Starting from Hasan bad, for the format he’s doing, who would you redirect people to?
I mean love for Richard Wolff and Luna Oi etc but those are fundamentally different operations.
HP’s politics and tone are roughly similar to los Chapos and they’re directly implicated in spawning this very bearsite on which we post
I don’t like him but he has said some correct things and not all are electoral. Yes the bar for American mass media is just that low

The deprogram? They seem to be the communist heir to the “dirtbag left” crown, which is exactly why I stopped listening to them, but at least they have mostly good positions.
The only thing is that they don’t bother with usian regional electoral politics the way that it makes a lot of Hasan watchers feel engaged, and why would they, 2/3rds of the podcast aren’t even American.
I was also going to say the deprogram. Maybe Party Girls or Trillbillies, though they’ve gone downhill a lot. QAA has a g*mer or two if that’s what people want.
Trillbillies are at their best when they cover elections and local politics. Otherwise it’s just them chatting about the most random stuff, and I don’t feel they’re as high energy as Hasan.
They’ve also been doing the pod for too long, it’s understandable they don’t want to take part in the outrage machine anymore
When i misbehave wifu tells me to go read marx
On a political level I have no problem penguin people i know in his direction. I would say my biggest difference with him isnthay he fundamentally liked the United States, while I see nothing salvageable. This includes his focus on US electoralism, but the reality is that a lot of people i know already center their views on US electoralism, so they may as well become Hasanabi heads and develop a somewhat more skeptical view of the system.
I am confident in my ability to explain the delta between Hasan and myself to someone who is aligned with Hasan (i have done it before). There is not currently a better media figure that suits this role, in my opinion, although I have used a couple of Professor Wolff’s videos in the past.
For the purposes of this post I am disregarding criticism of Hasan from the left, like I said above, i can do that just fine on my own.
That said, i think Hasan makes for interesting political discussions with less-aware people. One reason is that he has been getting the unfair Corbyn treatment due to hao antizionism. His Iran coverage has been firmly in the pro-iran camp. I just have so much less ground to cover if people have already been exposed to these viewpoints.
The reason I dont recommend him is because his stream is annoying. On the flipside, he has other appearances and interviews I can use. The other reason is a lack of alternatives that reach the same relevancy. He has been legitimized in the eyes of liberals by personal call outs from Trump and Netanyahu.
I think that a lot of people on Hexbear are frustrated by people getting “distracted” by “ineffective” electoralism, and while I agree with the foundations of that viewpoint, I wouldnt say I really share that opinion nor feel a frustration toward people getting politically activated. I don’t feel like this process needs to be optimized for efficiency.
I do think that this dynamic will shift, I wonder what Hasan’s approach to '28 is going to be after the all-out assault that happened in the midterms. I wonder if new personalities will rise to prominence, perhaps someone more firmly in the DSA-left (not expecting beyond that, but maybe?).
Another question is who do you recommend to a Hasan watcher? I like FD Signifier, but he is just a step or two left of Hasan. Deculturation is a smart guy, but last time i went to watch his stuff it was all full streams, hes gotta chop them up into clips.
I think the only way you could have a media figure that would match Hasan from the left is to have a backing org like PSL (problematic rn, I know, but i dont have a better example anyway). In that environment Hasan would be the spokesperson of the DSA and [new creator/show] would be the spokesperson of [PSL or whoever].
You can always recommend theory and books and shit of course, but that isn’t distinct from recommending YouTube clips and similar media.
A lot of variety in youtube content, some is heavy on theory, I’m looking for that parasocial hangout x day to day news vibe.
I’m not into Twitch at all and it’s hard to relate to the sheer content volume of people who stream constantly or Lenin forbid watch such content at length
Haha it sounds like Hasan is who you are looking for as it stands right now. There will probably be a few more lefty streamers coming up in the next couple of years, I think there’s gonna be a lot of socialist zoomers, just gotta figure our where the 24 year olds are being paranormal maybe.




