I just finished a PhD in stats, and before that, studied computer science. I had planned to go back to industry to do software engineering or be a data scientist afterwards.
However, it seems that in the meantime, vibe coding has taken over the software industry and swallowed most data scientist roles. Few open positions, and the ones that do exist are just pushing a button instead of thinking and solving problems. Is this a correct assessment? Should I try to get back in or just find a new career? I am not too keen on staying in academia either.
I don’t feel comfortable telling anyone to go into software engineering right now. I think the future is really uncertain. That said, I’m also not convinced this is a bad time.
The need for software engineering isn’t going away. LLMs are actually not very good at thinking and solving problems at a high level, so we still need people for that. LLMs are more of a performance multiplier than a replacement for human software engineers.
That does mean that fewer engineers will be needed to do the same work. But also, I think there’s a chance it’s a Jevons Paradox situation, and maybe if the cost of software drops we’ll see even more demand for it - like how we found tons of new uses for electricity when prices dropped. Maybe we’re entering a golden age of bespoke software. Unclear.
I agree with this take. Lots of uncertainty because LLMs are rubbish at probably solving (which is a human’s strength). LLMs don’t have a semantic understanding of the problem they’ve been tasked with solving.
tl;dr LLMs are useful tool but not software engineers.
The Jevons paradox point is interesting. Maybe we’ll finally get better software products, so far it seems like everything is as buggy and slow as as ever.
Even if unemployment isn’t an issue, engineers would need to have the flexibility/freedom to do things by hand sometimes though I think. Go into details, understand the lower level work. Just like pilots occasionally hand-fly not to lose their skills. Otherwise, it’s just too mind numbing to do long term, even if humans were involved in the big picture decisions.
The Jevons paradox point is interesting. Maybe we’ll finally get better software products, so far it seems like everything is as buggy and slow as as ever.
The bar to be a coder is being lowered, but actual software engineering with metrics, requirements, and deadlines will probably increase. I can easily see a world where everyone rushes into the AI to solve problems that used to not be cost effective and at the end of the first push (hopefully that’s around now) there’s a lot of new, untested code, and no metrics whether programmers were more efficient, and more importantly no metrics (I saw stats PhD) about whether the bottom line increased: https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/02/ai-redefining-wall-street-jobs.html
How would one measure the efficacy of two different AI generated trading regimes (or however it is they work up there) when the people who understood what they were asking can’t understand any of the code?
Thanks for your perspective. It helps to get some hope that software development skills might be still needed in the future.
This. You still need to know how to write and organize code to guide LLMs in the right direction, you just don’t have to write the code yourself anymore, that’s no longer economical at scale.
The skills you need to guide LLMs though comes from practical application/experience writing code in the industry though, so my concern is how people are going to get those skills now. You don’t get them from college.
The skills you need to guide LLMs though comes from practical application/experience writing code in the industry though, so my concern is how people are going to get those skills now. You don’t get them from college.
Yeah… it’s going to be really rough for new engineers for a while until we figure out a new way to train people. I think there will be people who are self taught and AI native who will do really well, but they will be the minority.
As a career software engineer, I think you’re right to ask the question.
I’m going to give an answer that will get me downvoted to hell, but you deserve to hear it.
Your PhD is extremely useful in specific cases regardless of AI slop-coding existing. With the caveat that you may need to be open to leveraging AI tooling to go faster.
I work with a few PhDs, smart people, sharp people, amazing ideas, but the things they think of and approaches they try are not something your AI/LLM is going to just magically always suggest. Even if it does, it likely won’t be contextually correct or proper for the situation.
A hybrid approach of someone with the intelligence to steer LLMs towards a goal and who understands the right ways to prompt to achieve or test that goal quickly is valuable.
I don’t know you, haven’t met you, don’t know your actual technical knowledge - but assuming that stuff all checked out it is exactly the type of thing some companies I’ve worked for or work for would hire around.
Unfortunately, the roles that appreciate someone like you are fewer and further between, but they exist and they’re in-demand based on what I’ve seen.
dunno why you would get downvoted, i think alot of people agree with your assesment.
AI poses one major risk to SE in general: the dropped need for low/entry level employees.
