Ahoy, y’all!

I’ve been meaning to make a post like this for some time.

Ever since this post I’ve been thinking about the governance structure on dbzer0 more and more. I’ve had some good discussions about the current governance model in that post, and I’ve also read other’s perspectives with interest. For those interested, here are the threads I’m referring to:

This week, I finally found some time to write about my thoughts in the hope that it could start a larger discussion about how we could improve the way decisions are made on this instance.

In the mentioned post, the general sentiment is in favor of defederating from (by far) the largest German Lemmy instance.

One comment stuck out to me: https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/comment/24355698

u/ggtdbz mentions how they are directly affected by zionism, but are against the decision. Importantly, they make an alternate proposal: a 3 or 5 strikes system, but keep feddit.org federated, so that the (heavily propagandized) German users are still exposed to anti-zionist thoughts, and will not be able to consider theirs the default position on the subject. Many people upvoted.

Nothing further happened. There was no response by the OP, no governance proposal, no extending the timeframe of the vote.

Now I understand that someone probably should’ve made a governance post about this proposal, however, to my knowledge, noone in the mentioned threads had the voting privileges to do that. This structure is mostly opaque to me (and most other users, I think), which is one of the issues I see with it.

This brings me to another thing I noticed in these proposal threads: many don’t seem to know how the voting system works. It isn’t explained on the post itself, and isn’t very legible either when people vote. As I understand it from this post, there’re different voting classes, depending on if/how much a user donates to the db0 admins. But do their votes get more/less weight? These also give users a different reply image from the bot as the vote is recorded, showing either the voting class or what they said in their registration message. It explains that users who actually have a vote are paying users, mods, and select users who were vouched for by a paying user, mod, or another vouched-for user. Looking through the previous votes I could find 8 users who have been vouched for (and participated in a vote) so far.

Now I don’t think this process was deliberated on by anyone outside the admin team who created it. I remember a few posts about the software to set this up being in development, and a post to announce its release, but none discussing just the structure of it. Please correct me if I’m wrong on this.

The proposal vote posts typically ask for a 2/3 majority from db0 users (outside sentiment is recorded, but doesn’t count for anything). Here also, I don’t recall any discussion about what percentage should be aimed at (although I think a weak consensus is a good idea, be that 2/3 or something else). Votes by regular members (not a mod/admin, paying user, or vouched-for) are used as a tie-breaker, although the exact mechanics seem to be more complicated.

There is de facto no discussion process that precedes or leads to proposals, and no method to amend existing proposals before or after a vote is called (see example above). There is a governance post type called “sense-check”, which looks like it’s intended for discussions prior to voting, but in practice it has been used exactly once for this purpose, on the only governance topic that wasn’t opened by u/Flatworm7591.

This is why I would classify this voting process as majority voting, as opposed to consensus voting. A majority vote in my understanding would be a simple vote that asks a yes/no question and passes if a certain size majority says yes, regardless of any other factors (strength of agreement, strength of disagreement, amendments, counterproposals, etc.) and requires no prior discussion by those affected. I think this is a charitable interpretation though, considering the relatively small pool of users who have actual voting rights.

Now after laying out my understanding of the existing structure, I’d like to propose two approaches.

First approach, a consensus vote:

A consensus vote would be one that follows the model: Discussion -> idea-collecting -> proposal -> amendment/counterproposal -> vote -> implementation or similar, that also takes into account strength of (dis)agreements (for anything other than full consensus) and abstain/stand-aside votes.

To avoid the issue of the one sense-check post we’ve had, which is that it wasn’t ever voted on, I think an important addition is that discussions must end in a proposal that is then voted on, even if the proposal is “change nothing”.

For this consensus approach, a harm to the community would first need to be identified (there are of course other reasons to make decisions, but I’m going to focus on grievances for simplicity). Then, someone creates a discussion post on the governance community to discuss what this harm is and what is causing it. Once the harm is understood, solutions can be discussed. This could be done by first collecting ideas and then trying to merge them into a proposal or choose the most popular ideas out of the lot. Once a proposal was formulated, people can voice disagreements with it so that everyone can think about amendments that could resolve those disagreements. Once all or the most major disagreements have been resolved, the proposal can be put to a vote.

Next, I want to talk about voting classes. I understand the inherent issues that come with online spaces like these, that any meaningful power given to the users can theoretically be abused by bots/bad actors, but I think it’s an issue that only 8 users were vouched for, and the rest paid for their right. Vouching should be far more prevalent IMHO, or this place will still be run by a very small minority.

