JoeySteel [comrade/them]

  • 2 Posts
  • 9 Comments
Joined 6 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 2nd, 2020

help-circle
  • This is missing a material analysis though comrade

    If people as smart, dedicated and brave as Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Castro, Hoxha, Mugabe, Ortega, Sankara and Qadaffi and the hundreds of millions of brave people that followed them all ended up in roughly the same spot something bigger is at work than “this leader is authoritarian”

    What’s more unless we’re great man theorists then we understand that the masses sought leaders of men of steel with the caliber of the people mentioned above.

    If US imperialism collapses we can indeed walk into fully automated luxury communism (and thats presupposing another power doesn’t simply fill the power vacuum). But looking at Cuba, DPRK or China now who are all still on a perpetual wartime footing I think this is utopian.


  • I do find it funny when anti-authoritarians whine about revolutionary societies

    The initial act of revolution is about the most authoritarian thing you can do. It is quite literally one part of the population pointing guns at the other and telling them how society is to be structured

    And rarely has that conversation ended in the other side readily agreeing. Theyve ususlly taken up arms and defended their exploitative positions in society until they met their end at a noose, guillotine or summary execution or killed the revolutionaries and resumed their garbage redundant position as a Kinglord/merchant/capitalist/landlord /

    In fact most of the time…they have been willing to tear an entire country in two rather than relinquish their position.

    The second problem is assuming those that have been overthrown are going to accept the new society and not work hand in hand with foreign agents to restore theprevious social order


  • Red fascism came from anarchists who swallowed antiCommunist propaganda and believe communists = nazis

    The problem with this is that the Soviets led by Stalin saved the world from nazi fascism and made the largest contribution to the world in the fight against racism and national liberation movements worldwide

    If USSR lost world war 2 the post war period would be dominated by fascist Italy, Japan and a Nazi Germany with the resources and land of the USSR. There almost certainly would still be colonies as USSR played a pivotal role in destroying the British empire also (the Suez crisis for instance… Russian technical expertise was given to Egyptians in managing the Suez canal largely seen as the end of British empire)

    Like these motherfuckers think the same people who liberated Auschwitz and hunted nazis all over europe are the same because…reasons?

    I guess Anarchists will reply that the Soviets were authoritarian (as if there is another way to build and defend your revolution)

    But if there problem is with authoritarianism then why are anarchists not fash with a cool drawn @ ?

    Afterall anarchists, when they have come to power, have setup Dictatorships of the Proletariat in mahknos Ukraine and Catalonia where they had secret police, total monopoly on newspapers, banned newspapers that werent anarchist ones, own judiciary, summary executions for suspected counter-revolutionaries (and due to their aversion to prisons were more likely just to execute people) and labour camps ie. Gulags

    Under Mahknos Ukraine they even went as far to chain gang peasants for slave labour

    So if Communists should have to wear the albatross of the occasional human rights abuses (and they were occasional and much better than capitalist nations who let people freeze ito death in the streets then whine when some counter revolutionary gets a beating or thrown in prison) then why dont anarchists?

    Because communists say “we are going to create a dictatorship of the proletariat where workers own, control and dictate everything”

    Anarchists say they are against all hierarchy until they come to power and throw that in the trash along with their opposition to a Proletarian state and instead setup a smaller state with all the features of say USSR/Dprk/Cuba just without the centralisation of production and the military means to defend itself


  • Traitors all the way down, right?

    No one ever said a lot of the Communists that were shot over that period were brazen counter-revolutionaries that one day woke up and marched into the camp of counter-revolution.

    By holding onto bad ideas, bad theory and terrible analysis they walked step by slow step into open counter-revolution.

    Trotsky (and his followers) for instance did not believe at the time that the Soviet Union would last a day versus German Imperialism. This defeatism that coloured their outlook meant “given that the USSR will fall in a war we must make peace at any cost and Stalins path to confrontation will result in absolute disaster”.

    Can we, however, expect that the Soviet Union will come out of the coming great war without defeat? To this frankly posed question, we will answer as frankly: If the war should remain only a war, the defeat of the Soviet Union would be inevitable. In a technical, economic, and military sense, imperialism in incomparably more strong. If it is not paralyzed by revolution in the West, imperialism will sweep away the regime which issued from the October revolution.

    Trotsky, Revolution Betrayed (1936)

    This is what Trotskys followers believed. That the USSR would fall.