It used to be, a senior would have a team of mid- and junior engineers, senior would be in charge of the big picture while the team learned, and delivered the actual low level tasks.
But with AI, companies started hiring only seniors. Which is an issue - now the market is full of “entry level” graduates who simply can’t find a job because nobody’s hiring. And seniors are left wrangling AI agents that don’t learn, don’t work autonomously, don’t ask questions, don’t bring ideas.
don’t bring idea
In my experience the AI agents do if you ask them. Rather than giving them a problem and telling them to solve it autonomously, I ask them to give me feedback on my plan and propose potential alternatives before starting any coding, and often I get good suggestions from them this way.
If your idea of an idea is “concept that I personally am not aware of but which has been conceived, elaborated on and documented by another human being”…
Then yes, totally!
The AI can extrapolate, but even if it couldn’t, ultimately I need an idea that works, not necessarily a completely original idea that works (and most humans don’t come up with completely original ideas very often either).
Yeah, I was gonna say, most engineers are gonna be taking a lot of code from the internet anyway. Most problems modern companies face have already been solved in one way or another, its just figuring out what fits your specific product and needs. That being said, I’m pro “ai as a tool in non-creative fields”, but it certainly doesn’t replace engey level engineers. I see it closer to a calculator or like factory machine. It can cut out the grunt work and summarize things well, but it takes a looooot of steering to actually work. And the engineer can maybe learn some new concepts or techniques along the way
Sauce for the first sentence?
Well, I have my personal experience, but there are also all those math problems that AI has been solving recently… Here’s one mathematician’s discussion, with links to blog posts by other mathematicians who had spent years unsuccessfully working on some of those problems. He says:
Also, if you were wondering: apparently they tried the model on about 4,000 problems. So, right now it “merely” solves ~10% of the longstanding open mathematical problems that it’s asked about, the problems that whole communities have spent years on, after a single 3-hour attempt on them.
That’s what’s gotta sting the most about this. Imagine you worked a problem for a long time… and then The Giant Pattern Matcher With Zero Fluid Intelligence actually finds something.
If it did find something, that implies the solution already existed in bits and pieces in the published literature. You would “just” have had to have read about it, and remember it, for successful application.
But suppose you had succeeded in that. You would have published a paper that enumerates a bunch of results some other people had reached, then plugs them together for a supposedly new theorem. Sort of like importing a dozen Python libraries, adding around fifty lines of glue code around them and then going, yeah, here’s a “new” thing, Fields Medal plz!
How much remaining interestingness did your chosen problem really have if the new math you had to create for it fits on the placemat buttressing the campus cafeteria sandwich you had for lunch?
What I’ve seen appears to indicate some genuinely new approaches by the AI, rather than putting together existing information. That blog post, for example, quotes some running commentary from a mathematician studying the proof of the theorem that she had been working on for years:
It feels like something written by someone who’s on psychedelics. So much unclear and doesn’t make sense. Lots of name dropping of previous work without discussing why it can be used despite impossibility results
Basically the paper is so horribly written that it’s impossible to read it without AI help
I asked Astra for reasonable completeness and soundness claims of the noise gadget and it gave them by combining claims from all over the paper
They also have direct optimal NP hardness of approximation proofs for the main applications of the UGC (Max Cut and all CSP) that bypass the UGC.
The UGC proof invents a completely new bizarre code with a noise test. It’s some crazy recursive construction.
It’s not the long code, not the short code – some alien craziness
I still think that there maybe is a proof that uses the half space code (which is natural)
The citations are often irrelevant and confusing
A possible future is a math world that’s heavenly if you have vision/creative ideas that AI could help check and implement.
And of course there’s a lot for us to learn from the aliens
Note that this particular proof is correct, according to that same mathematician.
“one mathematician” who happened to work at openAI, btw.
But it also appears that no human has understood just about any of these proofs yet; the race to do so has just started.
Sounds like a pretty smart mathematician
The blog post was written less than a day after the proofs were released, and apparently they’re very hard for humans to follow. Now that a month has passed, there are human mathematicians’ explanations of how the proofs work up on the internet.