This approach is not intended as “Do this thing now and do it exactly as I tell you to”. I’m sharing my thoughts on this in the hopes to start a discussion about possible alternatives/reforms. This approach is largely influenced by my reading on consensus systems and experience using consensus methods in IRL organizing spaces. Books/articles I’ve read on this that I found useful are: “Consensus” by Peter Gelderloos, “Consensus Decision Making” by seedsforchange.uk, and the Apache voting process.

Second approach, maximal autonomy:

This is one I am leaning towards a lot. The question I asked myself was “How would anarchists solve the problem of who to defederate from the best?” In governance votes about defederation there seem to be three major tendencies:

Those who want to:

  1. defederate from problematic groups
  2. federate, to keep these problematic groups exposed to radical ideas.
  3. use personal blocklists to “defederate” and only actually defederate from groups like, for example, exploding-heads.com, skinheads.io, etc.

I think 2 and 3 aren’t mutually exclusive. However 1 is incompatible with 2 and 3.

My proposal for those who find themselves in group 2 or 3 is to find/create an instance that defederates no instances you wouldn’t also add to your personal blocklist. Then, rely on that blocklist and your own judgement. Since personal blocking only affects yourself, it doesn’t raise the issue of having to make collective decisions on these topics.

A few Lemmy instances that defederate sparingly do exist, and rely heavily on users who create local blocklists as they feel the need to.

Perhaps someone could even create one that joins the FHF federation we got going on here.

Perhaps we could create shared blocklists that we curate, FOSS-style.

But the basic idea is to use blocklists to cut out the middle-person, the instance admins.

Naturally, this would still depend on moderation being done by admins, but I think having the least responsibility (and reliance) on admins as possible is the way to go, even if it cannot be fully removed.

This would also leave those in group 1 to make decisions with people who already have similar views, making decisions easier, and hopefully, strenghthening their consensus.

Finally

I hope I made some people think, and I hope we can have a healthy discussion about this in the comments, if people are interested.

Sorry for the long (and rambly) post, this has been on my mind for a few months now and it all had to come out at once :3

EDIT: To clear up some confusion I seem to have caused: The two “approaches” are not supposed to be mutually exclusive. I think we can and should consider both at once.

I also wrote a lot about instance defederations in this post, but I wanted to focus on how we make decisions broadly, not how we can handle (de)federation only.

  • db0@lemmy.dbzer0.comM
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    7 months ago

    Generally any attempts to restructure decision-making need to be also counter-balanced against the realities of running a social media and the fact that people are here for the social media, and not for the decision-making. I.e. introduce too many discussions and processes and you end up with people checked-out from the whole process due to “voting fatigue”. We’ve tried to structure our decision-making process in a way that tries to make it as smooth as possible within the confines of the lemmy software and doesn’t require endless rehashing.

    Yes a consensus vote is superior to majority vote, but I think it’s just not feasible with 1K+ Monthly active users. Even the discussions in the current voting threads become almost unmanageable. Consensus is great if we could organize the FAF around small instances based around affinity groups, where each affinity group would do a consensus process and bring the results to a larger confederation decision making, but the realities of webhosting and alienation make this practically impossible. But it’s nevertheless what we’ve been trying to soft promote with the FAF itself.

    Yes vouching should be more common, but at the same time, it’s not easy to understand who someone is from online comments, and fascists, entryists and wreckers are really fucking good at pretending just long enough to get such approvals, so I understand people being cautious. And the other part is that people just don’t bother to understand how to vouch for others.

    Second approach, maximal autonomy:

    This is just not a practical approach, especially in a very hostile online space, inundated with fascists, bigots, and so on. A lot of people join our instance because they don’t want to take the immense amount of effort needed to curate each and every interaction reactively. A lot of people want to just join an instance and use the threadiverse without having to worry about encountering, say, genocide apologists in every discussion. Is there space for such “manage your own blocklist” instances? Sure, there’s already plenty of them out there such as lemmy.zip and many people flock to them for precisely that reason. But not every instance has to work in that way and we choose not to.

    And shared blocklists are effectively the same thing we’re doing right now, only with more steps in between. Instead of trusting the admins of your instance, you’re now implicitly trusting the blocklist curators instead.

    • rivvvver@lemmy.dbzer0.comOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      edit-2
      7 months ago

      thanks a lot for the reply.

      yea, online decision-making is tough to handle, and theres a lotta issues stemming from the anonymity aspect alone. so i understand that my first idea is likely very difficult to implement fully and would cost those involved in it a lot of energy as well.

      the way u spoke about “voting-fatigue” makes me wonder tho, wouldnt we already have that?

      i know i definitely have long discussions in every voting poll, where new ideas come up that possibly werent considered as options. so this is already kind of happening, but bc of the structure that is used, the discussion is effectively worthless. so i think theres definitely enough energy there to have that discussion first, then follow it with a vote on a (now more thought-out) proposal. at the very least, it should make it easier for Flatworm to understand the “against” side more, which seems to have been a difficulty in past voting posts.

