Only Bayes Can Judge Me

  • 11 Posts
  • 601 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 4th, 2023

help-circle


  • Epistatus: I skimmed the first 20 pages of the paper. I have not watched the WoW documentary.

    Yeah, the paper doesn’t seem to do a good job at justifying introducing system 3. They should have at least looked at why you couldn’t model this as something like:

    1. Person encounters a situation requiring thought
    2. System 1 triggers System 2
    3. System 2 offloads cognition to some black box
    4. The result is absorbed and successfully addresses the situation
    5. A- System 1 is rewarded and begins adding use of the black box to its repertoire, skipping System 2

    or

    B- System 2 absorbs the result and begins trusting the black box more, perhaps deferring to its result before any internal cognition

    Both of these things I pulled outta my ass can explain deskilling, and a situation like 5a) might explain capitulating to AI under pressure. So I’m not feeling like System 3 is necessary here.

    That all being said, it’s not like the paper gets to decide how the rest of the world chooses to use “cognitive surrender”.