• whaleross@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    8 days ago

    I mean, I enjoy C&H comics that are intentionally offensive, but some are just recycled old jokes that don’t provoke or question but only affirm stale stereotypes.

    This is one of them. I wish they had gone with my version above because that would be more in line with pushing limits.

      • 🍉 DrRedOctopus 🐙🍉@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        8 days ago

        there’s a difference between dark humor and “pedophilia is funny”.

        dark rape jokes are fine like “it isn’t rape, it’s surprise sex”, “that dump truck puts the ass in sexual assault”.

        • RustyNova@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          7 days ago

          But the joke isn’t that “pedophilia is funny”? If the comic was cut to the first three panels, that wouldn’t be funny.

          The joke is that it isn’t the teacher that broke his arm as initially thought, but that his peers high fived him so many times for getting laid that it broke it. It’s the subversion of the expectation that is funny, despite being a horrible thing to laugh at.

    • craftrabbit@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      8 days ago

      I didn’t understand what the comic is about and now that I read your comment I’m starting to feel good about that

    • This is a thing that comes up whenever this specific comic appears.

      I’ll say something similar to what I have before, so excuse me if you’ve run across it.

      I think that taking this comic as a rape joke misses the layers it has, and thus the real point of it.

      The comic never says that the rape of a young boy by his teacher is a good thing. To the contrary, he’s in pain from other people doing the very thing that makes it so difficult for boys and men that have been sexually abused to have a real support network when they need it most.

      His arm is broken because of the very cultural problem surrounding the abuse of boys, specifically when perpetrated by women.

      Note also that the adult in the comic doesn’t engage in the same harmful congratulatory cycle, and assumes the harm occurred during the abuse, which is what we want adults to do, assume that the abuse is as harmful as it actually is.

      Now, you might think I’m giving undue credit, but c&h has a fairly reliable history of sneaking in serious commentary via dark humor. They’ve dealt with issues of mortality broadly, and in ways that indicate that the creators do indeed craft their humor with thought and nuance.

      If the argument is that joking about rape ia inherently bad, I very much disagree on the basis that well executed humor can shift minds in ways that all the essays in the world can’t.

      If it’s an argument that joking about rape at all is bad, I again disagree on the basis that no subject matter is, nor should it be, off limits entirely. That does leave us having to judge each attempt on it’s own merits, but I’m okay with that.

      But, if the argument is that this comic ia actually a rape joke, using the cultural flaw of unbalanced approaches to abuse perpetrated by women on boys and men, then I feel that that argument misses the entire point of the comic.