      Instead of trusting the admins of your instance, you’re now implicitly trusting the blocklist curators instead.

      theres a fundamental difference, tho: i can override the blocklist. i could make my own patches to it, but still keep the list updated. also, i could opt in/out at will without changing to a different instance with a different community and rules and governance.

      • db0@lemmy.dbzer0.comM
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        7 months ago

        I think you have a misapprehension about how our decision making works. Specifically, just because a vote is taken and goes one way at one moment in time, doesn’t mean we cannot open another vote, or amendment about the same subject later on. You also don’t need to wait for unruffled to make governance posts. Any person who can vote, can open governance posts.

        theres a fundamental difference, tho: i can override the blocklist. i could make my own patches to it, but still keep the list updated. also, i could opt in/out at will without changing to a different instance with a different community and rules and governance.

        Assuming the software handling the blocklist allows this. Likewise there could be threadiverse software that allowed soft defederation and people overriding it, but nobody built this yet. Anymore than they’ve build this shared blocklist format you imagine.

        Anyway, this tells me you effectively want to run your own instance, without running your own instance. But as I said, there’s instances that allow you to do that. Ours isn’t meant to work this way.

  • Azzu@lemmy.dbzer0.com
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    7 months ago

    I mean it’s pretty clear from how it’s setup that it’s not supposed to be a “proper” democratic system. Like you correctly identified, only a few select people even have voting powers, mostly by who pays and there’s no other clear way to get voting powers except to be friends with the admins.

    This is not an instance “by the people”, it’s just a tiny bit more transparent than others where the admins can and do just literally whatever they want. Power over the instance is a little bit more distributed. But it just being “a little bit”, it’s the same as any other instance: if you agree with the “ruling class”, fine, if not, switch instance to one you agree with.

    Your suggestions are partially nice but I don’t suspect their base goal is even wanted.

    • rivvvver@lemmy.dbzer0.comOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      edit-2
      7 months ago

      i mostly agree but i think it could be a lot clearer how it works.

      for the first few votes, i legit thought my vote counted like everybody elses. the bot response of “wildebeest image” was not helpful in clearing this up. a small note such as “u do not have voting rights, but ur vote will count as +0.01 votes instead” would be a good start.

      Your suggestions are partially nice but I don’t suspect their base goal is even wanted.

      i think the base goal is wanted, its just difficult to fully achieve, which is why i think it hasnt been done. full consensus is basically impossible, but weak consensus like 80-90% is totally doable imo if we simply used a process based on “discussion, then voting”, with a broader range of eligible-to-vote users.

      but this is an anarchist instance run by (mostly?) anarchists, i have no doubts about their base goals being pro-consensus.

      • Azzu@lemmy.dbzer0.com
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        edit-2
        7 months ago

        It’s kind of their goal, but consensus only among anarchists. They don’t want anyone not aligned with their agenda to vote, which is understandable, obviously you’d not want 60% fascists voting on something. But because of this, it’s not consensus like you want it (among the userbase) because they can’t know what the userbases agenda is. In society, as well as online, true anarchists are in the minority, and thus any vote system opened up to the majority would result in it not being like they want it anymore.

        On a kinda unrelated sidenote, my main problem is more that some hostile actor with like 100$/month to spare and a couple IP adresses and maybe some AI bots could make like 20 legitimate-looking accounts each donating 5$/month to gain a large share of voting rights, a relatively easy thing to do.

        • rivvvver@lemmy.dbzer0.comOP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          7 months ago

          hmmm i disagree with that sentiment. idk about the beliefs of dbzer0 admins, but as an anarchist myself, i would welcome any consensus, even among fascists.

          once theres a decision-making process that includes everyones perspective and considers everyones needs, idgaf what u call urself and what ur affiliations are.

          ofc i will likely disagree with the decisions a bunch of fascists make, but hey, at least theyre deciding anarchistically and i can bring my criticisms to the table and be heard (and for full consensus, they have to hear me out, too).

          in online spaces, it just gets impossible to organize such full consensus, as well as ensure everyone is also a user and not just a malicious actor who wants to fuck everyone over.

            • rivvvver@lemmy.dbzer0.comOP
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              0
              ·
              7 months ago

              consensus meaning consensus decision-making process in this context, in case u got confused.

              so yes, i want to tear down all hierarchies. and if my local racist conservative uncles already organize something anti-hierarchically, itll at least make it easier to convince them of my beliefs.

              • Salamence@mander.xyz
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                7 months ago

                and if my local racist conservative uncles already organize something anti-hierarchically, itll at least make it easier to convince them of my beliefs.

                Racist arent anti-hierarchy, they literally believe in racial hierchy, its in the name