• 0 Posts
  • 3 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: September 8th, 2025

help-circle


  • A healthy newborn is also equipped with more than a dozen reflexes – ready-made reactions to certain stimuli that are important for its survival. It turns its head in the direction of something that brushes its cheek and then sucks whatever enters its mouth. It holds its breath when submerged in water. It grasps things placed in its hands so strongly it can nearly support its own weight. Perhaps most important, newborns come equipped with powerful learning mechanisms that allow them to change rapidly so they can interact increasingly effectively with their world, even if that world is unlike the one their distant ancestors faced.

    These are all examples of algorithms. There are very obvious differences between a brain and a computer but they both also have huge similarities, which is why the analogy is so easy and widespread. When we make an analogy we are not saying ‘X is Y’, we are saying that in some ways X seems like Y, and that is often enough for us to build a better understanding of one or both of those things.

    A plane is like a bird; both fly because their wings are shaped such that there is higher air pressure on the underside, but planes don’t flap their wings and they aren’t made of flesh. The analogy can be taken too far but that doesn’t mean that it isn’t useful within specific constraints.

    So you are right that a brain is not a computer, but that doesn’t mean that;

    1. the analogy can’t be useful to help us to understand either system
    2. a brain could not be fully simulated in a computer (I’m not saying it could, there may be fundamental reasons why it can’t, but the fact that they are made of different materials and process information in different ways is not sufficient)
    3. we could never read a memory from a brain (similar to 2, I’m not saying we definitely could, but it may be possible, and in fact there has been interesting work in reconstructing visible images and abstract ideas from brain scans of volunteers already)