Earlier today a vegan made a post with a white supremacist dog whistle by satirizing a person who’s people “have been eating dog for thousands of years”. Another Indigenous person and I did our best to call out the white supremacist nature of the discussion, so the poster later edited the title to specifically reference European people, which may have been well intentioned but only served to gaslight us by making it look like we were over-reacting and looking to be offended.
I came here for the leftism, and stayed for the Trans Rights. I’m a 2-spirit, native leftist. I have myriad reasons why I may or may not choose or even have the choice of veganism and any moralizing or condescension that comes from white vegans is an extension of over 500 years of an imposition of an alien value system which is profoundly disconnected from this land and the plants and animals which are our blood relations.
Bruh, I’m Mongolian, my entire culture is based on herding sheet and cattle. Our entire diet consists of meat, milk, cheese and the few wheat we can trade with the southerners. If we were to eat exclusively agricultural products then my culture will quite literally be annihiliated, but since according to these libs eating mutton is just as cruel as a viking blood eagles I guess that’s good.
It’s okay to kill things to eat their flesh even if it isn’t nutrionally necessary if it’s done in an idealistic pastoral way and you aren’t white because no other culture has ever had moral failings. Meat is an inherit part of literally every culture, white or not. It’s not unique.
I don’t know how unique this perspective is but I’m a white vegan who is fine with hunting. Like, I wouldn’t want to eat the meat but I don’t see any inherent problem with it. If part of someone’s spiritual connection to the land, something that I value greatly and view as sacred, is to hunt and fish then that’s ok with me. My ideal society would have animals being used in non degrading ways, grazing animals used to stimulate grasslands, goats to manage forests and shrublands, chickens to manage pests, and then harvesting their flesh to feed cats, dogs, and other animals important to human society. Hunting and fishing could be things, but only if people understand how fucking horrible poaching is.
But there is nothing spiritual about factory farming. Isn’t saying that meat is important to your culture without then clearly showing how the way meat is currently used benefits your community and enriches peoples life just comodifying it? Reducing a product that requires an extraordinary amount of labor down to it’s end product without taking care as to what that labor actually entails seems bad. I’m sure you don’t support factory farming, few people do, but I can’t help but view the opinions of people who eat KFC while talking about the importance of meat to their culture as hypocritical.
Like, if you know exactly where the meat is coming from, you know the abattoir, you know the conditions of the animals and you decide that it’s ok then sure, we have better things to worry about. But eating meat that consciously is difficult. And these sorts of conversations always seem to ignore the fact that myself, and many other vegans, view the dairy industries as worse than the meat industry. The only meat that approaches the cruelty of dairy farming is bullet caged pig farming, imo. Even in India where cows are viewed as a sacred animal they are just taken across the border to Bangladesh or Pakistan and slaughtered with extreme cruelty.
Indigenous perspectives are important to me so I at least hope that this comes across in good faith
Material conditions determine culture to a good amount. If we are facing a climate threat and a yet to be global communist revolution alters the face of the earth it isn’t unlikely that the consumption patterns will have to be shifted radically. What exactly the consequences would be might be utopist thinking, however the material reality of the inefficiency of most (especially industrial) meat production is evident. This however doesn’t mean to force “uncivilized” into submission, as would be white tradition.
I won’t exclude omnis; we all want to overthrow capitalism, and we can’t agree on everything
but well-being for all means animals too; killing and exploiting animal comrades is wrong for anyone and everyone. if your conditions mean you’ll actually die without some animal product, that’s pretty different. but yeah eventually veganism should be integrated into leftism, it’s just amending who the subjects of exploitation are
Animal comrades?
Orwell wrote a book about those…
I disagree with veganism being mandatory of a leftist vision. I’m not going to discuss meat consumption right now. I agree veganism is good in the current conditions that most of us live in, but I disagree with thei idealization of veganism outside the capitalist system.
Most visions of socialism in the modern era include a symbiotic relationship to the natural world, and that doesn’t need to stop with animals.
Having a pet and maintaining humane living conditions for them isn’t exploitation. At most, they may provide emotional labour, but they’re generally quite eager and happy with their compensation.
Now say that pet is a female chicken. It lays eggs. Do I have to leave those to rot? Throw them away? Can we not have sheep? Can we not shear their wool? What about goats and their milk?
These are all byproducts or surplusses of natural processes. If we live together in a commune with these animals, is utilising that surplus immoral?
Our biological processes are designed to work together to maintain an ecosystem. We may have dramatically reshaped that ecosystem, but when we remove the system that’s actively pushing us to destroy it, we can rekindle that connection to other lifeforms.
utilizing that surplus is immoral because there’s basically never a way to do it harmlessly
-here’s some of the cruelty involved in wool (CW animal abuse): https://youtu.be/dUnTyjBuxkk
-taking in rescue pets is a good thing, but producing pets through dog farms results in a lot of animals getting culled
-both goat dairy and cow dairy require animals to be constantly impregnated (r*ped) so they can produce milk, and calves are separated from their mothers which is horrifying
-even if you just mean backyard eggs, female chickens were bred to lay many times more than they would naturally, and as a result suffer from calcium deficiencies, which result in lots of broken bones
even under socialism, we would continue to selectively breed animals in ways harmful to their health, and there would always be an incentive to treat them only well enough to get a product out of them. we have to remove the idea of getting labor/products out animals, because if we allow that, it means many people will take in animals just for those products. it’s basically incentivizing mistreatment
Can we just all assume that if someone says to go Vegan there’s always an imaginary asterisk where it says:
*if you’re a white person who eats the standard American/European diet, and is not currently struggling to survive.
I’m sure >90% of the people upvoting this are not indigenous people. I’ll be perfectly honest, there are a lot of vegans who need to shut the fuck up specifically when they’re dealing with indigenous communities, and I’m not going to defend whatever was said to you. However, a lot of times “indigenous people though!” is just something “woke” white people say to use indigenous communities as a rhetorical cudgel to never reconsider their role in the suffering of animals. It comes very close to the sort of tumblr liberal ideas of “Karl Marx was a white man! Communism is a colonizer ideology.”
No we can’t “just assume it” because no one actually ever says or means that, and never includes it in their vegan scolding.
“Guys can’t we just assume I didn’t mean to be exclusionary and racist when I made my exclusionary and racist remarks?”
Cmon, you can’t just be snopes fact-checking Joe Biden about things. “Technically, that was said verbatim, but he obviously didn’t mean it like that” fuck off you have to say it if you want to make those points in a non-shitty way.
Okay. Go vegan if you’re an assimilated westerner who is not struggling financially. It is a good and morally correct thing to do if you do not have reasons you can’t.
Doesn’t fit in the emote though. :im-vegan:
Go vegan if you’re an assimilated westerner who is not struggling financially
I have a restrictive eating disorder and the last two times i tried to go vegan I ended up starving myself, thanks tho




