• InevitableSwing [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    2 hours ago

    What “bodily integrity” does the Constitution protect? […] According to Engelhardt, the right applies to instances such as sexual assault by a police officer or prisoners being forced to take medication.

  • 7bicycles [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    2 hours ago

    Reading this article this seems to be mostly legalese formality bullshit, i.e. whatever article, amendment or whatever “guarantees” bodily autonomy is not applicable here. Might well be some other part of the constitution would, but that’s not what’s being decided here so who knows. It makes sense in the theoretical concept of checks and balances in that the court can’t just say “well your lawsuit here is wrong but here we provide a better argument for you”, allthough some judges are occasionaly inclined to inch that way in the ruling, as honestly that’d also be not great given the role of a court.

    I think it does, however, display a glaring fault in the theoretical checks and balances in that the role figuring out how “this has to be fucking illegal / unconstitutional somehow” which I think is a given here is left to concerned citizens and then whatever saul goodman-ass character they manage to be able to pay for if no NGO - decidedly not part of the checks and balances - steps in.

    Like if you wanted actual checks and balances and without even changing any of the basics of the systems you’d have a 4th branch whose sole job it is to take citizen complaints and then have a team of lawyers start suing the government on the governments dime. I freely admit this is pretty rife for hostile takeovers, too, but then so is every other branch and that runs on “well surely they wouldn’t” and everyone accept that.