Moss [they/them]

Who up sauling they Goodman. Is that anything

  • 3 Posts
  • 134 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 18th, 2023

help-circle


  • Like Frodo and Sam have this massive climactic, exhausting final push to get to mount doom and then they accept death, and then everyone but the hobbits gets a send-off, and then… There’s like this weird little rebellion plotline and Saruman is being a weird low-stakes villain? Like Saruman feels like a cartoon villain in this, not in an overly evil way, but just his plan is stupid and lame and then he just gets kicked out and dies. The tone is really weird, 19 hobbits and 70 (!) men die, and no one really cares that much, and it just isn’t that important.

    Thematically I guess it’s important to show that the old ways are truly gone, and even the Shire wasn’t safe from the war, but then it’s stated that the Shire immediately became a safe place again and pretty much went back to normal. So like what’s the point of this at all. Tbh it’s the only time in all three books that I’ve not enjoyed reading that much.