Very good analysis vid on what Team RWBY does wrong throughout the series. Their points are quite compelling.
Oh, I remember this one. It’s an older video, isn’t it?
I still like Judgemental Critter and will dip into her content semi-regularly (I especially like her videos on character designs) even if I occasionally have issues with the conclusions she draws; tho TBQH it’s good that I can find issues with her arguments and not follow blindly along 100% of the time. A lot of the fandom seems to take umbrage with her critiques such as this very one, tho, to the point where her vids/posts were basically banned on the big r/RWBY subreddit.
As to the video itself, yeah, from what I remember she raises a lot of valid points. Rewatching V6 in particular is kinda painful nowadays because they go from “well, they won’t let us in the front door” to “let’s commit a federal crime” like they were speedrunning treason. Early volume fights vs. the White Fang are cringe-inducing but I think Unicorn of War covered that topic much better and more thoroughly (it’s actually what opened my eyes to that whole debacle). I forget what all else she brings up.
Those kinds of things are why I tend to consider the RWBY writers as like first-time fanfic writers except that RWBY is this whole fully-produced fanfic right out the gate. It’s the kind of plot beats that what I would expect out of somebody who doesn’t think about what they’re writing and just wants to put it out on the internet.
the RWBY writers as like first-time fanfic writers except that RWBY is this whole fully-produced fanfic
Holy fuck that’s so true.
Honestly I found the video itself quite interesting, since Volumes 7 and 8 are probably the best volumes since 1,2, and 3, but this and the RandyBoyJr video on 1,2,3 have me considering what I liked about the series. I don’t often do critical analysis on stuff which I’d say is my biggest flaw, I just like to enjoy things without thinking about it too hard unless something obvious sticks out to me. Not to mention my opinions on things are often kinda dumb and oft unfounded lol.
I’ve spent a LOT of time over the years consuming critical media analysis, but one of the boxes that I tick in the autistic spectrum is that I’ve hardly been able to do more than parrot the exact lines of people I’ve listened to. I’ve gotten better in recent years, but the absolute travesty is that RWBY was perfect for me as someone who cannot analyze a show while in the middle of watching and worse than that, I tend to forget about anything that’s not right in front of my face. All the plot holes in RWBY never occurred to me without someone else pointing them out to me.
Like, if I can mount a slight defense of myself, endings are paramount to a show and RWBY… has none. Like, I wasn’t prepared to actually analyze it as a whole until it ended. I did step away at various times because it got to be a bigger and bigger time investment without an ending, but I never actually thought critically about it until finally stepping into the fandom… I guess 2 years and change now? It was when news of RT’s shutdown filtered down to me.
I’ve hardly been able to do more than parrot the exact lines of people I’ve listened to
Mood and same. I have no originality lol. I try to critically analyze things without seeing what other people have said for things I genuinely want to critique or learn from, but a lot of times I don’t have the energy or time or desire to do that for long media, because I lowkey need to consume it multiple times to keep track of everything and understand it in my head (。>﹏<。)
The lack of a proper ending for RWBY is hurtful, yeah. It’s a shame they weren’t able to leave things off in a good, well rounded ending, but idk if it would have been better to rush an ending that ties all the loose ends sloppily. I think Korra more or less suffered from the same thing each season; they kept not knowing if they would be greenlit for more seasons so they kind of had to make each season have a solid enough ending, or so I’ve heard, not sure if that’s true or not (me parroting just now).
To do proper in-depth analysis, yeah, it’s best to rewatch a series several times (preferably taking notes if you want to actually debate your stance), but usually what I’m doing is giving my impressions in a couple of paragraphs after I’ve finished a show or game the first time.
Occasionally, I’ve re-watched an anime subbed instead of dubbed (or vice-versa) when I didn’t know what to make of it, like with Domestic Girlfriend or Monster Musume, or if I’m still really unsure, go to the source manga to try and figure it out (as happened with Highschool of the Dead). Rarely, I’ll even get into some disagreement or discussion that compels me to deep-dive into a show that I don’t actually love because someone is making a hard-to-believe claim like “the manga fixes all the issues the anime had” (e.g. Akame Ga Kill! (and, personal opinion: the anime ending was much better as most characters get better sendoffs and it cuts out a kind of terrible arc at the end (incidentally, I’m half-planning an adaptation of sorts because putting RWBY characters in an Akame situation would fit perfectly))).
====
I’ve heard the same about Korra, I still need to go watch it one day.
====
It is unfortunate that RWBY still doesn’t have an ending (and I fully expect them to plan out 3 more volumes in Vacuo – whether or not they get 3 volumes remains to be seen) but I think they shot too wide after the V3 finale. That and they hardly know how to wrap up a season. There was a discussion that popped up a while back that V9 is “filler” and I’m inclined to agree because the plot was 110% put on hold so RWBY (and Jaune for no damn reason) could have a little side-adventure in Neverland.
Like, V9 took an entire extra year because they were struggling to get approved and that’s what they decided to do with it?
(e.g. Akame Ga Kill! (and, personal opinion: the anime ending was much better
Fucking thank you! I completely agree, yet all the discourse I see online talks the manga up like it’s God’s gift to weebs. The anime was so much better.
