Hello everynyan, we’re reading Soviet Democracy

Week 2 we are reading chapter 3: “The Rights of the Wage-Earner” and chapter 4: “The Power of the Trade Unions”

EPUB, and link to a PDF, of the book can be found on Comrade’s Library. If you find problems with the EPUB tell me and I will fix it.

  • Damarcusart [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    3 days ago

    I’ve been finding Sloan’s writing style a little hard to get into. Is it just me? It feels a little dry at times and I find myself skimming a fair bit more than actively reading carefully. It might just be the parts where it feels like it is just repeating things I already know though.

    It is interesting comparing and contrasting this work with “This Soviet World.” I can’t remember much mention of Trade Unions at all in that book, but this one heavily emphasises their role in the Soviet system. I’m wondering if it is more personal emphasis and focus, or if it is because this book is intended for a British audience more than an American one, while Strong was largely writing for an American audience.

    I’ve certainly noticed a lot of terms here I don’t think I’ve heard much about in other works, like the “triangle” or “patronage” I’ve heard these system described before, but not using this specific term for them, I’m not sure if these are actual terms used or if they are just terms used by Sloan to try and relate them back to things the audience might be more familiar with.

    Doesn’t really touch on it to the same extent as Strong, but it certainly has an interesting discussion of how a “reward” for a worker under capitalism is just an empty incentive by the boss to get the workers to produce them more profit, while in the Soviet system, rewards for workers were passed out by their fellow workers, the comradely nature of the Soviet workers is just so radically different to workers under capital, where we are trained to fight and stab each other in the back to get ahead.

    Also another mention of Stakhanov in this book too. I guess he was pretty famous at the time, imagine, not a celebrity who is pretty or handsome, or makes a ton of money for the rich, but is a hard working coal miner, making coal mining a more efficient and effective job, someone who achieves international acclaim through hard work and innovation, the closest we have is the “genius inventor” who even then, we don’t really see any accounts of people like that who aren’t just rich capitalists paying others to invent things for them to then claim the credit.

    Chapter 4 has a nice breakdown of why “everyone’s paycheck needs to be the same” isn’t really socialism, and ultimately doesn’t benefit society. Not tackling nearly as many anti-communist myths as Strong did, but it’s kind of inevitable that sooner or later the most common anti-communist cliches need to be addressed and debunked.

    And a mention of Kalinin as the president, the highest office in the country, not Stalin! Very interesting to see that Stalin hasn’t even been mentioned once so far (I think he is mentioned a fair bit in the next chapter though.)

    And of course, the chapter ends with yet another discussion of football, just in case you forgot the author is British. Surprised he hasn’t commented on the quality of the tea in the Soviet Union yet!

  • oliveoil [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    3 days ago

    I don’t like the Triangle model.

    I think that you should have a party representative who is involved in all decision making to make sure that there is proactive compliance with the laws, principles, and communist doctrine. Effectively we should have the party representative as an accountability officer.

    The manager and the union representative should be the same person. Elected by the workers.

    A top-down selected manager by the state just enforces hierarchy and may subvert the Democratic workplace process.

    Perhaps my philosophies are more anarchist than the USSR.

    • Damarcusart [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      3 days ago

      As you can see in the chapter, even people within the USSR had their complaints about it, it was far from a perfect system, it was an experiment, with positives and negatives, compared to literally anywhere else on earth at the time, it was a massive improvement, but it still needed improving itself, as people noted it resulted in things being somewhat insular and resistant to criticism. Reactions like this are probably why the Chinese communists emphasise “ruthless criticism of all that exists” as a means of preventing the eventual stagnation of the system that this “triangle” was a part of. Once political nihilism had set in in the USSR, there seemed to be little point to even bother criticising, since it seemed like people felt their voices weren’t really being heard, and a crop of do-nothing leaders more concerned with being in charge than actually leading ended up isolating people from the system. It certainly wasn’t the primary cause of the Soviet stagnation and collapse, but even at this point you can see people noticing the cracks in the system, and wanting them fixed before they become a problem (instead the later Soviet leaders seemed more focused on making them worse, deliberately or not).

