Much like a CEO, these people think that sitting around, reading posts, live streaming, and posting are “work”, as opposed to what they really are, which is a way to avoid getting a real job.
live streaming is work, that’s why i don’t do it
Live streaming is not work. It is parasitical to work, it likely creates negative labor value.
Love me some SnapCube though fr.
Live streaming is not work. It is parasitical to work, it likely creates negative labor value.
Is creating a TV-show work?
Is live-streaming creating a TV-show?
to a certain extent, yeah. you are using your time and some capital to produce a commodity(entertainment). its basically a simplified version of a tv show
edited to add more of my thoughts
To the same extent that farting is shitting?
Edit: Btw I am only being half serious here. However, the pinnacle of live-streaming was Jerma’s House streams, and that shit was absolutely a TV show, but most streams don’t even come close to that level.
To the same extent that farting is shitting?
Come on, that’s not serious.
To jump on your edit abit, simply creating a commodity is not producing labor value.
Labor value is only created when that commodity interacts with society in a way that reproduces or transforms the social relation. Say I pump water and trade it to you for clothing, the labor value is dictated not by the scarcity of the water or the clothing, but by if the amount of water and clothing that is traded that allows for this exchange to continue forever without either of us profiting from the exchange. If I pump too much water and exchange it to you for the same amount of clothing, then the exchange value may have decreased, but the labor value remains the same because I have still produced something that allows for the reproduction of the social relation. If I pump so much water out that there is no more water left, then I have, ultimately, created no labor value.
However, labor value also has to do with time spent doing something. So, if I spend three hours pumping water to trade you for clothes that took you four hours to make, then technically I have come out ahead. However, if I trade you three hours of water for three hours of clothes, then we remain even. The key to the consistent creation of labor value is balancing these needs of production, so that when I trade you three hours of water, it is worth three hours of clothing production. Or more complex, so everyone is trading everything that is needed to sustain a society in such a way that everybody is working around the same amount of time to sustain it. Marx, like many economists, believed this to be around like, two to three hours a day give or take (and this was before automation in the 1800s) which would leave the rest of the day to like do whatever.
In addition to this, Marx is pretty clear that these rules of labor value mostly apply to socially necessary commodities, with art (as we could potentially consider TV shows or streaming) not being classified as a commodity, being subject much more to individual or shifting social tastes than social necessity. If we don’t eat we die, but I can probably go my whole life never owning a Picasso.
If we deal with these things as commodities, the issue with TV shows and streaming is that the labor value itself is extremely far removed from the actual consumption of the product, which means that the commodity relationships are extremely obscured. Indeed, it is likely that both of them are extremely inefficient or even ineffective creators of labor value.
In the case of a TV show, dozens of people are spending hundreds of hours to create a commodity, that then thousands (or millions or whatever) of people then spend fractions of their hours to purchase, but also spend millions of hours to consume well after the initial labor value was completed. And that is not to mention the labor value involved in the production of the devices that run the media or host it. It’s not a simple commodity exchange, as in sometimes both a product (the show) and a service (the subscription). So do TV shows have labor value? Certainly there is labor value in the initial production, and even some in the hosting, but a large deal of the value comes from the exchange cause that has nothing really to do with the hours of labor that were put in, simply surplus exchange value being gained from the company owning the TV show. That said, the question then lies more in if you could eliminate a TV show from the world and the world would still keep going. Therein lies the 'well it’s just art" angle. So the issue lies less in the labor value of any individual TV show, but in the process of the creation of TV shows as commodities.
For streaming, this becomes even more difficult because streaming is essentially live-performance, which again, puts it not under commodity production, but under art. Ignoring that, classifying how the labor value is generated is extremely difficult, because if the viewing is free, then what social relation is exactly is being transformed or reproduced? If you were just paying a subscription, the relationship is simpler. They are spending hours creating something, but you are viewing it for those same hours. If it is free, then the exchange appears to be the parasocial relationship, which is likely an unsustainable commodity relationship, as that is basically just a simulated friendship. More interestingly though, if the streamer is creating labor value, then does that mean that chat is also creating labor value?
And this doesn’t even get into how advertising affects all of this, which is a whole other can of worms.
Anyways, sorry to go down a bit of a rabbit hole there.
That said, the question then lies more in if you could eliminate a TV show from the world and the world would still keep going.
Not unchanged to some degree.
If it is free, then the exchange appears to be the parasocial relationship
The entirety of your logic rests on this and it is false. The exchange is advertising and subscriptions for entertainment.
Just because a job creates “low or inefficient labor value” doesn’t mean it isn’t a job, just that it does, and that’s straight from Capital.
I stream and make videos. It is entertainment work, there is absolutely no possible way to construe it otherwise without leaping through hoops. To conflate the parasocial aspects of public-facing entertainment jobs with the idea that entertainment isn’t work is bullshit.
You are going to great lengths to discredit a worker’s output. It reminds me precisely of the arguments people make against sex work.
Chat are the real working class.
Seems she’s feeling Laura Doomer
But I don’t want to start a Laura Rumor
Laura Boomer
I hope we dont see the Laura Coomer arc
Theres no way that hasn’t happened yet.

Loomer has been leashed

should have been garrotted
I’m inclined to say this is a signal that the right are demoralised by this election.
Remember how fucked we get when things go badly for us? After Corbyn and things going very very badly for the UK left work basically completely collapsed, nobody was motivated to do anything.
She’s taking time for herself because they’re demoralised.
Yay depression-dopamine dynamics!
the sense that the work I do actually matters
I have questions. why does she keep calling what she does work, and whomever told her it matters has a wall to stand in front of. Is she actually getting married? who would marry that vile person? she must be marrying someone as soulless as she is. what a terrible breakfast conversation these two must have. Yuk.
came down the golden escalator
lol
She’s just jumping off a sinking ship. The hiatus is her putting distance between what she has been doing now and her inevitable pivot towards something new.
The right are going through the same thing we go through when things go very badly for us. They are demoralised and their motivation is collapsing.
Most right wing personalities are grifters with no real beliefs. I think a lot of the pro-Trump grifters are seething at people like Tucker Carlson who is unfortunately smart enough to pivot away years ago. Maybe she’s a genuine true believer in which case lmao
There have to be a shit load of true believers or else there wouldn’t have been Trumpism in the first place. Some of the people we think are grifters are just genuinely disgusting and very stupid people.

Rats are deciding the ship is sinking now?
This is what is going through the head of all your racist family members:

A spokesperson is looming in the future, but only after a spa day at Mar-a-lagoI have wanted to redo my studio for a year, but I keep pushing it all off, because that’s what I do. I push things off that matter to me and my happiness to do for others 24/7, and I think I need to change that for a brief moment.
She just cares so much about other people. That’s really the problem here.
I thought it’s because she (maybe accidentally) admitted to getting paid to post.