All of V9 is filler. Nothing that happens in that entire volume is conducive to the story at large besides character development which should have been done throughout the series and in the real world. Genuinely nothing changes because they went to the never after or whatever. The only real notable change is that Blake and Yang are dating now, which imo they didn’t build up enough and anyways they completely fumbled the entire dynamic. I’m fairly certain there’s a moment (or more) where the two more or less state that there doesn’t need to be one protecting the other or anything, or something to that effect, yet V9 has a scene where Blake literally hides behind Yang. Fuck that, give me my V1-3 aura farming ninja cat back. Ruby randomly develops this “I’m a terrible leader and huntress” mindset in the volume itself (whether she actually is or not is an entirely different story) which is resolved at the end of the volume putting her right back to square 1 ig. Same goes for Weiss.
The more I think about it, the less depth these characters have, holee fuck. The most interesting dynamics were neutered in favor of consumer appeal. Remember when Weiss hated Ruby for being a shit leader and was also a racist, and when Blake was secretly a faunus and also a white fang member? That was interesting! But instead of having Sokka 2 frozen boogaloo she just… stops being racist? why again? Instead of having layers of intrigue with Blake being a member of the resistance it’s just “I don’t like my ex and his ideals so fuck the entire white fang.” Instead of Weiss holding Ruby accountable for being a shit leader and constantly on her ass for every little fuck up she gets told to shut the fuck up by Port and she just… does? Gah!
Fucking thank you! I completely agree, yet all the discourse I see online talks the manga up like it’s God’s gift to weebs. The anime was so much better.
Cards on the table, I think even the Akame anime is forgettable in the extreme, but I am convinced that the reaction is because people can’t handle an ending that isn’t “happily ever after” in much the same way so many people have issues separating fictional characters from real people (e.g. all the hate Jax gets from Digital Circus).
The only real notable change is that Blake and Yang are dating now, which imo they didn’t build up enough and anyways they completely fumbled the entire dynamic.
Eyy ヘ( ^o^)ノ\(^_^ )
This is a really impractical recommendation, but if you have like 30 hours to burn check out the first 10 or so Team JYCT streams from Celtic Phoenix – they (Judgemental Critter, Celtic Phoenix who’s behind the Fixing RWBY series, Kaiser Shounen who’s also in the RWBY critics sphere and has some good videos, and a friend of theirs called Twilight Guardian) went through the entire series looking at anything that could have been considered a “Bumbleby moment” to see how well it holds up as a romance and the conclusion, obviously, is that it basically didn’t exist until V6 and then it was fumbled hard. Like, the Ponderstorm episode basically held them at gunpoint to make them kiss.
Ruby randomly develops this “I’m a terrible leader and huntress” mindset in the volume itself (whether she actually is or not is an entirely different story) which is resolved at the end of the volume putting her right back to square 1 ig. Same goes for Weiss.
Yeah, a critique I’ve heard more than once is that V9 feels like it’s written in direct response to criticisms people have raised about the characters, like how “Blake and Yang haven’t actually kissed” and “Ruby hasn’t had any development since V1”. The Curious Cat even knocks on the fourth wall by asking “Whatever happened to that Ciel girl?”
The more I think about it, the less depth these characters have, holee fuck.
Yeeeaaahh, they’re really just paper dolls when you get down to it. The phrase “wide as an ocean, deep as a puddle” applies to all of RWBY, but sometimes it’s fun to splash in puddles, you know? That’s why they’ve become my blorbos, I think. I recognize that they’re a whole lot of nothing but that means I can play around with them ad infinitum without it feeling “off”.
Like, I hope the deeper examination isn’t turning you off because while RWBY does have A LOT of flaws (to the point it’s almost more interesting examining what it does wrong), that doesn’t have to mean throwing your toys away. The fandom at large has a problem of toxic positivity and either never addressing its issues or thinking these critiques are attacks on the people who like it, but most of the best fanworks I’ve seen have come from people who see the flaws and want to fix them because they still love the world and characters.
Re: Akame Ga Kill. I mean a lot of media can be forgettable but still really enjoyable, but fair. About people’s reactions, I have no other theory to contrast that and tbh it’s quite reasonable. I know the time frames don’t line up but it feels like the manga took a lot of things the anime did and turned it to 11 for the sake of outdoing itself. The giant robot in the anime was just a giant robot, but we don’t even get to see it be a giant robot in the manga, we’re just told “hey this robot is strong” and then it gets eldritchified and we’re told it’s even stronger now. Like, one punch man ok meme. Esdeath goes from being strong in the anime to just overly ridiculously strong to the point where she can create entire armies on her own. Like tf??
Re: Bumblebee (is it bumblebee or bumbleby?). Thanks for the recommendation! I’ll check it out next time I need something to listen to passively or on long drives. And yeah there’s jack shit for Bumblebee in the show, it’s so bad and forced.
I hope the deeper examination isn’t turning you off
You’re telling this to a homestuck enjoyer. I love splashing in puddles too, some of my favorite media isnt all that deep (HS, Overlord, OPM). I do really enjoy RWBY despite its flaws, and in their defense they do well enough for a “turn your brain off and enjoy the jingling keys” show. Besides, I’m currently writing a whole fanfiction about it lol.