      It’s an important lesson to learn I think from this. A similar system could work well in the early stages of a socialist state, but it would need to be phased out once people no longer have a “capitalist mentality” and no longer view their fellow workers as a threat or competition. Just as socialism is a transitional state, it also has lots of transitions within itself.

    • hotcouchguy [he/him]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      5
      ·
      3 days ago

      In a general sense, I think it depends on how economic planning is handled. If it’s somewhat loose planning, with relatively more market mechanisms, you can let each enterprise do its own thing, entirely under its own self-management, as long as its compliant with whatever laws/regulations/mandates apply. But if production is more tightly integrated across enterprises, more directly coordinated across the economy, it makes sense to have more management input from the state and/or the party in some form. And that could potentially vary between industries, based on eg. the complexity of their supply chains.

      It sounded like co-ops were used to an extent, I assume operating how you describe, but not much detail on that so far. (That’s the next chapter & I haven’t read it yet)

      The triangle model seems reasonable based on the short overview given, but I have a lot of questions about what responsibilities map onto which ‘side’ & how this functioned in practice.

  • oliveoil [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    edit-2
    3 days ago

    The CCP having representatives inside private enterprises is the most critical aspect of how China can avoid collapsing into a capitalist hellhole.

    This triangle is the only a good way you can have private enterprise that is accountable to the state and society.

    However, I think it would be better to merge management and the union. Basically, the leadership should be elected by the workers - as in a co-operative. And the cooperative is accountable thanks to the internal presence of the party during decision making.

    • Damarcusart [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      3 days ago

      Basically, the leadership should be elected by the workers - as in a co-operative.

      “Soviet” literally means “council” and they were directly elected by the people, not quite as a co-op, but similar, I’m hoping this book will actually address the central pillar of Soviet democracy(though it would be very funny for a book called “Soviet Democracy” to literally fail to mention that). I think for now it is more just trying to show how the workplace in the USSR is also democratic, in stark contrast to the west.

      One of the problems with a co-op is they can end up focusing more on themselves and enriching themselves/putting their own co-op ahead of others, a co-op is accountable to itself, but not really to outsiders, which can create rifts in a system and have the co-ops forming almost microstates unto themselves and no longer working in the collective interest. Not to say this is an automatic consequence of co-ops, that it is inevitable, but it has been a long time problem with ideas like Syndicalism. It’s a frustrating problem with no easy solution, which is why it is important to learn and study how these things have been attempted in the past and what worked and what didn’t work.

  • oliveoil [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    3 days ago

    Why are communist books so sophisticated?

    On page 64, the word “identity” is used in the most formal mathematical sense of the word.

    While I understand well that this means “equivalence” it is a bit absurd to use it like that in regular discussion.

    No wonder people have a hard time reading this stuff.

  • hotcouchguy [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    3 days ago

    More of a historical question than a textual one, but how much did these workers self-management structures change over time? How did things move from this to the worker disengagement of the later Soviet years?

    • Damarcusart [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      3 days ago

      I’ve been trying to figure this out myself lately, I notice in this chapter a mention of the system feeling like it limits democracy:

      At this meeting the work of the factory Triangles was severely criticized as limiting democracy at the present time. Zhdanov referred to them as tending to become a “family compact, a conspiracy to make it more difficult to criticize. And once these three are in agreement, just go and try to criticize them!”

      From what I can tell, as the Soviet Union moved more and more into “Kruschevism” and away from the Stalin model, people felt increasingly disconnected from the government and the workplace, and if the system felt impossible to criticise before, it would probably feel much harder to criticise after. I don’t know enough about the organisation of the mid to late USSR to know if this disconnect was exacerbated by major changes to organisation, or through the system not really changing enough though.

  • Cowbee [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.netM
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    3 days ago

    On the latest version, seems “tine” is a typo for “time,” chapter IV I believe.

    But what an excellent pair of chapters! Expanded a lot on what Anna Louise Strong described, particularly the Triangle, the wall-newspaper, and the activities of the party as the most dedicated and advanced of the proletariat. The role of trade unions as the runners of society was also a great way to view them, as schools for communism that are not quite the communist party itself and not bound to a political line.