Preaching to the choir, but one of the most persistent myths that serve to defend the US empire is the oft-repeated canard that the poor are sent to die for the rich in “American” wars, so they deserve sympathy as our fellow proletariat.

Sure, maybe back when there was a draft(, but even then only the few who turned traitor). Now? It’s a volunteer army that’s more a professional caste than anything else. Which is what the linked article is about.

But even if the myth were true and soldiers were largely “forced into it due to poverty”, that’s still a choice they’re making to help slaughter and oppress people for their own enrichment. We are so far past the start of the “global war on terror” that everyone should be able to see that if you sign up to fight for amriKKKa, you’re signing up to murder innocent people. They largely choose not to see that because they largely choose to be white-supremacist racist fucks who fundamentally consider non-Burgerreichers to be untermenschen. Hold a gun to my head and tell me to choose between joining the US army and getting a real job and I’ll take the real job. Hell, I’ll take crime and robbing people over joining the US armed forces, because if I’m doing petty theft at least I’m only mildly inconveniencing burgerreichers in the first world rather than helping murder oppressed people in the third world

If you just drove a truck in an army base ferrying supplies from one point to another? Still a war criminal, that truck helped drop a bomb on some school full of children, and if it didn’t that’s just luck on your part. You would have driven that truck even knowing it was going to help kill people

Troop worship is nothing more than PR for the empire. Every dead American troop is a blessing, every live one a curse. They can only regain their humanity by quitting and spending the rest of their lives trying to atone for their inhumane choices and struggling for the liberation of their victims.

  • PKMKII [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    30
    ·
    4 days ago

    I’m of a mixed opinion on this. I don’t like the automatic “troops/cops are sympathetic proletariat” angle, and I don’t think service in the armed forces is a good way to pitch candidates or leadership within a leftist movement to the larger public. Antagonism to the imperial war machine needs to be central and not diluted.

    However, I’m not fond of the idea of mortal sins either. The typical American gets inundated with pro-troop propaganda, a lot of them enlist with just hearing the “they defend freedoms and spread democracy” side. If they go through enlistment and service and come out going “it was all bullshit, we were meatbags for corporate interests, the military just spreads their hegemony,” I don’t think it’s productive to turn them away from the movement. Those are the people most qualified to say “I have seen how the sausage gets made, and it is criminal.”

    I also do find it odd for ML’s to say, follow the example of Lenin, but not on this particular part. I know there’s counterpoints of “oh but the Russian army was different,” but, like, it was the Russian empire. Those were imperial soldiers. If nothing else, when shit hits the fan, having 10-20% of troops turning on their superiors is better than none turning on them.

  • Awoo [she/her]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    27
    ·
    4 days ago

    I think military trained people are a necessity for revolution.

    I do not think military trained people who volunteer for the imperial storm troopers will become leftist revolutionaries. These circumstances self-select for far right and loyal dogs.

    Historically the military trained people who do become revolutionaries were from drafted forces, or they were participants in forces other than national militaries. Whether that’s directly joining guerilla forces or something else.

    The question is how you move from having almost no military trained individuals in the revolutionary vanguard to having many such that you can expand a real fighting force, within the circumstances of a state that is operating a volunteer military and is also stable with no internal conflicts or paramilitaries.

      • Awoo [she/her]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        16
        ·
        4 days ago

        Once you have these points down it starts to become clear how ww1 created the conditions for the Soviet Union and how ww2 created the conditions for the PRC. Or more specifically, created the conditions for communists to be as trained as they were.

        The question really is whether or not you can create the conditions without a huge conflict. For the US in particular I also question whether an overseas conflict can create the conditions or whether it differs compared to a land border neighbouring conflict.

        • AssortedBiscuits [they/them]@hexbear.net
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          18
          ·
          4 days ago

          Modern militaries are far more bureaucratic, specialized, and mechanized than 20th century militaries. A procurement accountant and a fighter jet pilot are both largely useless within a guerilla warfare context or more accurately about as useful as a random civilian. The procurement accountant, fighter jet pilot, and some random janitor would all need to go through the same level of training.

          Most military personnel are less useful than a random civilian prole with a random civilian prole job or a random civilian hobbyist with spicy hobbies. A random submarine sailor is only useful if they’re actually on a sub where they can either sabotage the sub from within or start a mutiny to seize control of the sub. Otherwise, they bring nothing to the table. Some random truck driver is more useful than that sailor because the truck driver knows how to operate commonly used vehicles on top of most likely having certs under their belt that allow them to drive around with hazardous material while the sailor has few skills that doesn’t involve living in a submarine. Some dude who repairs cars for a living brings more to the table than some dude who repairs tanks for a living for obvious reasons.

          What people are looking for is people who were deployed as infantry, people who aren’t REMF but with their ass in the grass. The problem is that the vast majority of those people are either completely unhinged serial killers or broken people with horrible PTSD who you don’t them anywhere near a weapon. For example, Platner has plenty of combat experience and would be able to teach so much to any militant formation as an instructor. Platner is also a completely unhinged serial killer who only gets a chubby when he’s killing civilians.