    The Moscow Trials were largely about the fact Trotsky and Tukhachevsky wanting to carve off a huge rump of the Soviet Union (Ukraine) to the Hitlerites for assistance in coming to power. They believed the USSR was going to be defeated anyway. Better to present the land Hitler had demanded in MeinKampf for Lebensraum (the Ukraine for its Oil fields).

    This is why even in 1939 Trotsky was writing about the “independence of Ukraine” despite the independence forces being bourgeois nationalists and fascists who would only in a few short years setup their own SS divisions and collaborate with Nazis under Nazi occupation. While the pro Communist part of the population was pro-Stalin

    Leon Trotsky, Independence of the Ukraine and Sectarian Muddleheads, https://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1939/07/ukraine.htm

    In the 1980s both Arch J Getty and (trotskyite) historian Pierre Broue discovered that a bloc was created in the USSR which Trotsky had denied his entire life

    “[The bloc] is organized. In it have entered the Zinovievites, the Sten-Lominadze group and the Trotskyites (former ‘[capitulators]’). The group of Safar. Tarkhkan has not formally entered yet – they stand on too extreme a position; they will enter in a very short time. – The declaration of Z. and K. concerning their enormous mistake in ’27 was made during negotiations with our people concerning the bloc, immediately before the exile of Z and K.” - Sedov to his father Trotsky

    Pierre Broue, The “Bloc” of the Oppositions against Stalin in the USSR in 1932, https://www.marxists.org/archive/broue/1980/01/bloc.html

    “It is clear, then, that Trotsky did have a clandestine organization inside the USSR in this period and that he maintained communication with it. It is equally clear that a united oppositional bloc was formed in 1932”

    (Getty, Origins of the Great Purges: The Soviet Communist Party Reconsidered, 1933-1938)

    “Stalin must be killed!” –Leon Sedov

    “Stalin… is crushing the country … Inplacable hatred is accumulating around him, and a terrible vengeance hangs over his head… An assassination attempt? It is possible that this regime… will ultimately suffer individual terror. One can add that it would be contrary to the laws of history that the gangsters in power not be subject to acts of vengeance…” –Leon Trotsky

    About the same time American historian Arch Getty was discovering that Trotsky had secretly sent letters to at least Radek, Sokol’nikov, Preobrazhenskii, Kollontai, and Litvinov. The first three had been Trotskyites before publicly recanting their views. Getty did not find the letters – only the certified mail receipts for them in the Trotsky Harvard Archive. Getty realized this meant that the Trotsky Archive has been ‘purged.’ These letters had been removed. Other materials had undoubtedly been purged as well.

    Therefore it has been well established by scholars by the mid-1980s that a Trotskyite-Zinovievite bloc did in fact exist and that it was formed in 1932 and that Zinoviev and Kamenev were personally involved. Sedov also foresaw the entry into the group of Safarov, who in any case had a group of his own.

    The reason the Soviet state came down on them like a ton of bricks was because they had moved into open killings like they did when they Assassinated Kirov.


  • Na the CPSU ruthlessly purged the government and armed forces of their fifth column. It’s wild to me that European country after European country collapsed in the face of Nazi aggression due to Nazi sympathisers creating a fifth column in France/Czechoslovakia/Poland/Norway and the Netherlands fell overnight in some cases. France lasted 6 weeks before the Vichy government were collaborating.

    But somehow the Soviets wouldn’t have had a fifth column susceptible to Nazism despite that form of fascism basically originating from the White Guardists and Black Hundreds who lynched jews and hated Communism and a lot of those White Guardists would still be in the Soviet military 20 years later on the eve of ww2

    But nah, lol, the Moscow trials were somehow “subjects of torture” despite the fact the trials of 37 and 38 knew they would face a firing squad (after all of the 36 trial were executed) so why would they lie?

    We know now that it took US military 18 months of torture to get some reliable information from a prisoner of war. Yet apparently the Soviets can torture a confession spanning hundreds of pages, admitting to some things they were charged with and denying others without leaving a physical mark on them as they were trials open to the worlds press and diplomats. All within a few days or weeks. Not to mention the Ambassador of the US, Joseph Davies (trained as a lawyer), would write extensively on the trials being legitimate after witnessing them with his own eyes (after hearing the rumours of them being show trials.)

    I’m not convinced most of them were some sort of traitors.

    The grandson of an officer who was executed in the purge and always had believed he was innocent read the transcript of his Grandfathers in 2000 as he was a Colonel in the Russian army and could be trusted to read it in the reading room. Which was classified under Kruschev and remained so until 2018 to the public. His Grandfather was linked to tukhachevsky. After reading theTranscript he came away convinced Tukhachevksy, his Grandfather and the rest of the officers were guilty.

