A nice gesture, but let’s be honest, the system is corrupt and won’t care. The real way to fight is to use AI to opensource all proprietary software out there and watch them squeal.
No. Using fire to fight fire makes more fire. Never use generative AI, for any reason.
What about coding when you are simply incapable of learning it? I created a whole story, a whole world, the graphic, the features, the skill, the figures, sound, music, the characters, etc. But i can not put it together because it can not code. So now what? I can’t afford a professional programmer. Should i be banned from ever making my dream game?
This place is loaded with the same morons on reddit
The former establishment doesn’t want you to be able to realize your dreams unless you pay them. And if you don’t have the money to pay them, they want you to suffer.
But now they can’t stop you anymore, no matter how hard they try to vilify anyone who escapes their grasp.
define “simply incapable”. you can use a sequencer, a synthesiser, a modelling program, an animation suite, write design docs for entire interconnected worlds, but if you ever accidentally write
print("hello")you explode?A form of discalculia. I struggle to keep the logical operators in the program code in my head or to combine them in a meaningful way. When I look at code, it starts moving. it does not make any sense for me. And i try it since 1990.
So now what?
Write a book.
Do carpentry.I don’t want to write a book. I want to make the game i was dreaming about the last 30 years. Now i finally have the tools to do it and now i need to let other people judge me for that? nope, not happening.
I worked my ass off to write the story. I took courses to learn how to do basic drawing so i could at least show people what i had in my mind the whole time. I created concept of the player character and what skills he has. how he moves, how the world looks. how the lifeforms in it behave and interact.
And all i get as answer now is just “sucks for you. write a book”.
No fuck that. I will make my game. And i will use whatever tool i want.
Go for it!
What about coding when you are simply incapable of learning it?
In what situation would it be literally impossible for you to learn to code, where you would also have access to LLMs? If you have access to LLMs, you have access to a computational device of some kind.
I cannot put it together because [I] cannot code.
You can learn to code.
Should I be banned from ever making my dream game?
No. But if you have an LLM program the game, you have not made it yourself. So in a situation where you use generative AI here, you still have not made the game.
No he shouldnt take 5 years to develop something just becauss you want that, he can take a week for the same results
Content generated by plagiarism machines is worse[1][2] than intelligently designed projects. It is just a stochastic parrot[1].
And there are severe moral and ethical issues with the use of LLMs, both in regard of strip-mining the totality of human knowledge and art to generate soulless slop, and in regard to the damage done to the world[1] and to people[1][2]. And, if you happen to be Catholic, it is also opposed by the Pope (and also by many Christians of denominations other than Roman Catholicism) for being a “Tower of Babel”.
I have a form of discalculia. I struggle to keep the logical operators in the program code in my head or to combine them in a meaningful way. When I look at code, it starts moving. it does not make any sense for me. And i try it since 1990.
So the answer is just “well just fuck yourself” then? thanks.
The answer is one of:
- Overcome your difficulties and do it.
- Work with someone else.
- Surrender morality by using a plagiarism machine to make a game with bad source code that you won’t understand well enough to patch.
You’re not incapable, you’re choosing not to. There is an initial hurdle you have to get past after which the logic clicks. If you’re unwilling to move past that hurdle, that’s a choice on your part, not an innate shortcoming.
The amount of time it would take to make the 5 apps and 2 blender extensions I made that I now use daily, would be years, I dont care to develop, I dont want to know how, I dont want to spend years learning, I want the result, and the result works great, I’m happier using the result then I would be learning, instead of learning code, I can use the damn apps and extensions for my needs.
5 apps and 2 blender extensions I made that I now use daily
You didn’t make shit.
please see the other answers.
only way to stop a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun.
sound familiar?
This won’t work. If they want to protect from AIs they need new license which probably won’t fit definition of open source by OSI. Also GPLv3 even won’t protect them.
I guess ai prompts in code comments can be… interesting?
Other options? Asking for a friend.Based
I’ve hated the prevalence of too-permissive licenses in the past 15 years. People need to go fucking brush up on their Stallman writings
I am not entirely sure why the GPLv2 license wouldn’t work for the BSDs, but either way I doubt that the problem was so big that it really required a license change. Everything in life is a trade-off, and I think the trade-off of not supporting the BSDs to prevent potential bad faith actors from “stealing the code without attribution” is a really bad trade-off.
I am not entirely sure why the GPLv2 license wouldn’t work for the BSDs,
The GPL is a copyleft license. Derivative and combined works must be published under the same license.
You can use BSD with GPL and then publish as GPL, but you can not publish as BSD.
I understand that the licenses are different. What I dont understand is why the BSD operating systems cannot make use of Asahi if it is GPL licensed instead of MIT licensed.
Because, as the comment you’re replying to says, if they include any GPL code, the whole combined work has to be licensed as GPL, and the BSD operating systems don’t want to be GPL.
Isn’t AI and already rendering those licenses moot? AI data sets don’t care what type of license the code it scraped caries. and probably most AI code being generated for private companies is based on non-permissive licenses. yet nothing can be done about it.
to look at it another way: since anything an llm spits out is public domain, whoever commanded it do so is automatically in breach of the gpl unless they can show evidence that there is no copyleft material in the training data at all.
Afaik that’s not exactly so. I recall articles saying that significant input/prompt may influence that. Whether this is true or not I can’t say.
I recall articles saying that significant input/prompt may influence that. Whether this is true or not I can’t say.
