emacs, complete with copyright assignment, and it is technically correct, and, above all, you, the emacs maintainers are aware of how this was produced, would it be ethical to accept those contributions?

Our answer must be YES.

Any other answer is a first step towards splitting our community along the many lines of political and ideological divides that have nothing to do with software freedoms. Right now we have contributors from all over the world, despite the differences in their regimes and political systems, differences in ideologies, and even in the very interpretation of the notion of “freedom”. You are suggesting to subject the contributors to some examination of the principles they uphold, the ethics of their day-to-day activities, their views on matters of policies and important international events, etc. This will immediately fracture our community into many different enclaves. And that’s exactly my point, and the main reason why I must reject the “Human Emacs” initiative, as it is presented to us.

Dawg, the “splitting our community” ship has sailed. It’s fucking gone. The battle lines throughout the entire ecosystem of Free Software have been growing more and more entrenched for months. Dozens of projects have already been forked. Countless people have abandoned software that they are familiar with and have been using for decades to reduce their exposure to slop. A lot of maintainers have ditched projects they’ve contributed to for years to find another niche for themselves, or leave Free Software entirely. You have one of the most active channels on libera.chat discussing and preparing for a fork depending on the GNU project’s decision here. It is time to choose a side, or be swept into eternal irrelevance. Even the libertarian dweebs in Rush understood this.

it is my worry that the fsf and gnu’s apparent narrow focus on legality and technical correctness in the framing of llm contributions ignores the much larger issues with supporting human freedom, and, as such, becomes hypocritcal: free software is free in name only when it is used for subjugation or created from subjugation.

There’s no hypocrisy here, only the realization and understanding that we cannot fix everything in this world, even if we tried, not via developing and distributing software. So we limit ourselves to solving a few of the problems, and leave the rest to other communities. (Of course, people who contribute to Emacs can well be members of those other communities as well.)

this example is hypothetical and not intended to display any real or imagined link to how llms are created and operated. it is only intended as a philosophical point on how a narrow focus on license legality and technical correctness are, at times, inadequate in the pursuit of the larger goal of liberty for all humanity.

The Free Software movement doesn’t pursue the goal of “liberty for all humanity”. If you think it does, you are gravely mistaken. Our goals are different, and are well described elsewhere.

Well, maybe it fucking should!

As I wrote on Mastodon, you couldn’t ask for a more concise summary of why the movement has failed. Why the entire world is being crushed under the boot of surveillance tech, and its applications in marketing, propaganda, social manipulation, and weapons systems, while one percent of the computing public plays around with their linux distros like toy trains.

  • KnilAdlez [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    25
    ·
    13 days ago

    What is stunning me about this is that no only is the conclusion wrong, the justification given has the be the worst possible argument one could make for it.

  • doubledealer [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    17
    ·
    13 days ago

    Principles matter, and being a lead or main dev doesn’t mean you have any, or that you even belong in a decision making position besides how to best code something.

    The current model I see of “contribute to a project I like > try to make the project align to my principles > get overruled by fascists who control the project and above in associated orgs > fork” seems fraught, and under liberalism is probably the best to hope for. Very inefficient though and your contributions are ultimately helping achieve fascist ends, so their toleration and support makes sense.

    I wonder if a Communist Free Software Foundation that sets the principles, governs democratically, and then manages projects could be sustainable.

  • Chana [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    13
    ·
    13 days ago

    Amazing. Also nobody uses emacs except for old heads that will die soon enough and highly ideologically committed libre software advocates so “not taking sides” will doom the project.

  • companero [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    12
    ·
    13 days ago

    It seems like big MIT/BSD-licensed projects tend to be more anti-AI than copyleft ones, ironically.

    I’ve been using Gram as my editor for a while, but I feel kinda grossed out by the fact that it is still built on a mountain of slop (Zed), and it’s full of bugs. The maintainer is doing a great job trying to clean it up, but it’s a herculean task. Was considering switching to a simpler, more traditional editor like Vim/Emacs/Helix until I looked around and saw that they are also embracing AI jokerfied

  • TrashGoblin [he/him, they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    13 days ago

    Thanks for posting this. I’ve been involved with the Human Emacs mailing list from the start, and I was shocked by the reaction when we first presented the letter to emacs- devel. I had thought the divide over AI mapped pretty well onto the divide between the Free Software and Open Source “communities”. Emacs is a core part of my slow and retro computing practice and if it started getting ensloppified, I don’t know what I could do other than stick with an old version.

  • Sanctus@anarchist.nexus
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    13 days ago

    I can’t help but feel like the slavery analogy is a little over the top. Stolen labor to make them, yeah, but the bot doesnt feel or think. You can’t physically harm the bots. They are not conscious let alone intelligent or even beings for that matter.

    • PorkrollPosadist [he/him, they/them]@hexbear.netOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      13
      ·
      13 days ago

      Earlier in the thread (which I don’t blame anybody for skipping), it is made clear that this analogy is a hypothetical. The scenario isn’t meant to say LLMs are equivalent to slavery, but it is pitched to ask (paraphrased) “is there any situation where the origin of a contribution would be disqualifying?”

  • AssortedBiscuits [they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    12 days ago

    Honestly, even RMS’s 4 freedoms show limitations. Much of it has to do with RMS’s ideological blind spot as a libertarian socialist. For example, Freedom 1 only makes sense within the context of a society where people aren’t gatekept from acquiring coding skills. Just making software be open source doesn’t mean much if almost nobody can understand code if or if the code is impossible to parse as a human, which is what we’re approaching with slop code. Without a broader movement to end capitalism, libre software is about as meaningful as joining some commune.

    Libre software itself was already standing on a not great foundation, but at least it was a well-intentioned if ineffective anti-capitalist movement. Meanwhile, open source software is just capitalist recuperation of libre software. The problem was that there wasn’t a clear delineation between the two owning to most LS advocates not understanding or taking seriously the political ramifications (we speak of FLOSS or FOSS erasing the libre or even just OSS erasing the free as well, but nobody outside of RMS cares about LS vs GS). The result is that many LS advocates haven’t been politicized enough, acting more like OSS advocates who “just care about the tech.”

  • Life is Tetris@leminal.space
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    13 days ago

    You are making a lot of leaps here, selectively quoting the Emacs devs too. They clearly say “The GNU project as a whole would take a stand, then we will evaluate.”. And “Most problems in the world can’t be solved by free software”. ; The genesis of the thread itself was a wall of text on thin ground, threatening a fork based on a speculative future. The Emacs devs engaged with so much thought and patience, while the OP had one shallow response. The picture being painted is the opposite of that.