          • Awoo [she/her]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            11
            ·
            4 days ago

            There’s an element missing here and it is the discipline and confidence that comes from 1 knowing how to behave in a military from the training and 2 knowing what military activity actually looks like to be able to say “yes this is properly organising our revolutionary forces”. You get neither from civilians and as such people are much more unsure of their activities, whether ordered to carry them out by someone else or acting on their own. That fighter pilot knows what proper chain of command looks like, knows what a proper operation looks like at a small squad level or a larger organisational scale. The experience grants considerable confidence towards activities within revolutionary groups.

            Not that I think any fighter pilot is going to be a revolutionary anyway but I’m just mirroring your example.

            You’re not wrong about combat experience itself having significantly larger value but I do believe there’s other elements being missed here.

            • AssortedBiscuits [they/them]@hexbear.net
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              6
              ·
              4 days ago

              That fighter pilot knows what proper chain of command looks like, knows what a proper operation looks like at a small squad level or a larger organisational scale. The experience grants considerable confidence towards activities within revolutionary groups.

              Do you think jobs like firefighters and park rangers provide an okay substitute experience or does it have to be exclusively from working in the military?

              • Awoo [she/her]@hexbear.net
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                5
                ·
                4 days ago

                I think they’re more likely to be able to mentally deal with life threatening situations but aren’t necessarily going to be confident “yes this is what a military operation looks like” when them and 9 other people are planning an op. They’re going to understand the concept of working in squads and planning out an operation but the difference between them and the military operation is the opposing side has counter-ops. A firefighter’s experience is against a fire and a building, not an opposing force of humans. The main fear people without experience in military are going to have is “are we doing this right?” and “is this what this shit looks like in a real military?” to give them the confidence of actually going through with the activities. If they’ve done it in a real military (or been part of chains of command where they’ve seen others doing it at other levels), they’ve got the confidence to say things are being done correctly and recognise the gaps or errors etc.

                Maybe an outdated concept but let’s say it’s the russian revolution and someone is put together 10 civilians to rob a bank for funding a revolution compared to putting together 5 civilians and 5 with military experience at various levels that isn’t necessary combat. You’re more likely to actually get people carrying through an operation if they know what ops look like from their ww1 experience in the military. They’re more likely to feel confident enough to do it.

                I think there’s also a sort of collective confidence too. You get enough people with various degrees of training and different experience in different roles and the confidence that creates with the range of skills and understanding expands collectively. It also spreads, those people teach everyone around them, and the ops they actually carry out become military experience in and of itself.

  • Antiwork [none/use name, he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    31
    ·
    4 days ago

    I think the real reason imperial core revolutionary leftists want to organize the military is bc they don’t believe they have the numbers of those willing to take up an armed struggle and view those who have practice in combat to be well equipped with some of the skills needed.

    I think there’s a big fallacy in that argument as well, but I do see that as a bigger driving force than the empathy for them being preyed on by the imperialist military.

    • woodenghost [comrade/them]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      20
      ·
      4 days ago

      Yes, and while I don’t know if that can ever apply to the US military, historically, many revolutions had part of the military revolting and relied heavily on that for military strength.

      And while I agree that being a cop or soldier is morally reprehensible, in theory, a soldier that revolts, kills their commanding officer and risked their live for the revolution would at least redeem themselves somewhat.

      Aside from that, it’s not our task to judge the moral worth of people but to organize class struggle. In the Vietnam war, at least fragging became more and more popular and contributed to the Vietnamese victory.

    • SickSemper [she/her, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      11
      ·
      edit-2
      4 days ago

      the skills needed for what? because the american left couldn’t organize any material action against the governments support for genocide or the domestic terror campaign against PoC, so it feels like putting the cart before the horse to start looking for ex wehrmacht to rehabilitate on the off chance they’ll shoot at cops

  • Belly_Beanis [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    4 days ago

    You shouldn’t trust troops because they’ve already shown a lack of conviction. They joined an organization that openly commits crimes against humanity and did nothing to stop it.

    “Well I didn’t want to get a dishonorable discharge!”

    “I didn’t want to get court marshaled!”

    “It was just to pay for school!”

    …and so on are all excuses for taking money to look the other way when witnessing or even participating in war crimes. What the fuck do you think is going to happen when these same troops get arrested by feds? A leftwing revolution is incredibly dangerous to participate in. Just look at the Panthers or IRA or Red Army Faction and what they had to deal with.

    Accepting former troops or cops into our ranks is accepting snitches and rats. They’ve already proven they can be bought for five figures or less. And you think they’re going to be reliable when shit hits the fan? Have you considered how bad it’s going to look when troops commit the same war crimes they did elsewhere in the world to US citizens? It opens up accusations of “red fascism” and other anti-communist rhetoric.

    The most you can do with them is training somewhere remote where they don’t have the ability to blather to whatever handlers are monitoring them. Actual direct action? Absolutely not. They’re a danger to opsec. That’s assuming they aren’t potential mass shooters and terrorist chuds.

  • plinky [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    4 days ago

    the deeper question is how much of military industrial complex is unionized (the raytheon locals 1488 of aim), and how much is it from the 10% total of unionized workforce? 20%? 40%?

  • SickSemper [she/her, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    4 days ago

    idk why you presented a set of facts and people jumped in to talk about moral failure; nor why people read “struggling for the liberation of their victims” and interpreted it as “struggling for the liberation of Americans”