That’s not true. Until these issues have run through the courts, we won’t know what is or isn’t legal. The biggest court case I’m familiar with atm is the New York Times’ case that has yet to be resolved, and even then the ruling there will probably be too narrow to decide anything for code licensing. Hell, OpenAI/Microsoft might even settle to avoid a bad ruling, leaving all those questions unanswered.
So the Tl;Dr is that anyone using LLMs to code (in any capacity) is taking a risk, since the legality of it is still uncertain. It’s not outside the realm of possibility that some court will rule that LLMs trained on stolen data are illegal, and the outputs of those models are infringing.
can’t be. if there is gpled code in the training data, all code must be gpl since the model is one work. and since it can’t, that’s a breach.
Yeah, in theory. In practice, good luck proving it.
I hate seeing this kind of doomerism around AI discussions. A future where we have no rights is not inevitable.
We know for a fact that OpenAI, Anthropic, Google etc trained on GPL code. They haven’t claimed otherwise, and this isn’t something they’re trying to hide.
We also know what the various open source models were trained on, since they’re open source.
We can pass laws that require LLM providers to disclose their data set in some way, eg through independent audits. Trump is the one who didn’t want AI regulation, and he basically just lost all ability to make that a reality. The final six weeks of the pedophile congress isn’t likely to accomplish anything on that front, and even if they do, the incoming congress can reverse it.
This is the time to energize people, not complain on the internet.
I think the answer is “yes”.
This feels like a token response to a systemic unsolvable problem.
The article says itself talks about having models launder code so it can’t be considered a copy of the source.
If you can compare the code and it matches you probably have a good case if the AI user can’t demonstrate it’s not coming from you.
There’s different kinds of datasets. Some respect, select and disclose licenses, others do not.
Some model trainers use any data they can, others are selective on what they train on.
It can also be a decision on principle rather than current or future enforcability. If you say “don’t copy this” and someone blatantly does, the morality is clearer than if you didn’t specifically say that.
There’s also a question of how court rulings and law may change the situation of enforcability and usage/ignorance risk.
MIT requires attribution too. GPL is, at the very least, a stronger statement of intention and demand. It can also be seen as protest or indication of a broader move of corporate AI exploitation leading to damage to the whole FOSS ecosystem, with additional restrictions being applied. Corps that would use AI now can’t use the MIT product anymore like before.
First, you can’t even compare the code if you don’t have access to it, you don’t have access to google’s or facebook’s code.
Second who can even legally challenge entities with pockets as deep as the ocean.
Third courts will probably classify AI generated code based of non-permissive licenses as fair use, so It’s a lost cause anyway.
Nothing is set. Until there’s a challenge in court, all you stated as certainties are just conjectures.
I really don’t understand why someone would use a permissive license in the first place. Especially a project this big.
Permissive licenses are what everyone should strive toward. A world where we can share advancements and technologies freely with one another and innovate based on the prior work of others is a world where a shit load of cool stuff gets done. The issue arises when bad faith actors take advantage of it and act against the spirit of collaboration. The problem isn’t caused by the permissive license, but by the bad actor, and the latter is what should be addressed
A world where we can share advancements and technologies freely with one another and innovate based on the prior work of others is a world where a shit load of cool stuff gets done.
And how does a copyleft license get in the way of that? On the contrary, with the GPL, I can be sure that the technology and code will be freely shared. Freely as in freedom, that’s the whole point.
I misunderstood your initial point, I thought you were speaking against permissive/copyleft licenses generally. We agree with one another. Except in the “I can be sure that the technology and code will be freely shared” because just as bad actors can abuse a permissive license, bad actors (see: companies with enough money to just squash the legal case) can simply ignore a copyleft license. I think we 99% agree though and I love copyleft.
because just as bad actors can abuse a permissive license, bad actors
You are right, but with copyleft you at least have legal mechanisms to force the company to comply with the license. With MIT or BSD there aren’t any, because permissive licences don’t enforce any such restrictions.
I think we 99% agree though and I love copyleft.
Yup. And I love copyleft too.
Permissive is the opposite of copyleft. Permissive is “here’s my code, do whatever the fuck you want”, copyleft is “here’s my code, you may use it but if your derivative work is available to other people then I dictate how it must be licensed”
“Sad to see Asahi out there burning bridges for no reason… relicensing m1n1 and drivers under GPL2-or-later, seemingly without the consent of all prior contributors, under the guise of “defending against AI bad actors”, seems entirely disingenuous and misguided.”
“no reason” but there’s reasons anyway and those are “entirely disingenuous and misguided”
Too bad [their] twitter posts don’t go into actual arguments. Why is it supposedly disingenuous? Why misguided? Are there better alternatives? Probably not.
It would be interesting to see whether the BSD community finds a way to keep working with Asahi under the new terms.
They could go GPL too. :)
Asahi dual-licensing would be difficult, because then it’d be out there as MIT or BSD, which they don’t want. The BSD using custom-licensed parts - the BSD projects probably don’t want that.
In a perfect world we wouldn’t even need licenses, or just use BSD style ones, but alas… And thus moving to a copyleft license is the best move for sure.
AI bubble has shown that if you don’t have billions of dollars for lawyers, your IP will be copied and compressed into an LLM and you won’t be able to do anything about it, regardless of license. But at least Apple won’t be able to profit from Asahi team work and BSDs won’t be able to use drivers from Asahi. So much winning.
Apple is an asshole company, if they wanted community contribution for their drivers, they could’ve made their stuff open, now they can go fuck off, full stop











