This post is written on https://normals.me/ and delivered to !fediverse@lemmy.world over #ActivityPub, so if you are reading it the basic plumbing works. Now let me explain what is this.
Normals is a forum with communities, threads, and questions with an accepted answer. It is a single instance, not software you can host, and the core is closed for anti-abuse reasons. The federation module will be published separately with implementation notes (FEP-67ff).
What federates today
Every community is a Group actor following the Lemmy model (FEP-1b12). Follow @selfhosted@normals.me or any other community from Lemmy, PieFed, Mbin or Mastodon.
Posts and comments go both ways. Replies from your instance appear in the thread on Normals, replies from Normals go back to the origin.
Remote content is labelled with its origin, links back to it, and is never copied. Media loads from the source.
Signed fetches, so it works with instances that require authorized fetch. NodeInfo 2.1 is up.
Policies, in case they matter to you, it has no ads, and no paid reach, and of course no AI training on posts. AI crawlers blocked by default, public mod log with reasons, and no automated removals. Numbers at https://normals.me/transparency so please take a look.
If something from your instance shows up wrong here, or something from here shows up wrong on yours, reply with the URL and I’ll fix it. Andy Piper mentioned NodeBB uses the same group model, if anyone runs a NodeBB instance I’d like to test against it, if possible.
I hope we all have fun.\ Cheers!
Posted on Normals.me · View the original post
Hi there!
Your site looks really interesting. Based on content alone I’d be inclined to join. However my concern is the exact same thing as Reddit- even though it is part of the Fediverse, you’re just one site, single instance.
Let’s say your thing works, and FWIW I hope it does.
Let’s say you grow like Reddit. Let’s say there’s even a Digg-like migration to Normals.
Since you’re only one instance, if something happens to you, if you run out of money, if you get acquired, if you suddenly decide to turn evil, or much more likely if you pull a Slack (like when they killed their IRC bridge) and someday shut down the Fediverse gateway and become an isolated forum, we’re all SOL.
It’s not that I think you’re a bad guy. I think your heart is in the right place. But the way you are building your system requires us to not only trust you, but trust future-you and any business partners or new owners. It makes my registration part of your ‘monthly active users’ which you can sell and I can’t get away from without completely ditching Normals and going back to vanilla Fediverse.
With that said- I hope your thing works, if you bring more content to the Fediverse that’s a good thing.
I also can’t seem to load your instance from mine- I’m on lemmy.today and I can’t load @selfhosted@normals.me…
Closed source and clearly completely vibe coded? Just look at the site, it reeks of AI. Even this post has so much AI-speech.
Yea, no thanks.
It’s a shame you see it this way, Andy Piper disagrees but you’re free to think as you wish, it’s an open forum :)
In fact, the UI is purely Tailwind, and the design is based on the best of each platform. I’m sorry if you don’t like the Tailwind CSS. But it’s the framework I know best. I considered Bootstrap, but honestly, it felt too rigid. Thanks for the comment any way :)
I think its funny when someone doesn’t disclose it’s an ai project they get hella upvotes
if the core is closed for the stated reason, does that mean you are unsure about the safety of the system?
Good question, however the security model doesn’t depend on the code being secret, and it shouldn’t. The auth, signatures, permissions and input handling are standard and went through an OWASP review before launch.
What’s closed is the anti-abuse layer, spam, rate-limit tuning, the signals for detecting ban evasion and coordinated accounts. Those work partly because spammers don’t know the exact numbers. Lemmy’s and Mastodon’s are public and they get played for exactly that reason. Hope it helps :)
This makes sense, but that doesn’t stop release of the source code. You just make the security stuff a module or plugin of some kind that is not released.
Thus I could spin up a Normals instance, run it, have people on it, but I’d need to make my own spam filter.
Hi, I got a couple questions that aren’t answered on your transparency page yet.
- Has AI been used to create this?
