So, it seems like PieFed is becoming a real alternative to lemmy.
What are the differences between these two? From a tech perspective, and also morality/ethics, if you want. Any differences in vision for these services?
Say whatever is on your mind. I want to know.
On which one should we put our weight?
PieFed all the way. It’s developing at lightning speed, while Lemmy lags behind as the transphobic genocide denying devs beg for donations with in built donation begging banners on all Lemmy instances front pages. Instances are apparently scared to defed from .ml for fear the devs wont support them with help.
Rimu has made some interesting choices, such as blocking 196 from default federating posts until a user subs first or a dislike for meme subs. But when spoken to has been receptive and removed such things or made them optional for admins.
Ethically and feature wise PieFed is in the lead, its not perfect but its open to change and receptive to ideas
If anyone says it doesn’t matter, it does. Piefed will drop comments for multiple reasons, worst IMO is because someone has blocked someone or an instance, resulting in the entire instance (the blockers) being unable to see any reply from that person or instance to the blocker. An entire conversation can be happening, and you cannot see it. You cannot choose to see it, and unlike instance defederations where you can go to /instances and see which instances are blocked, you have no such way of knowing it.
Even worse, as far as I understand, if someone replies to a blocker in a community on the blockers instance, no other instance will know of the comment.
ⓘ This user is suspected of being a cat. Please report any suspicious behavior.
Yeah but tankies on Lemmy support censorship in the abstract, which is worse than concrete.
That is so amazingly abusable. You can basically be a one-person defederator with a single account on any instance. The devs of piefed are so smart.
It’s only replies to you that don’t show up. So you have to be a power poster too.
ⓘ This user is suspected of being a cat. Please report any suspicious behavior.
Ahahaha so it’s a reward for bots and extreme obsessives
It also makes it easier to coordinate downvoting on specific users and make it so they can’t keep contributing
Blocked users still being able to reply to your comments is very abusable too. I don’t like how blocks work in Lemmy either.
If we are talking about dealing with interpersonal abuse and not just blocking people who annoy you, I think the Piefed approach is a bit better even if it’s borked with federation.
Shouldn’t that just be mods’ responsibly? Banning someone personally abusive?
Which mods? Seems complicated across communities and instances.
Moderation is federated in Lemmy, when I take a look at communities in other instances I never see content from users that were banned over there. There can be cases where a moderator on an instance that isn’t federated with mine bans a user on an instance that is (e.g. lemmy.world mod bans lemmy.ml user) and I would still see that user’s posts, but in practice this doesn’t happen very much and isn’t very abusable.
The big problem with the piefed system is that it gives every user a sliver of mod powers when usually moderators are supposed to be vetted; it’s also frowned upon for a moderator to get into an argument then take mod actions against the user they were arguing with, but PieFed gives every user the power to partially ban whoever they’re talking with.
I think it’s ok if posters get a say in who can see and interact with their posts/comments.
It’s so easy to abuse it’s not even funny. You can be a power poster who replies to almost everything, block the people who disagree with you, and make it look like everyone on the site is on your side because no one ever disagrees.
Doesn’t seem like a huge problem to me.
I crave this herculean demi-mod status.
at the very least, your mods are able to ban them from your instance. i think it’s a lot less abusable to be able to designate people whose comments you personally can’t see than it is to designate people whose comments no one can see. at the very low end of what counts as abuse, i keep getting blocked by libs on reddit specifically so they can get the last word. it gives the appearance that they were so correct no one could come up with a response to their epic bacon comeback