Photo by user “Valdemar” on parovoz IS
i’ve observed that many on the left tend to be overly enthusiastic about high-speed rail, perhaps due to misunderstanding the success of china’s network.
high-speed rail is indeed impressive and serves as an important element of transport infrastructure, but it cannot fulfil every transport requirement, nor was it intended to do so! a rail system’s usefulness depends on the network supporting it, which should mainly include regional trains, and freight services, perhaps also narrow-gauge lines, where appropriate, not solely the headline-grabbing high-speed corridors. while speed is important, factors such as coverage, access, capacity, and the types of services the network can provide are much more significant.
regional rail is what makes a passanger network practical on a daily basis. most journeys are not made between distant megacities; people require reliable connections between towns, suburbs, smaller cities and regional centres. a train station that is difficult to access except by car, or that serves only a limited number of major destinations, is of limited value. strong links between high-speed rail and commuter or regional services allow more communities to benefit from faster intercity travel.
freight rail is essential, despite being seen as less glamorous than passenger services. freight requires capacity, reliable paths, and infrastructure suited to heavy loads, rather than top speeds. dedicated high-speed lines often have steeper gradients and more costly alignments, which can be unsuitable for freight operations. focusing rail strategy solely on passenger speed overlooks one of rail’s key economic functions: moving goods efficiently at scale.
also, narrow-gauge rail is criminally overlooked and warrants investment based on its own merits. track gauge is a matter of engineering rather than a measure of a railway’s quality. narrow-gauge lines can provide services in areas where terrain, existing infrastructure, or low demand make a new, high-speed standard-gauge line impractical. while they may not support high speeds, they still offer reliable passenger connections and freight movement. insisting that every line emulate high-speed rail risks disregarding useful existing routes or serving communities unable to justify the expense of a new corridor.
also, china’s system is by no means perfect, with its CRH200J trainsets actually being a fairly good example of the image of hsr being used to make rail service worse, not better:
from january 5, 2019, CRH200J trains were introduced into passenger service and replaced some conventional trains (“green trains”). however, while the regular trains were categorized as “k”, “t” or “z”, their replacements are in the higher fare category “d”, which belongs to the high-speed group. however, the train itself does not fit category d in terms of speed, as it moves much slower, only 130 km/h! (not to mention that service reportedly got considerably worse.) the only reasons for the fare-increase was thus only the missaplied “hsr” marque. the same trainsets are used on the much-lauded china-laos “hsr”, btw, which seemed to have caused much envy among western leftists, despite moving slower than the american acela.
yes. Here in yurop somehow we lost quality of service since the TGV. Before TGV we had night train, autorail (you could put your CAR on the train). TGV are fly when you see them but they’re expensive, sometime more than flying, the network is not harmonized between different countries, and they’re private.
Dont get me wrong they’re pretty comfortable and beats planes in therm of comfort and simplicity, like I can be 1000km away in a couple of hours without having to go through any security and its usually center to center. But the rest of the network does suffer
in the case of the SNCF, the worsening quality mainly comes from the neoliberal reforms from the '80s onward, with acquisition of rolling stock being off-loaded to regional governments, infrastructure not being maintained properly, and continuous reductions in personnel (e.g. from over 245 thousand in the mid-1980s to 180 thousand in 1995!). the government also obliged the company to conduct “economically profitable business”…
Also worth noting: there is a practical limit to how fast any given mode of transportation can go that has nothing to do with how good your technology is. You could put the fastest train in the world on a subway line and it wouldn’t matter because you can’t subject your passengers to 10 Gs accelerating and decelerating between stops that are really close together.
exactly! track geometry imposes hard limits on how fast any given rolling stock can travel on it. if a track is designed for 120-160 km/h, then you will not be able to travel faster on it without derailing.
not to mention unpleasant stuff like g-forces, wear, vibrations, abrasion, etc…
I will take any rail at this point. Give me that thing where you have to pump it with your arms and i’ll fucking take it at this point.
build it yourself. All you need is a 5 foot wide, 400 miles long plot and the invisible hand of the free market.
ah see, the invisible hand of the free market is currently squeezing the life out of me, I don’t think i’m in favor with it
sowwwy :( gaz expensive
yes, but also medication and doctor bills


yeah, i wrote this post pretty much as a response to the outsized mention of HSR whenever rail transport is brought up, especially in regard to china.
don’t get me wrong, china’s hsr network is extremely impressive, but its impressive image has also led some people, especially online, to tend to make some (in my opinion problematic) oversights. i constantly see people from countries with poorly developed rail networks (read: north americans) making the mistake of believing that hsr would somehow magically solve all their car-dependent problems, not realising that such ills need to be addressed on the micro level first and foremost: again, a train station thats hard to reach without a car, or serving few main destinations, becomes largely pointless.
worse still is when people spread outright misinformation, à la the china-laos “hsr,” simply because they believed a marketing label and did not bother to read what the realities on the ground actually turn out to be.
it would dent airport road traffic
don’t get me wrong, i’m not arguing against building high-speed rail!
i’m just trying to point out that hsr depends on less glamorous rail services because it works best as part of a network, not as a stand-alone fast line. it is much smarter to build a network and then add hsr once it is needed, than vice versa.
also, and more importantly, “conventional” rail transport is not “lesser” rail transport! it has its own merits and warrants investment just as much, but oftentimes gets overlooked due to being in hsr projects’ shadow.what i’m trying to say is, that while hsr is good for supplying speed between major centres, ordinary rail and transit are the ones that supply the access, connections, and coverage that make the fast line useful in the first place.
Yeah a super fast and sexy HSR line from where I live to Toledo OH could spawn in right now and it wouldn’t be very helpful because once you get to Toledo you’d have to get around a very car-centric city with no car and little alternative transportation.