    “My grandfather and Tukhachevsky were friends. And grandfather was on the judicial panel that judged both Tukhachevsky and Eideman. My interest in this case became even stronger after the well-known publications of procuror Viktorov, who wrote that Iakov Alksnis was very active at the trial, harrassed the accused. . . . But in the trial transcript everything was just the opposite. Grandfather only asked two or three questions during the entire trial. But the strangest thing is the behavior of the accused. Newspaper accounts claim that all the defendants denied their guilt completely. But according to the transcript they fully admitted their guilt. I realize that an admission of guilt itself can be the result of torture. But in the transcript it was something else entirely: a huge amount of detail, long dialogues, accusations of one another, a mass of precision. It’s simply impossible to stage-manage something like this. . . . I know nothing about the nature of the conspiracy. But of the fact that there really did exist a conspiracy within the Red Army and that Tukhachevsky participated in it I am completely convinced today.”

    –Colonel Alksnis (Elementy, 2000)

    My conviction that Tukhachevsky and his colleagues were simply forced to incriminate themselves under torture was seriously shaken, because judging by the transcript, they gave their testimonies quite sincerely. After reviewing the transcript of the process, I came to the conclusion that there was still a “military conspiracy”, or something like that, in the Red Army.

    https://diplomaticpost.co.uk/index.php/2020/07/15/the-moscow-trials-colonel-viktor-alksnis-read-the-tukhachevsky-transcript-and-came-away-convinced-he-was-guilty/



  • If you believe that the Moscow Trials were a hoax then sure

    In reality they were all guilty of the crimes charged against them.

    When Kirov was assassinated in 1934 by Leonid the NKVD uncovered a wide ranging conspiracy to murder the Soviet leadership.

    We’re 80+ years from that event and bourgeois historians told the West nonstop for those 8 decades that Stalin killed Kirov to justify the crackdown on the opposition.

    Because Kirovs assassin in custody gave up a circle of names in terrorist organisations and then those terrorists gave up ever more names.

    If Stalin had Kirov killed then it shows the entire thing from the onset was a setup to justify the ensuing “Show Trials”

    We’re 80 years from those events and there has been 3 studies on the Kirov assasination,

    By Kirilina, Lenoe and Grover Furr.

    2 of them are bourgeois historians and come to the conclusion that Kirov was murdered by a “lone gunman” whilst Furr tears apart both their studies to show how disingenous their work is and shows how he was connected to a Trotskyite-Zinovieite bloc that show it was a bloc dedicated to assassinating the Soviet leadership

    What’s more, reading Lenoes study he spends 15 pages saying how much he hates socialism, hates stalin and hates the Soviets before stating his conclusion in the introduction (that Kirov wasn’t killed by Stalin).

    Because he knew that this tore down a key piece of Western propaganda against the Soviet Union, Stalin and socialism - that Kirov was genuinely assassinated and not murdered to justify the so-called “show trials”

    Trotsky immediately pens a an article saying Stalin had Kirov killed and was such a monster he was a pall bearer at his funeral. IE. Stalin was such a ruthless killer he’d murder you then carry your coffin to the grave.

    So we know Trotsky lied about Kirov and we know he lied about setting up an illegal bloc

    In the year 2000, Tukhachevskys grandson (now a colonel in the Russian army) was granted access to the Tukhachevsky trial transcript that was made confidential under Kruschev and remained confidential to the wider public until 2018.

    Tukhachevskys grandson was raised as an anti-Stalinist (and why not? Soviet leadership had his grandfather shot!).

    He read the transcript and came away convinced his grandfather had been part of a conspiracy.

    https://diplomaticpost.co.uk/index.php/2020/07/15/the-moscow-trials-colonel-viktor-alksnis-read-the-tukhachevsky-transcript-and-came-away-convinced-he-was-guilty/

    In hindsight it all makes sense. Why would they be “show trials” when they were trials opened to the worlds press. The American ambassador at the time (trained as a lawyer) believed the trials were authentic.

    People seem to forget the trials happened in the years preceding World War 2 when pretty much every government in Europe fell within days or weeks due to amazing Nazi foreign policy of building fifth columns inside countries.

    There were many in the Soviet Union that would rather have ceded massive amounts of land to the Nazis in fear of war (particularly Ukraine which Hitler had already specifically mentioned he wanted for German ‘Lebensraum’ as well as the oil deposits).