• happybaby [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    2 hours ago

    Amazing reporting by the NYT, as usual. It’s amazing that they can compartmentalize reality and ignore so much of it. I really don’t get their numbers (beside the fact that they are comparing two totally different systems with different motivations and goals) they said

    “The big problem is that the revenue mismatch with the Chinese models relative to capex is arguably more extreme than the U.S. case,” Mr. Wright said.

    American A.I. companies spend roughly five to six times what their Chinese counterparts do, but bring in substantially more money. China’s six leading A.I. firms collectively generate about one-tenth the combined revenue of OpenAI and Anthropic, according to Epoch AI, a nonprofit research organization.

    but it looks like China’s Z.Ai had earnings of -$0.67 Billion USD for 2025 while OpenAI lost $8 bn. It must be a masterstroke of framing- American A.I. companies spend roughly five to six times what their Chinese counterparts do, but bring in substantially more money dozens of more dollars.

    And did they just admit that capitalism does not lead to the greatest social good?

    China’s embrace of open-source A.I. has made that imbalance even harder to overcome. By allowing developers to use and modify their models freely, Chinese companies have accelerated the global spread of their technology. But that strategy has also undermined their ability to profit from it. Companies can charge for access, only to see rivals offer the same technology at lower prices. Fierce price wars have squeezed profits further.

    Z.ai, a Chinese A.I. start-up, learned that lesson in August when it released its latest open-source model, GLM-5.3 Flash. The company halved prices for two weeks to entice users to run the model on Z.ai’s servers rather than their own. But competitors quickly moved in. By November, roughly 20 rival providers were charging less than Z.ai for access to its own technology, according to Open Router, a platform connecting users with A.I. models.

    Competition is good but ofc not when the Chinese do it, even among themselves. Monopoly is good! But not when the Chinese do it a la electric cars.

    Here is a long read but a great insight into the different approach China takes with regard to AI https://liangwenfeng.art/index.en

    Spoiler: it’s use-value, not exchange-value

    • MolotovHalfEmpty [he/him]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      1 hour ago

      China’s embrace of open-source A.I. has made that imbalance even harder to overcome. By allowing developers to use and modify their models freely, Chinese companies have accelerated the global spread of their technology. But that strategy has also undermined their ability to profit from it.

      Even if you take the Western capitalist reading that the Chinese economy is basically just trying to do ‘capitalism with centralised Chinese characteristics’ the idea of writing this off as a weakness is a sirdly premature and also something they’ve done before, to their discredit.

      China frequently uses different companies, regions, or approaches to technology (and sociological or ecological problems using technology) as a sort of lab trial to see what works, why, and how - without the primary concern of profit. And the western business press scoffed at it right up until they didn’t - with agriculture, with solar tech, with transport, nuclear etc. And they seem to be doing exactly the same with AI.