- Two AI communities are on top of your communities list. Your terms talk about preventing AI scraping, yet your platform seems to welcome “AI founders”. How does this go together?
- Where is the source code?
- Your terms talk about monetization through Normals Plus. Can you elaborate on this?
Do I use AI to do everything? No, as a software engineer with over 15 years of experience in the industry, you can’t let AI do all the work any developer knows that at this point? It messes things up all the time, ignores design patterns, ignores best practices, writes code stupidly cloning functions already exists, ignores SOLID, ignores security vulnerabilities, and so on. But I did use it to run unit tests, integration tests, perform performance and speed tests, and even to hack my own app.
The communities are random, there’s no fixed order in them. Besides, they’re mirrored of other existing communities. As you can see, they come from other sources like Mastodon based on the hashtags.
Regarding the plus feature, it’s a way for users to decorate their profiles. I planned as source of income to maintain the project, otherwise, the project wouldn’t exist, unfortunately I would need to pay for the serves to host the app, the DB backups, the infrastructure, pipelines, buckets, well if you are developer you might understand how a platform actually works. But nothing is implemented yet, nor will it be in the near future regarding the plus.
It is a real shame that people think that this is vibecoded, without prior experience working as a developer and I am saying this because it more than enough to hit F12 and check the network tab, and the weird thing for me is that people judge because how it looks, but this is what the CSS Framework https://tailwindcss.com/ offers. However I appreciate your comment and I hope I answered your questions.
If you think choosing tailwind forces you into a certain style of website, you clearly don’t know what you’re talking about.
And you clearly haven’t just used AI for tests. I wonder if the source is closed because you know how obviously AI generated it would look if it was open source?
Why does your comment smell of elitism?
Yeah, it would be better if the code was FOSS. But at least it was released, the author seems to know the important parts of AP integration and is asking for constructive feedback. This is one million times better than developers who keep their purely organic, 100% fair trade software projects in a virtual shelf for fear of being criticized.
Is it elitism to call out vibe coding now? What a world.
Not to mention that their understanding of what tailwind is seems patchy at best, despite claiming that they have 15 years of experience.
The elitism is in thinking that using AI for some parts of the application (the frontend) nullifies the whole project.
I very much doubt the AI use is confined to the frontend. But I don’t see why the frontend is fine to vibe code while other stuff is not?
Using AI as a tool is fine. It can be very useful for programming. But “vibe coding” is using it to an extreme degree where the AI is producing almost the whole thing, with a very small amount of guidance or design from the user. That’s what I would object to. Such a thing has very little value, anyone can vibe code such a thing.
Using AI is bad in general. Plain stop.
Its strange how hostile people are being. And people are assuming everything is vibecoded at this point.
Please no. Fediverse, open standards, open source, free software, no bullshit.
I don’t believe all software should be open source. In that you’re wrong. I think @baldur did a great job here.
i think you’re wrong and a bad person for having that opinion
WTF? Why I am a bad person?
Lots of people are getting pissed at it being closed source. I get that it isn’t the norm. But, there are closed-source paid software on the Fediverse. This isn’t anything new. Also, there’s ways to disagree and share opinions without being hostile - we are not children here nor teenagers lacking a fully developed brain
As a counterpoint, sloppy projects are being shared all over and it’s basically spam at this point. Even /r/rust had to disallow code projects, because there was simply way too much slop being posted all the time.
People share projects because back in the day, a project with hundreds of thousands of lines of code with a cool website and a lot of features were evidence of a lot of hard work, a lot of design decisions and a lot of tradeoffs.
Vibe coding has made that a bad metric. These things no longer mean that any actual work has been dedicated to this project. Anyone could use an afternoon prompting an agent to build the same thing. There is no value in sharing such a thing. At best, it’s worthless and at worst, it’s borderline a scam, an attempt at disguising a project as something it isn’t.
Hello from RetroLemmy! Always fun to see a new platform join in
Yay! Thank you, I appreciate the comment! It seems to work!











