In 2017, the British Marxist scholars Robert Fine and Philip Spencer warned of “the return of the Jewish question.” A decade later, that warning looks remarkably prescient. Across the ideological spectrum, we are witnessing the resurgence of a political logic that casts Jewish collective existence as an obstacle to human emancipation.
…
As at previous historical junctures, anti-Judaism functions today as a kind of political superglue, binding otherwise fragmented camps within the left and the right. More telling still, elements of the far left and the far right increasingly echo one another. As left-wing media personality Cenk Uygur recently told his right-wing nationalist “brother” Tucker Carlson: “I also want to break down the barriers of Republicans and Democrats, right-wing versus left-wing … I think it has been used to divide us.” Anti-Jewish tropes thus construct a bridge across ideological extremes.
…
But Heine rejected the idea that a future utopia could miraculously redeem the present and espoused a politics of moderation and reform informed by Jewish moral philosophy. In his Confessions, he presented Mosaic law as a realistic form of socialism. “Moses,” he wrote, “did not wish to abolish property; rather, he wanted everyone to possess it, so that no one, through poverty, might become a servant with a servile disposition. Freedom was always the ultimate thought of the great emancipator.”
…
On the left, Jews are once again cast as a force of reaction, linked to capitalism, imperialism, and racism. For example, left-wing historian Enzo Traverso, in his 2016 book The End of Jewish Modernity, argues that Judaism has moved from revolution to reaction. Trotsky, the “Jew as revolutionary,” Traverso argues, has been supplanted by Kissinger, “the Jew as imperialist.” This supposed shift produces a new political myth. Traverso concedes that Jews were never uniformly revolutionary, but doesn’t ask why they, alone among nations, should be expected to be. The urge to essentialize proves too strong. He thus assigns a fixed political value to an entire people—the one that has been essentialized with such tragic consequences.