I’d give it a couple months before really committing to a new career
Everything is very uncertain right now, but the AI bubble is looking very poppable right now. After that happens, I think we’ll have a lot more clarity about what the future will look like
It’s going to be a long 8 weeks, but hopefully on the other side of that things will start making sense again
I still have an academic job for some months now (one that cannot be extended), so I will definitely wait and see. But I think it’s time to start planning and preparing.
I left corporate software engineering after 10 years. I wouldn’t recommend it unless you can stomach the worst side of humanity.
I still love development, but I would only return if I can get a guarantee that I don’t have to develop or work with AI, and only if I’m offered more than I was making before
What did you switch to?
I already had a second career in circus so I’m just shifting priorities
circus
wat

If you want to get into software engineering as a career, please be patient. The bubble is close to bursting, and there will inevitably be a push to hire humans. This time around however, your job will be un-fucking your employers vibe-coded slopware.
It is one of those things. LLM’s are brilliant at recombining old code/art/ideas into mixtures of these old things, but they cannot create anything genuinely new. Eventually we will need new idea and means of doing it.
Most of this slop-ware will probably be ditched in years to come as its tidal wave of technical debt becomes more of a burden than the gain.
With a PhD in stats you should be able to make more than most software developers. Companies need scientists to sign off on certain claims for liability reasons and it’s easier for them to just have one in house. That’s a licensed position that AI will not be able to take away.
I’m a senior developer. I haven’t written any code by hand so far this year, and the highly technical stuff I have on the resume is already done both faster and better by AI than I would be able to do it. However, I find that there’s still a lot of work for me to do because the AI has trouble maintaining coherence and working towards long-term goals in the absence of straightforward metrics. I end up herding a bunch of highly competent but easily distracted AI agents. It’s like being a manager, I think, although I’ve never managed humans myself. You still have to keep track of the overall goal and how the different agents are working (or failing to work) towards it in a way that requires human judgement and experience. I wouldn’t suggest becoming a junior dev in 2026 (because I would rather work with an AI than a junior dev) but senior devs aren’t obsolete yet although the nature of the role is changing rapidly and I don’t know what the future will bring.
I think at the point SWE and DS are solved problems, most other white collar jobs are too, then you’ll have huge numbers of applicants for the remaining white collar jobs and blue collar jobs which will drive down the marginal value of those skills. Realistically if you like SWE and are seemingly pretty good at it, keep applying and get a job until the music stops
The whole idea really is to drive the value of everyone, well except those that actually run the generative AI systems.
I wouldn’t recommend anybody pursue software right now, switch if at all possible while you still can.
I couldn’t be happier with my nursing career. I have several buddies that went the tech route and are currently in a revolving cycle of new job for 6 months and either laid off or looking for a new job. They make good money, but it seems like their is zero job security. Most of them have had to relocate more than once.
Right now really is the time to find careers that AI can’t take.
Most people I know that were heavy into corporate software coding, have ‘pivoted’ to their next big hustle “that could be ANYTHING!”. This is the bargaining phase right before depression and acceptance. Their entire career has been gutted from below them and now desperation is setting in.
Wait for the bubble to burst.
Anecdotal: at
${DAYJOB}a junior was tasked with “enhancing” a VB6 project, using AI of course, by adding more features1. In a dev meeting today someone asked the junior some basic questions:- If you had to, could you fix a bug alone without codex? No
- What if we can’t use codex anymore (price, end or contract, etc)? shrugs
1by the way the C/C++project i’m solely maintaining already has said features…
This kind of dependence on these systems is breeding a kind of gambling addict like behavior, that one dears what will happen if it goes away.
I also have a theory that because LLM’s use a bit randomization to it that it scratches that same itch that gambling has and this is why so many people are addicted/defend their slop so hard. “Yes, this code is crap but if I rub this chair and switch this light on and off 54 times, maybe the LLM will reward me with exactly what I want.”
As they say, just put the fries in the bag, bro.
Jk. You’ll be fine.
At the very least, it’s a very different job than what you remember. It’s more of a manager role now, without the paycheck.
Data analysis is only going to be more and more in demand.
My advice, as always, is to take a look at current offers and to try to find both a line of work and a company that would interest you (and has the right benefits for you). Then build towards the requirements, not the other way around.
Every single piece of our economy runs on software so there are plenty of options beyond being an AI wrangler at Evil-Corp.





